Topics

Indigenous health

Indigenous health Prevention and Promotion May 2009 Free

Improving Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander nutrition and health

Economic interventions to improve access to healthy food Poor nutrition is a major determinant of excess morbidity and mortality among Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples,1 contributing to over 16% of the burden of disease.2 In this issue of the Journal (page 549), consistent with the “economics of food choice” theory,3 Brimblecombe and O’Dea report that the diet of a remote Aboriginal community was high in energy-dense, nutrient-poor foods — the cheapest options to satisfy hunger.4 This energy–cost differential restricts access to healthy food, and helps explain the persistently poor dietary patterns and deplorable health status of remote Indigenous communities.4 Placing nutrition issues in an economic framework highlights the investment required to improve Indigenous nutrition.4 But what has been learned to date about where resources should be directed? Despite the high costs and limited availability of healthy foods in remote community stores, surprising achievements have been made in some areas. Community dietary patterns were found to respond directly to improved stock management and food supply,5,6 and multistrategy, community-directed nutrition programs in some remote communities resulted in marked and sustained improvements in anthropometrical, biochemical and haematological risk factors for chronic disease.7,8 Knowledge gained from such studies has broadened the focus of Indigenous nutrition initiatives to include the “supply side” (improving food quality and access to healthy food in remote communities) as well as the “demand side” (promoting nutrition through behaviour change). In 2003, the FoodNorth study provided a comprehensive analysis of remote food supply issues, barriers and leverage points for improvement.9 More recently, the Remote Indigenous Stores and Takeaways Project developed nine practical resources, including a freight-improvement toolkit and a buyer’s guide, to assist remote stores to stock, promote and monitor the sale of healthy food.10 A major barrier is that community stores are seen as small businesses rather than as essential services, like health and education. Encouragingly, several submissions to the recent House of Representatives Inquiry into community stores in remote Indigenous communities detail specific approaches to secure both health and viable business outcomes.11 Remote store groups that combine buying power and operational efficiency (eg, the Arnhem Land Progress Association and the Retail Stores group in Queensland) have shown the benefits of store nutrition policies.9 Outback Stores, a company established by Indigenous Business Australia in 2006, included provision of nutritious food as a key goal, and provides one potential model to support sustainable employment and economic development in independent remote stores.12 The National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Nutrition Strategy and Action Plan 2000–2010 provided a broad framework for nutrition interventions, addressing both supply and demand issues.13 However, implementation of the strategy has neither been sustainably nor well resourced and remains fractured and opportunistic. Therefore, what is still urgently required is systematic, widespread, sustained implementation of evidence-based nutrition interventions. Brimblecombe and O’Dea now rightly highlight the need to also include innovative economic interventions.4 In Northern Territory communities, it has been estimated that up to 36% of the family income is needed to purchase food,14 which is at least double the proportion required by non-Indigenous Australians.15 One of the proposed “Close the Gap” equity targets was that, by 2018, 90% of Indigenous families could access a healthy food basket for under 25% of their income.16 However, nutrition issues were not included in the final National Indigenous Reform Agreement of the Council of Australian Governments. Globally, the dominant economic intervention affecting food pricing is national taxation on food to raise general revenue.17,18 In Australia, the basic foods required to maintain health were mostly exempted from the Goods and Services Tax (GST), and the price of these foods was expected to fall after the introduction of the new tax system in 2000.19 However, in Queensland from 2000 to 2001, the price of a basket of healthy foods increased by 12%, more than twice that of less healthy options.20 This highlights the unpredictability of complex economic systems and the need for rigorous testing of economic solutions to increase access to healthy food.18 Such testing is imperative within remote communities, but baseline data are not readily available as Australia lacks a comprehensive food and nutrition monitoring and surveillance system. It is also crucial that economic interventions support broader models of sustainable development in remote communities. Potential economic instruments include greater differential national taxation on energy-dense, nutrient-poor food (the “fat tax”), and subsidisation of healthy food through freight, in-store pricing and/or direct commodity subvention systems. There is a case for combining both approaches17 to better influence diet among lower socioeconomic groups18 and within relatively closed systems, such as schools and workplaces.17 The provision of free fruit in such settings has also produced sustained benefits in some countries.21 Improving remote area housing to include infrastructure for storage and preparation of food is also vital; in one study, this was serviceable in less than 6% of houses.22 Local food production, including that of traditional foods, may hold promise in some areas. Training and employment of Indigenous nutrition workers23 to deliver services, including budgeting programs like Indigenous FOODcents,24 are also required. Welfare reform and income management programs have great potential in some areas. However, in communities where incomes are quarantined and welfare recipients are required to spend a significant proportion of their income on food and other essentials, good public policy dictates that governments must also ensure that a healthy food supply is actually available and affordable in those communities. For the most vulnerable, food supplementation programs,25,26 if desired and controlled by the community, are warranted. The value of such assistance is greatly increased where food costs are high, and can immediately improve recipients’ dietary quality.19 Within a multistrategy approach, economic interventions tailored to community needs will assist low-income Indigenous Australians in remote communities to obtain the food they need for good health. “Best buys” of such an approach are listed in the Box. Solutions must involve sectors beyond health, including food producers, transporters and retailers, educators, economists and policymakers. “Best buys” to improve Indigenous nutrition and health 1. Continue and expand the reach of successful interventions Increase demand for healthy food Brief nutrition interventions and early interventions in primary care, including “well persons” health checks and follow-up action Prenatal, antenatal and postnatal nutrition programs; culturally appropriate infant growth assessment and action programs; and promoting breastfeeding and appropriate introduction of solid foods27 School-based nutrition-promotion projects, and community food-literacy and budgeting projects Improve supply of healthy food Use of resources developed by the Remote Indigenous Stores and Takeaways Project10 to improve store management practices, and transport and stocking of healthy food Local food gardens and traditional food procurement projects Increase capacity to achieve the interventions given above Train and employ an Indigenous nutrition workforce Improve housing, including food-storage, preparation and cooking facilities Develop a national, coordinated monitoring and surveillance system for food and nutrition 2. Trial economic interventions for widespread roll-out, if successful Food supplementation for women, infants and children Free fruit and vegetables for remote schools and other settings Freight subsidies for getting basic healthy foods to remote areas In-store price “mark-up” of less healthy items, and lower price margins on healthier foods Expansion of the current national differential taxation system to further favour competitive retail pricing of healthy foods

Amanda J Lee PhD, BSc(Nutr), GradDipDiet · Dympna Leonard MPH, BSc(Diet) · Aletia A Moloney MCommNutr · Deanne L Minniecon MHSc(HealthProm)

Indigenous health Prevention and Promotion May 2009 Free

The role of energy cost in food choices for an Aboriginal population in northern Australia

Objective: To explore the relationship between dietary quality and energy density of foods (MJ/kg) and energy cost ($/MJ) for an Aboriginal population living in a remote region of northern Australia.Design: For a 3-month period in 2005, we collected food and non-alcoholic beverage supply data from food outlets available to the study population. From these data, we compared the energy density of foods with their energy cost.Main outcome measures: Energy density and energy cost of food purchases.Results: The diet of the study population was high in refined carbohydrates and low in fresh fruit and vegetables. Foods with high energy density were associated with lower costs and contributed disproportionately to energy availability.Conclusion: The energy–cost differential between energy-dense, nutrient-poor foods and energy-dilute, nutrient-rich foods influences the capacity of Australian Aboriginal people living in remote communities to attain a healthy diet. This is consistent with the “economics of food choice” theory, whereby people on low incomes maximise energy availability per dollar in their food purchasing patterns, and has particular relevance for developing nutrition policy and strategies in Aboriginal communities, where poor nutrition is a major determinant of preventable chronic disease.

Julie K Brimblecombe PhD, MPH, GradDipNut · Kerin O’Dea AO, BSc, PhD

Indigenous health Prevention and Promotion May 2009 Free

Lipid treatment guidelines and cardiovascular risk for Aboriginal people in Central Australia

Objective: To evaluate the extent to which the current Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme (PBS) guidelines for patient eligibility for lipid-lowering medication are applicable to Aboriginal people in Central Australia.Design, setting and participants: A 10-year cohort study of 659 Aboriginal people who participated in population-based cardiovascular disease (CVD) risk factor surveys in 1995 and who were free of CVD at baseline, for the period from 1995 to 2004–2005 or until first CVD event. Evidence of atherosclerotic CVD (ischaemic heart disease, ischaemic stroke, and peripheral vascular disease) was sought from hospital, primary health care and death records. PBS eligibility was assigned according to the current PBS criteria, which were amended in 2006 to include Aboriginal-specific criteria, using participants’ baseline (1995) and 10-year follow-up data.Main outcome measures: Proportions of PBS-eligible and PBS-ineligible participants who had CVD events during the study period; sensitivity and specificity of the criteria.Results: Of 42 participants who had CVD events during the study period, 35 were PBS-eligible (incidence, 1130/100 000 person-years; relative risk compared with PBS-ineligible population, 4.87 [95% CI, 2.19–10.80]) and seven were PBS-ineligible. PBS eligibility was associated with older mean age (37 v 32 years) and male sex (48% v 37%), with 50.7% of participants (334/659) meeting eligibility criteria. The mean high-density lipoprotein cholesterol level at baseline was very low in both groups (0.81 v 0.87 mmol/L). The current PBS guidelines have low specificity (52%) in this population, which was found to improve (to 71%–82%) by incorporating additional non-lipid criteria (age and multiple non-lipid risk factors).Conclusion: The current PBS lipid treatment criteria, which include any Aboriginal person with diabetes and less stringent cholesterol thresholds than the previous version, identify a group at very high risk of CVD. Global risk assessment may better identify those at risk.

Joanne N Luke BSc, MPH · Alex Brown BMed, MPH, FCSANZ · David N O’Neal MB BS, FRACP, PhD · Kerin O’Dea AO, BSc, PhD · Alicia J Jenkins MB BS, MD, FRACP · Margaret Kelaher BSc(Hons), PhD · James D Best MB BS, MD, FRACP · Kevin G Rowley BAppSci, GradDipEpi, PhD

Indigenous health Prevention and Promotion May 2009 Free

Knowledge and attitudes regarding smoking during pregnancy among Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander women

Objective: To identify factors associated with antenatal smoking and explore characteristics of smoking behaviour among pregnant Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander women.Design and setting: Cross-sectional study using interviewer-administered questionnaires of 145 pregnant Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander women attending a health service in Far North Queensland between November 2005 and December 2006.Main outcome measures: Prevalence of self-reported smoking; predictors and patterns of smoking in early pregnancy; and relationships between smoking and the prevalence of predisposing, enabling and reinforcing factors, including women’s knowledge about and attitudes towards smoking and the risks involved.Results: Of 145 women, 41% (n = 60) reported being daily or occasional smokers. Knowledge about harms of smoking was generally high. Women who were smokers had a significantly higher rate of smoking partners (n = 36) than women who were non-smokers (n = 31) (77% v 41%, P < 0.001). Level of daily stress was significantly higher among smokers than non-smokers (P = 0.001).Conclusion: Shifted population norms among Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders are accompanied by a shift in the factors that can effectively differentiate between smokers and non-smokers within this population. Rather than the traditional, mainstream predictors of antenatal smoking, interventions with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander women should focus on the social environment, and the influences of social networks and partners on the behaviour of individuals.

Conor Gilligan PhD · Robert W Sanson-Fisher PhD · Catherine D’Este PhD · Sandra Eades PhD · Mark Wenitong MD

Indigenous health Prevention and Promotion May 2009 Free

Adult health checks for Indigenous Australians: the first year’s experience from the Inala Indigenous Health Service

Objective: To evaluate the role of the adult health check for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people aged 15–54 years, in an urban Indigenous primary health care setting.Design, setting and participants: Cross-sectional study of Indigenous patients recruited opportunistically from the Inala Indigenous Health Service between 1 June 2007 and 31 July 2008.Main outcome measures: Newly identified cardiovascular risk factors, investigations ordered and performed, interventions and new diagnoses made.Results: 413 patients out of a possible 509 consented to participate (93% were Aboriginal). High prevalences of cardiovascular risk factors such as smoking (67%), being overweight and obese (61%), harmful levels of alcohol consumption (36%), and depression (23%) were found. The adult health checks resulted in new investigations (in 82% of participants), lifestyle advice (67%), vaccinations (42%), referrals (62%) and new medications (49%). New diagnoses resulting from the health checks included depression (6%), a harmful level of alcohol consumption (4%), chlamydia infection (4%), hypertension (3%) and diabetes (3%). Pap smears were performed in 47% of women as a result of the health check.Conclusions: The adult health check for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders aged 15–54 years is a viable vehicle for evaluating health status, identifying chronic disease risk factors and for implementing preventive health care.

Geoffrey K P Spurling MB BS, FRACGP · Noel E Hayman MB BS, MPH, FAFPHM · Anna L Cooney RN

Indigenous health Prevention and Promotion May 2009 Free

Linking Indigenous health care with school education

A holistic approach to education at Yipirinya School represents an extraordinary opportunity to deliver health care to Indigenous children Last year, during a visit to Alice Springs, we witnessed first hand the consequences of inadequate provision of health care for Indigenous children. Although we are all specialist doctors, we were travelling in our capacity as fathers, accompanying our sons in a school-based “service” program.1 We experienced a unique, independent Indigenous school that we believe could provide a nexus for delivering health services to students and their communities. New models of service delivery are required to improve Indigenous health outcomes, and we believe that crossing bureaucratic boundaries between health and education might permit such progress. Yipirinya School does not have a student fee structure, hence has limited funding.2 The school is comprised of a child care centre, preschool, primary school and growing secondary section, and enrols about 200 seriously disadvantaged Indigenous children from the Alice Springs region, including 20 town camps and eight outstations within 75 kilometres. We lived and worked at Yipirinya for 10 days, in a group consisting of 20 fathers, our adolescent sons, and support staff. Our involvement with this community was privileged and rewarding yet, at times, distressing and confronting. We arrived wondering how a group of affluent, non-Indigenous outsiders could help, let alone engage, the local people. During our stay, we went on school bus runs into camps, served meals, assisted in class, played football at lunchtime, and gradually seemed to make friends. At night, before retiring to our swags in the school gymnasium, we reflected on events that had disturbed us — the ravenous appetite of a hungry child at breakfast, the filthy dwelling to which we delivered a 6-year-old in the afternoon, or the child who was misbehaving in class because of domestic violence. Were we ultimately successful in engaging with the locals? If the tears shed on our departure (by ourselves and our new Indigenous friends) were a measure, we succeeded. Although we helped with teaching, we also learnt. We learnt about the community’s pride in Indigenous life, culture and their land, and also learnt of stark gaps between us. As doctors, we were particularly dismayed by the stark contrast between the access to health care of the students of Yipirinya and that of our own sons. Might this school represent an opportunity for more effective delivery of health services to its students? The school authorities had previously thought so and, independently, we came to the same conclusion. At Yipirinya, there is a holistic approach to schooling: five separate bus runs pick up and drop off children each school day, as few would otherwise attend; children receive a sit-down breakfast and lunch; clothing is provided when needed, especially on cold winter days; basic hygiene is directed by dedicated and friendly teachers; and an academic program embraces conventional and Indigenous education. For many children, this represents a temporary release from an otherwise chaotic lifestyle; on some days it may simply represent a place to eat, sleep and feel safe. Yipirinya enrols more Indigenous students from town camps and outstations than all Alice Springs government and private schools combined (personal communication, Ken Langford-Smith, Principal, Yipirinya School). The school represents a central node from which nutrition, washing, clothing and education are regularly provided for these disadvantaged children. However, because of the independent status of Yipirinya, together with sporadic and diminishing support from local health services, there is no school nurse to provide care beyond that given by teachers. The provision of health care through the school, encompassing education, prevention, and acute medical or nursing care, would narrow the existing service gap. Perhaps more importantly, an extraordinary opportunity exists for more effective delivery of paediatric, and ultimately even adult, health care to those living in camps and outstations. Yipirinya is a highly respected and culturally sensitive organisation, with Indigenous language speakers and elders who could help to facilitate and support the provision of effective health services. We hope that our own approaches to Northern Territory health officials, together with recent submissions from Yipirinya, will lead to the provision of a dedicated full-time school nurse. We are certain that this will improve regional Indigenous health care services — starting with the children. Finally, we came across this situation and the opportunities presented by chance. Opportunities must surely exist in schools and communities elsewhere to more closely align Indigenous health care and education, and thereby improve the wellbeing of children and families living in these disadvantaged communities.

Geoffrey M Forbes MB BS, MD, FRACP · Stephen J Davis MB BS, MRCP, FRANZCR · Martin D Robson MB BS, FFA · Anthony F Connell BSc, MB BS, FRACS · Peter C Richmond MB BS, MRCP, FRACP

Indigenous health Communication, culture and health May 2009 Free

Healthy country, healthy people: the relationship between Indigenous health status and “caring for country”

Objective: To investigate associations between “caring for country” — an activity that Indigenous peoples assert promotes good health — and health outcomes relevant to excess Indigenous morbidity and mortality.Design, setting and participants: Cross-sectional study involving 298 Indigenous adults aged 15–54 years in an Arnhem Land community, recruited from March to September 2005.Main outcome measures: Self-reported involvement in caring for country, health behaviours and clinically measured body mass index (BMI), waist circumference, blood pressure, type 2 diabetes status, albumin to creatinine ratio (ACR), levels of glycated haemoglobin (HbA1c) and high-density lipoprotein (HDL) cholesterol, lipid ratio, score on the five-item version of the Kessler Psychological Distress Scale (K5), and 5-year cardiovascular disease (CVD) risk.Results: Controlling for sociodemographic characteristics and health behaviours, multivariate regression revealed significant and substantial associations between caring for country and health outcomes. An interquartile range rise in the weighted composite caring-for-country score was significantly associated with more frequent physical activity, better diet, lower BMI (regression coefficient [b] = − 2.83; 95% CI, − 4.56 to − 1.10), less abdominal obesity (odds ratio [OR], 0.43; 95% CI, 0.26–0.72), lower systolic blood pressure (b = − 7.59; 95% CI, − 12.01 to − 3.17), less diabetes (OR, 0.12; 95% CI, 0.03–0.52), lower HbA1c level (b = − 0.45; 95% CI, − 0.79 to − 0.11), non-elevated ACR (OR, 0.28; 95% CI, 0.13–0.60), higher HDL cholesterol level (b = 0.06; 95% CI, 0.01–0.12), lower K5 score (b = − 0.97; 95% CI, − 1.64 to − 0.31) and lower CVD risk (b = − 0.77; 95% CI, − 1.43 to − 0.11).Conclusions: Greater Indigenous participation in caring for country activities is associated with significantly better health. Although the causal direction of these associations requires clarification, our findings suggest that investment in caring for country may be a means to foster sustainable economic development and gains for both ecological and Indigenous peoples’ health.

Christopher P Burgess FRACGP, MPH · Fay H Johnston PhD, FAPHM · Helen L Berry PhD · Joseph McDonnell MSc · Dean Yibarbuk · Charlie Gunabarra · Albert Mileran · Ross S Bailie MB ChB, FAPHM

Indigenous health Communication, culture and health May 2009 Free

Barriers to participation of Aboriginal people in cancer care: communication in the hospital setting

Objective: To report Aboriginal patients’ views about effective communication between Aboriginal people and health service providers in Western Australian hospital settings.Design, setting and participants: Qualitative study involving indepth interviews between 1 March 2006 and 30 September 2007 with 30 Aboriginal people affected by cancer from across WA.Main outcome measures: Aboriginal patients’ views about the quality of communication within the hospitals, factors impairing communication and suggestions for improvement.Results: Factors crucial to effective patient–provider communication such as language, shared understanding, knowledge and use of medical terminology require attention. Additionally, communication between Aboriginal people and health care professionals needs to be understood within a broader sociocultural and political context. Fear of the medical system and of being disempowered; mistrust; collective memories of the experience of colonisation and its aftermath; lack of understanding of Aboriginal customs, values, lifestyle and the importance of family and land; and experiences of racism were key issues impairing communication. Health service providers’ inability to interpret non-verbal communication and the symbolism of hospital environments also posed problems.Conclusion: Key areas for the attention of health service providers in communicating and caring for Aboriginal people in the hospital setting include culturally sensitive and empathetic personal contact, acknowledgement and respect for Aboriginal family structures, culture and life circumstances, an understanding of the significant role of non-verbal communication, and the importance of history, land and community. Employing more Aboriginal health workers in hospitals, and allowing Aboriginal people to participate at a decision-making level in hospitals is likely to improve Aboriginal people’s access to cancer treatment, and would be important symbols of progress in this area.

Shaouli Shahid MSS, MA, BSS · Lizzie D Finn PhD, MAppPsych, MA · Sandra C Thompson PhD, MPH, FAFPHM

Indigenous health Communication, culture and health May 2009 Free

Indigenous medical workforce development: current status and future directions

Both more Indigenous doctors — for the sociocultural capabilities they bring — and better sociocultural education of all medical students will be needed to “close the gap” When Prime Minister Kevin Rudd and representatives of Australian health leadership signed a statement of intent to close the Indigenous health gap by 2030, they committed to putting in place by 2018 the primary health services and other health infrastructure necessary to achieve this goal.1 Although health service development has been key to the national policy agenda in Indigenous health since the National Aboriginal Health Strategy in 1989, a high level commitment to workforce development was not in place until the Australian Health Ministers’ Advisory Council endorsed the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Workforce National Strategic Framework in 2002.2 This priority was subsequently reinforced when the National Indigenous Health Equality Council was established in 2008 — with a significant focus on workforce strategy.3 There are two key issues in Indigenous medical workforce development — the relative undersupply of Indigenous Australian doctors, and the need to equip all Australian medical graduates with the skills, knowledge and attributes to provide quality health care to Indigenous Australians regardless of where they present in the health system. Indigenous Australians represent 1.9% of the total population aged 15 years and older, but only 1% of the total health workforce.4 In 2006, there were 100 Indigenous Australian medical practitioners (0.2% of the total), including 40 medical specialists.4 In 2008, the Australian Indigenous Doctors’ Association (AIDA) estimated that there were 125 graduates, with another 125 in training (an estimate consistent with figures previously published in the Journal).5,6 According to 2006 census figures, the proportion of doctors in the Australian population was 0.27%, while the proportion of Indigenous doctors in the Indigenous population was 0.019%.5 Increasing the participation of Indigenous people in the health workforce is an important workforce development strategy, as well as an important goal to pursue for equity reasons. Indigenous Australians can contribute to improved quality of care by aligning their technical and sociocultural capabilities to maximise patient or population health outcomes. The presence of Indigenous practitioners in the health workforce adds a collegiate dimension to relationships between non-Indigenous practitioners and Indigenous Australians, and this has the potential to facilitate reform in health care practice. To that end, the leadership provided by Indigenous practitioners in health research and education is also important. However, the responsibility for quality health care for Indigenous people is one that must be shared. Non-Indigenous colleagues play a critical role, which is why all graduates need to be equipped to work across the entire range of Australian sociocultural contexts, including in Indigenous health. The Indigenous health medical workforce agenda has been implemented through a broad partnership that includes AIDA, Medical Deans Australia and New Zealand and the Australian Medical Council. This has resulted in a suite of tools for supporting medical school reform and revised standards and procedures for medical school accreditation.7-10 There have been two recent developments that we anticipate will provide further impetus in curricula development. The first is the development of the Critical Reflection Tool (CRT).11 The CRT was developed to support medical schools in their efforts to implement the national Indigenous health curriculum framework and their initiatives to support Indigenous students. It was designed to cover the broad context of medical schools in implementing an Indigenous health reform agenda. The CRT provides an opportunity for medical schools to critically analyse factors such as their structural relationship with existing Indigenous health units, and the aspirations of the medical school as articulated through mission statements, through to the detail of the curriculum itself (including teaching and learning, assessment, implementation and review and evaluation) and Indigenous student recruitment and retention initiatives and strategies. All medical schools in Australia and New Zealand were invited to trial the CRT in October 2007 through to June 2008, and 12 of 21 schools were able to provide feedback within the timeframe required. Trial findings endorsed the content of the CRT. The second development supporting curricula development is the creation of the Leaders in Indigenous Medical Education (LIME) Network for medical educators, specialists in Indigenous health, policymakers and community members with an interest in quality Indigenous health content in medical education.12 Medical Deans Australia and New Zealand established the LIME Network to provide a forum for medical educators in Indigenous health, promote the exchange of best practice and facilitate professional development. The Network hosts a biennial conference to facilitate dialogue on Indigenous health between medical educators, colleagues across the other health disciplines and community partners.12 There is still much work to be done to increase Indigenous participation in the health workforce, and to develop medical schools into places that produce a workforce fit to meet the needs of Indigenous Australians. Clearly, there is a significant undersupply of Indigenous doctors, but as yet there are no nationally agreed targets. This is an important policy agenda and a brokered agreement on targets by key stakeholders would enable a more robust framework for monitoring change. Targets should be achievable and take into account high school retention rates, tertiary readiness, potential pathways and population demographics. Nationally, the track record for medical schools in recruiting and retaining Indigenous students is very mixed. Institutions such as the University of Newcastle, the University of Western Australia, James Cook University and the University of New South Wales clearly lead the field.6 There is a debate about whether strategy should focus on building the programs within schools with a proven record of success, or whether all medical schools should be encouraged to do better. Our view is that the system should enable Indigenous students to select the university that will maximise their opportunities for personal success. However, this would require more universities to develop the comprehensive integrated programs that develop pathways through secondary education, promote health sciences as a career choice for Indigenous Australians and provide robust support for the academic and social development of enrolled students. Graduate attributes are arguably the best marker of efficacy in curriculum reform. The CRT provides a framework for internal reflection by medical schools on their structures, curricula, and recruitment and retention strategies, to maximise their potential to graduate Indigenous and other students who can contribute to “closing the gap”.

Ian P S Anderson MB BS, FAFPHM · Shaun C Ewen BAppSc(Physio), MMIL · Debra A Knoche BA(Hons)

Indigenous health Capacity to care May 2009 Free

Coronary heart disease events in Aboriginal Australians: incidence in an urban population

Objective: To determine the incidence of coronary heart disease (CHD) events in an urban Aboriginal population.Design, setting and participants: Cohort study of 906 Aboriginal people without CHD from 998 who had undergone risk-factor assessment in the Perth Aboriginal Atherosclerosis Risk Study (PAARS) in 1998–1999. PAARS cohort data were electronically linked to a range of databases that included Western Australian hospital morbidity data and death registry data. We analysed data from January 1980 to December 2006 to identify previous admissions for CHD from 1980 to baseline (1998–1999) and new events from baseline to 2006.Main outcome measure: First CHD event (hospital admission or death).Results: There were 891 linked records for the 906 participants without previous CHD. The event rate was 12.6/1000 person-years (95% CI, 10.2–15.6/1000 person-years). Annual CHD event rates ranged from 8 to 18/1000 person-years. After adjustment for age (sex was not associated with the risk factors assessed), factors associated with risk of a CHD event in the PAARS cohort were a history of diabetes, overweight or obesity (indicated by body mass index), smoking, and hypertension, but not waist circumference. People with these risk factors were 1.9–2.7 times more likely to experience a CHD event. Compared with previously published information from a remote Aboriginal community in the Northern Territory, the incidence of CHD events among urban-dwelling Aboriginal people was not significantly different (P > 0.05 overall and for subgroups defined by age and sex).Conclusions: City-dwelling Aboriginal Australians have an incidence of CHD events comparable to that of Aboriginal people living in remote northern Australia.

Pamela J Bradshaw PhD · Helman S Alfonso MSc, PhD · Judith C Finn RN, MEdStud, PhD · Julie Owen DipT, MPHC, PhD · Peter L Thompson MD, FRACP, MBA

Indigenous health Capacity to care May 2009 Free

Outcomes of cardiac surgery in Indigenous Australians

Objective: To describe baseline characteristics, operative events and late mortality among Indigenous Australians undergoing cardiac surgery.Design, setting and participants: Prospective study of consecutive patients undergoing cardiac surgery at Flinders Medical Centre in Adelaide between January 2000 and December 2005.Main outcome measures: Operative (30-day) mortality and late mortality after cardiac surgery.Results: Of 2635 patients undergoing cardiac surgery, 283 (10.7%) were Indigenous. Indigenous patients were substantially younger than non-Indigenous patients (mean, 47 [SD, 14] years v 65 [SD, 12] years; P = 0.001) and were more likely to have diabetes (39.6% v 27.3%; P = 0.001), renal dysfunction (3.2% v 1.2%; P = 0.009), and valvular surgery (53.0% v 23.1%; P < 0.001). There was a non-significant trend toward excess operative mortality in Indigenous patients (Indigenous 2.5% v non-Indigenous 1.3%; hazard ratio [HR], 1.67 [95% CI, 0.74–3.75]). But in the under-55-years age cohort, the difference between the two groups was highly significant (Indigenous 3.3% v non-Indigenous 0.4%; HR, 7.99 [95% CI, 1.66–38.50]), even after adjustment for euroSCORE (the European System for Cardiac Operative Risk Evaluation). Survival at 1 and 5 years was 94.0% and 80.6%, respectively, for Indigenous patients compared with 96.7% and 87.7%, respectively, for non-Indigenous patients. There was an excess in euroSCORE-adjusted mortality in the Indigenous cohort overall (HR, 1.46 [95% CI, 1.03–2.07]) that strengthened when restricted to the under-55-years cohort (HR, 6.9 [95% CI, 1.42–33.5]).Conclusion: Indigenous Australians present for cardiac surgery nearly 20 years earlier than non-Indigenous Australians and experience excess age-stratified operative and late mortality.

Sam J Lehman MB BS, FRACP · Robert A Baker PhD · Philip E Aylward MB BS, FRACP, PhD · John L Knight MB BS, FRACS · Derek P Chew MB BS, MPH, FRACP

Indigenous health Capacity to care May 2009 Free

Timing of transfer for pregnant women from Queensland Cape York communities to Cairns for birthing

Objective: To determine whether the current planned transfer of pregnant women from Cape York communities to Cairns at 36 weeks’ gestation for birthing is medically appropriate.Design and setting: Retrospective audit of travel details and demographic and obstetric outcome data on all women from Cape York communities who travelled to Cairns for late pregnancy care and birth at Cairns Base Hospital in 2006.Main outcome measures: Length of stay in Cairns; gestational age at birth.Results: In 2006, 172 women from 14 Cape communities travelled to Cairns to give birth. Of these, 76% identified as Aboriginal or Torres Strait Islander, 20% as Caucasian and 4% were from other ethnic groups. The mean time of stay in Cairns before birth (range) was 24 (0–86) days. Eleven women (6%) gave birth between 36 and 37 weeks of pregnancy; this point marked the beginning of a significant rise in births for increasing gestational ages.Conclusion: Aiming for 36 weeks’ gestation for transfer is medically appropriate, but results in long periods of separation of women from Cape communities from family and friends, with detrimental social, cultural and financial consequences. Reopening maternity units in towns serving the Cape communities could reduce the number of women from the region having to travel to Cairns for pregnancy care and birth.

Joanna L Arnold MB BS, FRANZCOG · Caroline M de Costa FRANZCOG, FRCOG, MPH · Paul W Howat MB BS, FRANZCOG

Indigenous health Capacity to care May 2009 Free

Middle ear disease in Aboriginal children in Perth: analysis of hearing screening data, 1998–2004

Objective: To describe diagnoses and correlates of middle ear disease in Aboriginal primary school children in a targeted school-testing program in Perth, Western Australia.Design and setting: Analysis of records of ear testing carried out over a 6-year period in three primary schools in Perth.Participants: Aboriginal children of primary school age (4–12 years) who attended the schools on the day of testing. Data on middle ear disease and hearing impairment were available for 119 and 94 children, respectively, from their first test.Main outcome measures: Proportions of children with middle ear disease and hearing loss.Results: Middle ear disease was diagnosed in 50 children (42.0%; 95% CI, 33.0%–51.4%). Rates were lower in older children (P = 0.002) but did not differ according to season of testing. Hearing loss (mild or moderate) was detected in 18 children (19.1%; 95% CI, 11.8%–28.6%). Hearing impairment was also less prevalent in older children (P = 0.007) and had no association with season of testing.Conclusions: Middle ear disease is a significant problem for Aboriginal children in Perth, and is associated with mild–moderate hearing loss. Health authorities must continue to focus on appropriate identification and management of the disease in this population.

Corinne J Williams BAppSci(Speech and Hearing), BA(AS)(Hons), PhD · Harvey L Coates AO, MS, FRACS · Elaine M Pascoe BSc(Hons), MBiostats · Yvonne Axford · Irene Nannup

Indigenous health Capacity to care May 2009 Free

Improving Indigenous patients’ access to mainstream health services: the Inala experience

In 1994, only 12 Indigenous people attended the mainstream general practice in Inala, south-western Brisbane, Queensland. An Indigenous community focus group and telephone interviews revealed deficits such as: few items (eg, artwork) that Indigenous people could identify with; lack of Indigenous staff; staff perceived as unfriendly; inflexibility regarding time; and intolerance of Indigenous children’s behaviour. Access to the Inala Indigenous Health Service by Indigenous people improved when these issues were addressed, and has grown significantly every year from 1995 to 2008. Other important factors in improving access include: energetic Indigenous leadership; enabling bulk billing to increase funding; moving to a stand-alone clinic; and engaging with teaching, research and community programs. A Centre of Excellence in Indigenous Primary Health Care is envisaged as the next innovation required to improve access and quality of service, and to close the gap between Indigenous and non-Indigenous health outcomes.

Noel E Hayman MB BS, FAFPHM, FRACGP · Nola E White RN · Geoffrey K Spurling MB BS, DTM

Indigenous simulated patients: an initiative in “closing the gap”

To the Editor: The Australian Medical Council (AMC) now includes Indigenous health in its accreditation standards for medical schools,1 with guidelines stating that medical curricula must contain the “. . . appropriate use of educational expertise, including the educational expertise of Indigenous people, in the development and management of the medical course [emphasis added]”.1 These AMC requirements arose from the Indigenous Health Curriculum Framework, which was endorsed by the Committee of Deans of Australian Medical Schools.2 The second encounter of the Indigenous Simulated Patient Program at the University of Melbourne In the second encounter, the “patient” is concerned both about the conflicting information they have been given concerning diabetes and the need to attend multiple clinics. The “patient” attempts to explain that family and work obligations mean they cannot wait in outpatient clinics all day. The students in this session are encouraged to work with the “patient” to problem solve the issues that arise. The “patient” has been instructed to provide realistic reasons why these solutions will not work for them, highlighting possible differences in family responsibilities and living arrangements for some Indigenous community members, and demonstrating the conflicting priorities and expectations between the “patient” and the medical system. The University of Melbourne School of Medicine developed the Indigenous Simulated Patient Program in 2002 as one element of an integrated Indigenous health curriculum. The Program meets some of the goals of the framework by acknowledging and incorporating the educational expertise of Indigenous people, exposing students to Indigenous peoples’ lived experiences and world views, and by linking the simulated patient experience with other teaching content regarding the many ways in which history has affected Indigenous health. Indigenous simulated patients are used both early and late in the medical course. The early patient scenario is used within an uncomplicated communication skills tutorial, in which students practise their developing patient-interviewing skills and discover that the “patient” is Indigenous. The later scenario is more complicated (Box) and builds upon the first experience. In both scenarios, students are encouraged to ask the Indigenous patient, both in and out of character, questions about their personal experiences. The aim is to use the Indigenous Simulated Patient Program to help students understand that they will encounter Indigenous patients in their clinical studies and as junior doctors, and that these patients will have both the same and different issues from non-Indigenous patients. Solutions need to be tailored to meet the individual needs of the patient, and should include lessons from previous teaching within the curriculum — for example, the role of Aboriginal health workers in hospitals. The impact on Indigenous community members who participate in the program has been strongly affirming, with one actor commenting, “Today I felt like I really contributed to the training of medical students in issues that were important to me and my community”. Students also rate the experience very highly.3

Shaun C Ewen · Margo E Collins · Jennifer A Schwarz · Eleanor M Flynn

Patterns of mortality in Indigenous adults in the Northern Territory, 1998–2003: are people living in remote areas worse off?

To the Editor: I read with interest the article by Andreasyan and Hoy,1 in which lower Aboriginal mortality rates were found in “very remote areas” compared with “remote areas” in the Northern Territory. In a previous article,2 I reported a similar finding from national data, based on information published by the Public Health Information Development Unit at the University of Adelaide.3 Thirty years ago, in this Journal, Morice outlined the health benefits that accrue for Aboriginal people moving away from larger settlements to live in smaller, decentralised communities where they can care for their country.4 There is an increasing literature to demonstrate that Aboriginal people living in smaller communities have better health than those living in larger settlements and regional towns. These findings have policy relevance, but they appear to be ignored by policymakers. The current Australian Government is continuing previous policies that do not support decentralised communities, but rather encourage their residents to move to larger communities or regional centres, where mortality is higher. These policies appear to be heavily influenced by allegations based on narrow economic arguments that the lack of “jobs” in small remote communities is a reason for them to be closed down.5 A minister in the previous federal government derided smaller remote communities as “cultural museums”.6 It is disturbing to note that a recent major Australian Government policy announcement stated that funding for the next 6 years . . . will support improvements to the delivery of services across 26 remote locations across the Northern Territory, Western Australia, Queensland, New South Wales and South Australia. These locations represent some of the largest concentrations of Indigenous Australians in remote Australia.7 Apparently, over 1100 smaller communities will not receive new funding. This is likely to accelerate the drift from small communities to larger settlements and towns, increasing exposure to health risks. Evidence from the Journal and elsewhere suggests that this drift will increase Aboriginal mortality. The current Australian Government has made a commitment to “close the gap” between Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal life expectancies. The Prime Minister has also stated that his government’s policies will be based on evidence.8 Yet current policies ignore the evidence for the health benefits that accrue to Aboriginal people living in small decentralised communities. These policies also ignore the known health risks associated with larger settlements. Consequently, such policies may widen rather than close the gap.

David J Scrimgeour

Why Australia needs a national college of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health

To the Editor: The recent article by Parker1 presents an interesting case for the establishment of a national academic college of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health. The notion has been considered within Aboriginal health policy forums in the past, and the federal parliamentary Inquiry into Indigenous Health2 noted that an exploration of the merits of creating a new medical specialty for health care providers to Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples was arguably favourable. On the other hand, the concept has not gained significant support from some existing medical colleges. Broadly, the arguments supporting a college of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health are that the subject is a national health priority,3 the subject has its own specialised literature, practice within an Aboriginal cultural framework is a specialised activity,4 technical aspects of health care delivery often require specialist knowledge,5 and providers of health care for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples often act as consultants for other practitioners and policy development.6 The contrary view is that Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health is a health science sub-discipline within general practice, and that existing structures satisfy training needs. In terms of academic education in relation to the health of Indigenous Australians, Aboriginal community-controlled health organisations have had substantial experience and success over the past 25 years — primarily in the provision of accredited Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health worker training, but also in undergraduate and postgraduate training in medicine, nursing and allied health. Aboriginal representative bodies such as the National Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation (NACCHO) and its Affiliates are already the arbiters of standards, benchmarks, codes of ethics, policies and protocols that define health care delivery to Indigenous Australians. With appropriate additional resourcing, it would be feasible to build on such existing expertise and infrastructure to develop a national Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health college. Ultimately, consistent with international principles of self-determination, Aboriginal community-controlled health organisations, NACCHO and Torres Strait Islander authorities should determine whether or not to progress the processes required for establishing an Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health college. They should also, as a corollary, determine the structure, function and membership of such a college, if it were to be developed.

John Daniels · Sophie Couzos

The capacity of mainstream alcohol and drug treatment services to respond to the needs of Indigenous Australians

To the Editor: Compared with non-Indigenous Australians, Indigenous Australians are more likely to smoke, drink at risky levels and use illicit drugs.1 These alcohol and other drug (AOD) use patterns contribute to or exacerbate a wide range of health conditions and are significant contributors to premature death and morbidity among Indigenous Australians.2 Some attention has been paid to the efficacy of Indigenous-specific AOD programs,3 but there has been little investigation into the capacity of mainstream AOD services to respond to the needs of Indigenous Australians. To address this deficiency, we conducted a national postal survey of workers employed in agencies listed in the 2001 clients of treatment service agencies (COTSA) database. A total of 1345 workers employed in 369 agencies responded (a response rate of 38%). Most respondents (86%) indicated that their agency provided services to Indigenous clients, and that there was either strong (53%) or some (38%) need for such services. However, almost two-thirds (64%) felt that Indigenous clients’ needs were only partially met, and 9% reported that such needs were not met at all. Private sector workers were significantly less likely to report that their agency provided services to Indigenous clients than workers in government agencies and non-government organisations (NGOs) (χ2 = 102.4; effect df = 3; respondents = 1335; P < 0.001). NGO workers were significantly more likely to report a strong need for the provision of AOD services to Indigenous Australians than government and private agency workers (χ2 = 22.2; effect df = 6; respondents = 1110; P < 0.001). Workers in remote locations were significantly more likely to report a strong need for AOD services for Indigenous Australians than workers in other locations (χ2 = 24.9; effect df = 8; respondents = 1108; P = 0.002). Nearly two-thirds of all respondents reported they had no (18%) or limited (44%) access to AOD resources designed specifically for Indigenous Australians. NGO and private agency workers were significantly more likely than government workers to report limited or no access to resources designed to meet the needs of Indigenous Australians (χ2 = 17.8; effect df = 6; respondents = 1168; P < 0.001). These findings indicate a clear need to improve the capacity of mainstream AOD treatment agencies, especially those servicing remote areas, to respond to the needs of Indigenous Australians. Until improvements are made, AOD problems will continue to erode the health and wellbeing of Indigenous Australians, with predictable outcomes in relation to injury, mental health, parenting and contact with the criminal justice system. As recently highlighted by Indigenous spokesperson Mick Dodson,4 initiatives, beyond support for Indigenous workers and communities, are required to improve mainstream services for Indigenous clients in a culturally sensitive and appropriate manner.

Ann M Roche · Kenneth J Pidd · Vinita Duraisingam

Effect of swimming pools on antibiotic use and clinic attendance for infections in two Aboriginal communities in Western Australia

To the Editor: Silva and colleagues examined the effects of swimming pools on antibiotic use and clinic attendance for infections in two Aboriginal communities in Western Australia from 1998 to 2005.1 They concluded that swimming pools led to large decreases in clinic attendances for skin infections, respiratory tract infections, and antibiotic use. The huge health and social disadvantage suffered by Indigenous children is well documented, and any interventions that demonstrate health gains should be recognised. This study highlighted important issues and the results suggested some positive outcomes. However, two weaknesses of the study deserve comment — the lack of a control community without a pool, and the selective use of baseline years. In the absence of a control community (without a pool), these results could reflect documented secular trends in Aboriginal child health overall. For example, there was a 48% overall decline in hospitalisations for childhood pneumonia in four jurisdictions, including WA, between 1998 and 2005.2 This is not significantly different from the 52% reduction reported by Silva and colleagues. Second, the selective use of baseline years potentially obscures more modest results. The authors use 1998–1999 data for the figure (Box 3) and 1999–2000 as the baseline in the main results table (Box 4). The use of the second time period (1999–2000) gives more favourable results than if the previous year had been used. By interpolation, using the first period as baseline would reduce the effect size from 68% to 35% reduction for skin infections in one community (Jigalong). In the second community, rates of skin infections were actually increasing after 2002. Swimming pools in remote Aboriginal communities appear to have many benefits, including increased showering, school attendance and enjoyment among children. We believe that this study has not demonstrated a health impact of swimming pools in these communities that is different from trends elsewhere. That said, swimming pools are a “public good” that should be available to all Australian children, especially those living in very hot places where there are few alternative recreational opportunities. Arguments about direct health benefits should not be a requirement for one group of disadvantaged Australians when we do not feel we need to make the same arguments for other Australian children.

Yvette Roe · Robyn A McDermott

Indigenous health Close the gap May 2009 Free

Close the Gap: ask the experts

Planning the next steps in an Indigenous-led journey Tom Calma, 19 Aug 2008, Victorian Government and Opposition signing of the Statement of Intent. Courtesy: Lara McKinley, Oxfam Australia. When Prime Minister Kevin Rudd made his much anticipated formal Apology to Indigenous Australians in early 2008, he described it as a first step [towards] a future where we harness the determination of all Australians, Indigenous and non-Indigenous, to close the gap that lies between us in life expectancy, educational achievement and economic opportunity. Every journey requires preparation before the first step can be taken, and this one was no exception. In his 2005 Social Justice Report, the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Social Justice Commissioner, Tom Calma, highlighted the huge gap in health and life expectancy between Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples and the rest of the Australian population, and issued an inspiring challenge for closure of the gap within 25 years. By early 2007, “Close the Gap” had become a national campaign supported by more than 40 Indigenous and non-Indigenous organisations and many thousands of individual Australians, and at the end of the same year the Council of Australian Governments promised that all Australian states would work with (and fund) Indigenous communities to address this issue. Soon after Rudd’s Apology, the government signed a Statement of Intent with peak Indigenous health bodies to work together to achieve equality in health status and life expectancy, and established the National Indigenous Health Equality Council. In the past year, targets have been set and considerable funding allocated for ongoing Close the Gap initiatives. The journey has indeed begun! Scattered throughout this special MJA Indigenous Health issue are brief contributions from some of the key organisations in the Close the Gap campaign (Social justice, Psychology, National Indigenous Health Equality Council, Dentistry, Aboriginal community controlled health services, Oxfam Australia, Nursing, Australian Indigenous Doctors’ Association). We asked each of them to outline one or two things that will make the most difference in the short term to the longer-term goal of closing the gap. Ranging from personal, through practical to political, their responses share a common thread: the importance of true partnerships with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples at every step along the way. Closing the gap began as an Indigenous-led movement, but it has now inspired Australians at every level and become the foundation for unprecedented political focus on our nation’s biggest challenge. Many of the contributors of these short pieces are telling us that they know what to do next to keep us on track to reach our final destination. Partnerships with and continued leadership by Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples will be key to the journey’s success.

Ruth Armstrong

Indigenous health Close the gap May 2009 Free

Close the Gap: social justice

We need a stronger focus on the social determinants of health Since 2006, Australia’s peak Indigenous and non-Indigenous health bodies, non-government organisations and human rights organisations have worked together on the Close the Gap campaign for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health equality by 2030. The key elements of their approach are: A comprehensive national plan of action that is properly resourced and that has the goal of closing the health and life expectancy gap between Indigenous and non-Indigenous Australians within a generation. This is vital to ensure that governments work towards Indigenous health equality in a coordinated fashion (including the many reform processes currently underway), and that none of the determinants of Indigenous health inequality are missed. A partnership for Indigenous health equality between government and Indigenous peoples and their representatives. Within the national plan, a targeted approach to achieving Indigenous health equality, focusing on a wide range of health conditions and health determinants. The campaign partners have developed a comprehensive set of Close the Gap National Indigenous Health Equality Targets (http://www.humanrights.gov.au/social_justice/health/targets) to guide this target-setting process. These were presented to the Australian Government in July 2008. Support for Aboriginal community-controlled health services. The good news is that Australian governments have already committed to this approach through: Bipartisan support for the Close the Gap Statement of Intent, signed by the Prime Minister in March 2008 (see: http://humanrights.gov.au/social_justice/health/statement_intent.html) — this alone represents a historic turning point in the approach to Indigenous affairs in this country; and Commitments by the Council of Australian Governments, where Australian governments have committed to closing the life expectancy gap within a generation, halving the mortality gap between Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander and non-Indigenous children under 5 years of age, and the provision of record levels of new funding to support this. However, despite substantial investments in Indigenous health as a result of the campaign, progress has been slow in turning the commitments around planning and partnership into action, and there needs to be a stronger focus on the social determinants of health rather than simply a health sector response. This remains the challenge of the campaign partners over 2009–2010.

Tom Calma

Indigenous health Close the gap May 2009 Free

Close the Gap: psychology

Addressing psychological distress is key The enormous disparities in social and emotional wellbeing and mental health outcomes, and an apparent worsening of the circumstances of many Indigenous communities, were two of the major reasons that prompted Indigenous psychologists from all over the country to form the Australian Indigenous Psychologists Association (AIPA) in 2008, under the auspices of the Australian Psychological Society. AIPA has the dual aims of increasing the number of Indigenous psychologists and addressing the widening gap in social and emotional wellbeing and mental health outcomes for Indigenous peoples. The National Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health Survey 2004–05 showed that just over one-quarter (27%) of Indigenous adults reported high or very high levels of psychological distress. This proportion was similar to that in New York City 8 months after the attack on the World Trade Center. Regardless of the causes, people who find themselves psychologically overwhelmed or struggling to cope suffer high levels of psychological distress. Such distress is a clear global indicator of poor social and emotional wellbeing among Indigenous Australians, and needs to be addressed early to prevent an increasing burden of mental illness among Indigenous peoples. The integration of culturally appropriate social and emotional wellbeing and primary mental health care services into Aboriginal community-controlled health care settings is essential in addressing the high levels of psychological distress among Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples. There is evidence that Indigenous peoples do not have universal access to these services, which should be available to all Indigenous populations in urban, regional or remote Australia. Preventing psychological distress is likely to result in a range of beneficial health as well as mental health outcomes for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples, and could make a major contribution to closing the gap in life expectancy between Indigenous and other Australians.

Patricia Dudgeon

Indigenous health Close the gap May 2009 Free

Close the Gap: National Indigenous Health Equality Council

Guiding policy to end Indigenous health disadvantage The National Indigenous Health Equality Council (NIHEC; http://www.nihec.gov.au/) was established in July 2008 to advise the Australian Government Minister for Health and Ageing. Most of its members are Indigenous Australians, with expertise drawn from across the Aboriginal and mainstream health sectors and Australian Government. The Council’s terms of reference focus on: Its role in the development and monitoring of progress towards a set of health-related goals and targets to support the government’s commitments to Indigenous life expectancy and child mortality. Providing national leadership in responding to the government’s commitment to closing the gap of Indigenous disadvantage by advising the government on working towards the provision of equitable and sustainable health outcomes for Indigenous Australians. Providing strategic advice on: the commitments made under the March 2008 Statement of Intent on achieving Indigenous health equality; the development and monitoring of health-related goals and targets to support the government’s commitments to life expectancy and child mortality; priorities for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health, including strategies for meeting targets agreed upon by the Australian Government and the Council of Australian Governments (COAG); monitoring progress towards closing the gap of Indigenous disadvantage; and any specific matters referred to it by the government and the Australian Health Ministers’ Advisory Council. As a first priority, NIHEC was asked to make recommendations on workforce development and sustainability, including advice on pathways to increase Indigenous workforce representation. Recent NIHEC initiatives include projects to: Map workforce development initiatives (the “Helicopter Project”); Articulate the parameters of a forward-looking workforce agenda in Indigenous health (the “Visions/Futures” Project); and Develop a national instrument for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health goals and targets. NIHEC has also agreed to provide strategic advice supporting the implementation of COAG’s 2008 $1.5 billion investment in Indigenous health.

Ian Anderson

Indigenous health Close the gap May 2009 Free

Close the Gap: dentistry

Enhancement of public dental services will improve dental care to the most disadvantaged Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples have higher levels of dental disease, including more untreated tooth decay and gum disease, than other Australians. Those who do receive treatment have fewer preventive appointments and many more extractions. The impact on general health of dental disease is significant. When inadequately treated, dental diseases can result in higher rates of malnutrition, low birthweight, preterm births and cardiovascular disease. Many Indigenous Australians have insufficient teeth to eat nourishing foods. To close the gap in oral health for Indigenous Australians requires: fluoridation of community water supplies; more Indigenous dentists, dental therapists and dental hygienists; coherent oral health promotion strategies and an Indigenous oral health dataset; and high-quality, comprehensive and culturally appropriate oral health care services organised and coordinated on a regional basis. These goals require federal government resources and coordination. The proposal of the National Health and Hospitals Reform Commission to provide Medicare funding for dentistry will not help close the gap. Schemes based upon universal access, such as Medicare, do not serve disadvantaged groups well. Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme data, highlighted by the Close the Gap campaign, show per-capita spending on Indigenous health to be half that of spending on non-Indigenous health, despite an incidence of ill health three to four times higher for Indigenous Australians. Medicare-funded dentistry will primarily benefit the better-off in Australian society, and Indigenous Australians will be, in relative terms, further disadvantaged. To provide dental care to the most disadvantaged, current government spending of $1.5 billion on dentistry must be used to build up public dental services. Funds made available by ending the Medicare Enhanced Primary Care dental program, the Medicare Teen Dental Plan, and the private health insurance rebate would, along with existing resources, enable the reinvigoration of public dentistry. Indigenous Australians could then access the culturally appropriate, comprehensive, high-quality care that ought to be a hallmark of public dentistry.

Christopher J Bourke

Indigenous health Close the gap May 2009 Free

Close the Gap: Aboriginal community controlled health services

Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples have a right to full participation in decisions affecting their health During 2008, the Council of Australian Governments (COAG) made several large-scale funding commitments to close the gap in life expectancy between Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal peoples, and to improve Indigenous child health. These commitments represent a significant first step, but the funding package was devised without the full and active involvement of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples — the process failed to comply with the Close the gap statement of intent, which commits all partners to ensuring “the full participation of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples and their representative bodies in all aspects of addressing their health needs”. The challenge now is to turn the COAG proposals into programs that will work for the Aboriginal community, particularly for those who are most disadvantaged. To this end, committing to the partnership forums established over the past 10 years between Aboriginal community controlled health services (ACCHSs) and state, territory and Australian Government health departments will be critical. At the national level, ensuring the effectiveness and appropriateness of federal programs is difficult, given there has never been a formal partnership between the Australian Government and the Aboriginal community on health matters. A national framework agreement between the Department of Health and Ageing and the National Aboriginal Community Controlled Health Organisation (NACCHO) will ensure Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples are in control of their health. NACCHO represents over 145 ACCHSs across Australia, which provide the vast bulk of comprehensive primary health care to Aboriginal peoples. Making sure the programs that result from the COAG commitments are in large part realised through the ACCHSs is critical to closing the gap in Aboriginal disadvantage. A national framework agreement between NACCHO and government will ensure Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander peoples have the right to full participation in health service design, delivery, monitoring and evaluation. Such an agreement will set the stage for improvements in four key areas: joint planning processes to allow for full participation in decision making and priority setting; transparent and regular reporting; improved service delivery through greater cooperation among key players, and more efficient coordination; and better understanding among key players of one another’s roles and responsibilities. Every inquiry over the past 30 years has confirmed that ACCHSs are the most effective means to close the gap.

Mick Adams

Subscribe to
MJA email alerts

No spam, you can unsubscribe anytime you want.

By providing your information, you agree to our Terms of Use and our Privacy Policy.

Good one! Your updates are coming

Thank you for subscribing to the MJA email alerts. Receive the latest content in your inbox.