Topics

Indigenous health

Indigenous health Dr Ross Ingram Memorial Competition May 2011 Free

Talking about hepatitis

Hepatitis C is a blood-borne virus, and so in this poster the Aboriginal communities in Victoria are represented as blood cells, holding hands to indicate community strength, and coming together to talk about hepatitis and injecting drug use. Hepatitis C is very much an issue for urban Aboriginal communities in Australia. By coming together we encourage conversations about the more marginalised people in the community who are affected by the virus, and, ultimately, help to prevent and treat this disease. Click here for a larger version of this graphic.

Peter C Waples-Crowe MMS

Wap10202 fm 1big 0
Indigenous health Dr Ross Ingram Memorial Competition May 2011 Free

Mental illness or spiritual illness: what should we call it?

With permission from my son I am able to tell this story. I have not used his name for privacy reasons. I would like to dedicate this essay to the many Indigenous people who have passed away in psychiatric hospitals and did not make it home to their families and communities. “Historical trauma” is defined as the subjective experiencing and remembering of events in the mind of an individual or the life of a community, passed from adults to children in cyclic processes as “collective emotional and psychological injury . . . over the life span and across generations”.1 I was raised in a foster family from the age of two, in suburban Brisbane, Queensland, with three of my siblings. I am a proud Aboriginal woman with close family ties across south-east Queensland and the north coast of New South Wales. My mother is from the Wakka Wakka clan group in Cherbourg and Brisbane. My father is from the Gumbaynggir and Dunghutti communities of the north-coast region of New South Wales. Recently, I arrived in Canberra from Brisbane with my son to take up a Research Fellowship with the Australian Institute of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Studies. My research is on the question of “Mental health: what treatment options are working for Indigenous peoples?”. I have chosen this topic because of my personal experience as a mother. The day before we left our home in Margate, a suburb in the north of Brisbane on Moreton Bay, to travel to Canberra, we attended my son’s mental health review tribunal hearing, an event that was life-changing for both of us. My son has suffered from a mental illness (schizophrenia) for many years, which saw him hospitalised for ten-and-a-half years. During this time he was on a forensic order as an involuntary patient, because of crimes he had committed while being unwell. I was expecting to be seeking the tribunal’s permission to take my son interstate for the three months that I would be working. Instead, to our surprise, his forensic order was revoked, meaning he was able to leave Queensland and live wherever he wanted. Overwhelmed by the decision, my son kept repeatedly asking the tribunal panel what it meant for him. As a mother I have struggled, mostly because I was only seventeen years old when my son was born. Of course, you can never imagine or prepare yourself for the way life can take such a turn some twenty years later. I had lived with my biological mother on and off since I was fifteen, so she took on significant caring responsibilities for my baby, who was her first grandchild. She was very close to him. My mother had also suffered from “mental illness” as a young woman and had been hospitalised (I don’t know how many times). I remember being told about it in quite a negative way. Mum was admitted to what was the “old” Wolston Park Hospital some forty years ago. This hospital was located on the same grounds as the hospital called The Park, Centre for Mental Health, where my son has spent his years. She had grown up in Cherbourg Aboriginal community in Queensland where she spent some of her childhood in the dormitory while her mother travelled away for work. I know she did not have good memories of the dormitory days, as she later shared some stories with me about the abuse that she witnessed and was subjected to in the dormitory. My mother died at the age of fifty-seven from kidney failure caused by diabetes, when my son was only twelve. What I have read and come to understand about transgenerational trauma within Indigenous communities is that the suffering of individuals and communities from trauma and pain results in many unresolved issues not just for those immediately affected, but for those around them, their families and their descendants, and from what I know about my family history the trauma reaches much further than my mother. Personal experience has left me with no doubt that transgenerational trauma contributed to the mental/spiritual unwellness of both my mother and my son. After my mother’s death our lives changed dramatically. I was in deep grief. It was difficult to “be there” emotionally, or in any other way, for my son. I felt vulnerable and extremely fragile. The grief was unbearable. It took me to a place that I found hard to come back from, to the point where I thought that I would die from it. At the time part of me wanted to. Fortunately, I did come back, just as my son was about to travel down his own road of self-destruction, which began with bizarre behaviour patterns. At about age fourteen, he started to use drugs — first marijuana, then amphetamines, known on the street as speed. This is a parent’s nightmare. Drug taking was not something I had experience with, nor did I expect this to be happening to my child. What followed was years of risky behaviour, crime, eventually juvenile detention and then prison! As a mother, the pain of this is beyond imagination: it reaches into the very core of you. When your child is locked away, you are too. I was overcome with feelings of shame and guilt. I felt emotionally, psychologically and spiritually immobilised and trapped within myself. Of course, eventually it took its toll on my mental and physical health, and I was diagnosed with my own life-threatening illnesses. One of the many challenges was dealing with blame from people who were close to me. Some made conscious and unconscious hurtful comments because of their own pain and lack of understanding of my son’s illness. We also experienced discrimination arising from the general community’s ignorance of mental illness. When going out in public — going shopping, for instance — people would stare, laugh or make comments. The effects of this trauma are still with me today. In prison, my son’s mental illness started to become very obvious, through the signs of self-harm, and symptoms of mental unwellness such as crying and responding to voices. Eventually, he was hospitalised and I visited him regularly, took him on leave many times and had him living with me for short periods. Unfortunately, he was so unwell that he would abscond from the hospital, and would run away from me as well. This caused immense anxiety, not only for me and our family and friends, but also for staff at the hospital who were genuinely concerned about his welfare. My son would go missing for days, sometimes weeks, without his medication. The police were, of course, alerted and it was their responsibility to find him, but I would usually locate him before they did, and would then seek help from the Indigenous workers or nurses to return him safely to hospital. This happened on many occasions. Throughout these years of experience with my son and his illness, there were many moments when I questioned my own thoughts and feelings. I did know, however, that I was experiencing something that was deeply spiritual and unknown. My son’s thin and pale, ghost-like appearance haunted me, and I could feel him detaching from what was real. That is why it was important for me to be around to keep the strong spiritual and emotional bond between us — I knew from a sickening feeling inside me there was a very real risk of losing him through suicide. He was haunted by voices, and would respond by talking to people that he believed were real. Sometimes he was happy and laughing along with them; other times he would be screaming back at them to leave him alone, and would cry in a very mournful way that made me cry as well. I remember all this very vividly, especially the times at night when I would lie awake listening to him talking in another language which I knew to be an Aboriginal language. This did freak me out a little, as he appeared to be having conversations and speaking the language fluently. I thought that I was imagining what I had heard until family members and workers at the hospital told me that they had witnessed him doing the same thing. It was through this experience that I came to know and believe that Indigenous mental illness is also spiritual illness, as it is deeply connected to our spirituality and cultural beliefs. I also believe that this spiritual connection is what helped my son get through his illness to where he is today. A quote from the Schizophrenia Fellowship of NSW newsletter has been helpful in supporting my thoughts around mental–spiritual illness. Wellbeing is an holistic and collective issue, with specific individual health problems being of little relevance if not considered as part of wider social, spiritual and community health . . . Mental illness or disturbance may be seen as a ‘soreness of the spirit’ caused by loss of social and family networks, destruction of kinship and family, dislocation from ancestral lands and the conflict between tradition and the pressures of trying to exist within and alongside European culture.2 On one very memorable visit to the hospital I sat with the treating psychiatrist to discuss my son’s “progress”. She explained to me that there were “two very sick patients in the hospital at the time, [my son] being one of them”, and that “out of the two, he [was] the most unwell”. In a roundabout way, I guess she was trying to tell me that my son was the sickest patient in the hospital at that moment. To this day I don’t remember how I drove myself home. During his long hospital stay of over ten years, my son lost elders and friends, mostly Indigenous patients, who passed away in hospital. He dealt with this in his own way, showing courage and strength. The thought was always at the back of my mind that he himself would not survive. I questioned myself all the time as to whether I was in denial of the possibility that he would be institutionalised forever, but remained convinced that it was important to rise above this thinking, and to try to stay positive, and most of all to believe that things can change and be different. My son is now very well, the best he could possibly be. He lives with me full-time and is actively seeking employment. I have presented at workshops on mental illness in Indigenous communities and received positive responses from people who appreciated honesty and openness in talking about this sensitive area. There is definitely a need for more understanding and education in our communities so people can come together to share and talk openly without any shame or blame. I always tell people that talking about it and seeking help can mean the difference between life or death for a loved one. Through the years, I have always felt very strongly that “someone” was around, guiding me through this time in our lives. I listened to the messages and acted intuitively, particularly when my son was at his most critical times of illness, and the times when he went missing from the hospital. I give many thanks to all the people who were there supporting us on this long journey, such as family, friends, hospital staff and community, who gave us hope and encouragement. If it weren’t for them, I know we would not be here today to tell this story. This story is difficult to tell because I know that I will be revisiting the trauma, reliving the memories of events that took place, and visualising the images that will forever haunt me. With permission from my son, I wanted to document and share this story in the hope that it may give strength and support to some other family who is going through the same or similar circumstances.

Lindy L Moffatt DipCommWelfareWork

Indigenous health Dr Ross Ingram Memorial Competition May 2011 Free

Closing gaps, maintaining cadence and removing trampolines: a personal reflection on 20 years in health

A number of inquiries have drawn attention to the unacceptable gap between the physical health status of Aborigines and that of the remainder of the community. The House of Representatives Standing Committee on Aboriginal Affairs report, Aboriginal Health, and the National Trachoma and Eye Health Program of the Royal [Australian] College of Ophthalmologists are recent examples. Comparatively little attention, however, has been given to the mental health needs of Aborigines.1 Health is overratedI arrive at work, sweaty but satisfied, 50 minutes or so after leaving home. “Closing the gap is going to kill me!”, I joke with a colleague as I haul my bicycle up the stairs. My efforts to delay the sprawl of a once moderately shaped midsection mean that I arrive at work at least once but ideally up to three times a week in this manner. As much as my two young boys enjoy using that expanding part of my anatomy as a surrogate trampoline, I felt its recent growth spurt demanded some attention. On reviewing my shape, taunts of my unappreciated high school nickname, “Fat Garvs”, began to revisit my consciousness. This, coupled with an awareness of the high hospitalisation and mortality rates associated with cardiovascular disease for Indigenous men aged 35–44, meant that I was unable to sustain the delusions that my clothes had mysteriously shrunk during winter; that it was OK to be breathing a little heavier from a strenuous round trip to the mail box; and that watching sport burns the same number of calories as doing sport. For the most part, it is easy to be distracted during the morning ride from Fremantle to Bentley. Majestic black swans and other waterbirds meander by along the Derbarl Yerrigan, pausing now and then to graze happily on its banks. By comparison, I imagine cars and other vehicles crawling by on congested roads, pausing now and then to wait impatiently at traffic lights. My laboured breathing belies the fact that I am glad of my choice of transport and the environment through which I propel it. The journey home, however, is another story. There is the “Fremantle Doctor” to contend with — an afternoon sea breeze, often blowing between 15 and 20 knots and penetrating as far as 100 kilometres inland. It provides welcome relief from the heat of the day, but little relief for those attempting to travel against it by bicycle. The potential of this force to both help and hinder isn’t lost on me, but on some days it’s easy to feel ambivalent towards the bloody Doctor! “Yep, closing the gap is going to kill me”, I joke to myself through gritted teeth as I press on, searching for a gear that allows me to keep a steady cadence into the headwind. The ride to and from work oscillates between enjoyment and pain as I negotiate serene distraction and powerful opposition. Maintaining momentum in the face of the latter can be difficult; however, I know that my thoughts about the conditions can mediate their influence on the journey. An unbearable, hopeless, pointless slog is draining, whereas regarding the ride as a challenge invokes (for a competitive person like me) a sense of energy and purpose. Can I turn the pedals five more times at this rate? What about five more? Five becomes ten, and so on, and before long an intermediate goal is reached — a tree 100 metres up the road, another cyclist, a street sign — something to aim for, and a small success to celebrate ... until the next landmark. I find strategies like these give focus and permit completion, while overcoming the struggle provides a sense of achievement likely to prompt another effort tomorrow. This is good, because removing a trampoline isn’t done in a day. The changing nature of workWork is a little different at the moment. It is still at a university — the same one at which I have been employed for close to two decades. In the beginning, I was invited to join the counselling and mental health program being developed at the Centre for Aboriginal Studies (CAS). As a recently graduated psychologist, it was felt that my expertise would be of use to the course and its students — Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people from many parts of Australia, diverse yet united in their desire to participate in the restoration and promotion of the social and emotional wellbeing of their families and communities. This meant leaving Cairns and my role in community mental health, but the lure of a new experience and an adventure in the west was too good to miss. “It will only be for two years”, I told myself and others when I departed. Eighteen years later, I am still reminded of this promise during visits home. The program we developed set the benchmark for some time, cresting the wave of an unprecedented focus on Indigenous mental health that was heralded and constructed in such landmark publications and events as the Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody,2 the National Inquiry into the Human Rights of People with Mental Illness,3 the first National Aboriginal Mental Health Conference in Sydney in 1993, the “Ways forward” consultancy report on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander mental health,4 and the “Bringing them home” report.5 However, tremors in the Indigenous mental health arena had been felt earlier, along with an attendant frustration at the lack of meaningful response.6 The opening quote of this essay is illustrative of the relative neglect of Indigenous mental health. Perhaps surprisingly, it is not sourced from any recent report but is an observation made 31 years ago in the foreword to a special “mental health” issue of the Aboriginal Health Worker Journal.1 More recently, on the eve of National Close the Gap Day 2011, these old concerns are being echoed.7 While the Close the Gap campaign is commemorating its fifth anniversary of mobilising the current generation’s efforts in Indigenous health, discussion of a mental health gap for Indigenous Australian people was occurring at least a generation earlier. The 1990s also saw a change in the way that my profession sought to engage with Indigenous Australian people — a relational gap of sorts — prompted by the aforementioned documents and at the insistence of a small but active Indigenous membership. In 1995 I was able to observe an interested, ambivalent and curious audience watch the first Aboriginal keynote address to the Australian Psychological Society, delivered by Aboriginal leader and activist Robert Riley. I knew Rob as the man who had taken me, sight unseen, into his home during my initial weeks in Perth. He was a supporter of the CAS, and his offer of accommodation was brokered thanks to his friendship with the then Head of the Centre, Pat Dudgeon. I would argue that Rob’s challenge to the profession to examine its consideration of Indigenous people retains currency within and beyond psychology.8 I would also lament his tragic passing not long after, and question what else I should have done with my supposed expertise to assist him to maintain cadence in the significant headwinds he encountered. Of that period at the CAS, I recall with fondness and frustration the late nights spent preparing student workbooks, the friendships forged and fractured by debates over self-determination and mental health competencies and, of course, how we were meant to assess this stuff in ways demonstrative of student utility, academic rigour and community appropriateness! With our attention well and truly focused on the conceptual and practical requirements of course delivery, I doubt we took the time (or had the time) to consider the symbolic significance of our endeavours — the collaborations, real, messy and imperfect, that arose as we attempted to negotiate and reconcile the kinds of cross-cultural and interpersonal tensions involved in facilitating Indigenous health. It was in many ways a journey into the unknown; an intense and tumultuous time. I remember feeling part of something special, something important, and that we persevered and problem-solved in uncharted territory. I also remember burning out after about two years, to the point where I was unable to recognise the destructive symptoms and had to be told, in no uncertain terms, to take a break. I had tried to keep up with seemingly inexhaustible mentors and a relentless workload; possible for a time, and made easier by the excitement and novelty of the endeavour. Ironically, though, I would fall foul of the very advice we gave our students — to look after themselves in order to avoid such a state of exhaustion, and to be wary of the expectation placed on them to be “superhuman” health workers. The maxim “if you don’t look after yourself, you won’t be of any use to others” rang true as a description of my own debilitated state (one from which I would, thankfully, recover). If there was any consolation, at least I could now use personal experience to illustrate the lesson, and pursue a more sustainable tempo. New landmarksWhile my roles and goals have changed over the years, one constant has remained — an annual ritual of PhD avoidance. A new year’s resolution to enrol would be broken as semester-based demands were allowed to take priority. However, the mantra of “there’s always next year” becomes less reassuring when considered in the context of the gap. Indigenous people get to use the “there’s always next year” excuse some 15–20 fewer times than other Australians, on average, so, statistically at least, now was the time to focus on that next landmark. It should come as no surprise that the research I am pursuing concerns what has been described as “the tensely contested arena” of Indigenous mental health.9 This is motivated by my own questions and experiences of the arena, and by the thousands of conversations over 20 years with people interested in, ambivalent about and curious about the social and emotional wellbeing of Indigenous Australian people. To continue the metaphor, I am not only interested in the tension and conflict apparent on the arena’s floor, but what characterises the hypogeum (Greek for “underground”). In an arena, this refers to a subsurface network of channels and compartments that house combatants, props and other gladiatorial paraphernalia that would eventually be released into the main stage. In terms of my research, it involves an examination of the discursive resources and deeply held myths and metaphors about wellness, relationships and services that have formed Indigenous mental health, and the attendant tense and conflicting responses to it over time. My research is also concerned with bridging and negotiating gaps between people — addressing those enduring dilemmas10 involving the providers, consumers and designers of Indigenous mental health services. My sense is that, until and unless we are willing to consider the role of these less apparent yet influential linguistic and ideational precursors, we will continue to experience conflict in the arena, and the gap-centred litany, such as that in the opening quote, will endure. Moving forwardMy 20 years in health have been characterised by achievements and disappointments, friends made and lost, and lessons often learned the hard way. I maintain a sense of optimism inspired by the Indigenous and non-Indigenous people I’ve met who, despite the challenges, remain committed to Indigenous health. If my time in health and my more recent forays into healthy activity have taught me anything, it is that it is worthwhile setting goals, adopting attitudes and behaving in ways that support a sustainable rhythm over the long term. This is not to say that bursts of energy and enthusiasm aren’t useful or necessary; it is just that shining brightly can often mean shining briefly. My advice to those who choose to engage with the health concerns of Indigenous Australian people or who are about to graduate to such endeavours? Work to maintain a healthy cadence. Negotiate reasonable goals. Develop ways of enduring those inevitable headwinds, and take the time to acknowledge and celebrate landmarks reached. And do be interested in the momentum of others, especially when their tempo is flagging. For me, in addition to a renewed work focus, I have recently been given two beautiful reasons to remain personally and professionally invested in health. If I can build bridges for my sons to negotiate their way with their own “bloody Doctors”, and in any way contribute to their life’s quality as well as its longevity, then the ride will have been worth it. Unfortunately though, while Ollie and Elliot get immeasurable joy from pounding my midsection with their energetic play, I need to say, “Sorry boys, daddy’s trampoline won’t be there much longer. But don’t worry, he’ll be able to get you a real one with the money he saves on new clothes!”

Darren C Garvey BPsych, PostGradCertEd, MHlthProm

Indigenous health Body mind matters May 2011 Free

Racism as a determinant of social and emotional wellbeing for Aboriginal Australian youth

Objective: To explore the associations between self-reported racism and health and wellbeing outcomes for young Aboriginal Australian people.Design, setting and participants: A cross-sectional study of 345 Aboriginal Australians aged 16–20 years who, as participants in the prospective Aboriginal Birth Cohort Study, were recruited at birth between 1987 and 1990 and followed up between 2006 and 2008.Main outcome measures: Self-reported social and emotional wellbeing using a questionnaire validated as culturally appropriate for the study’s participants; recorded body mass index and waist-to-hip ratio.Results: Self-reported racism was reported by 32% of study participants. Racism was significantly associated with anxiety (odds ratio [OR], 2.18 [95% CI, 1.37–3.46]); depression (OR, 2.16 [95% CI, 1.33–3.53]); suicide risk (OR, 2.32 [95% CI, 1.25–4.00]); and poor overall mental health (OR, 3.35 [95% CI, 2.04–5.51]). No significant associations were found between self-reported racism and resilience or any anthropometric measures.Conclusions: Self-reported racism was associated with poor social and emotional wellbeing outcomes, including anxiety, depression, suicide risk and poor overall mental health.

Naomi C Priest BAppSci(Hons),PhD · Yin C Paradies MMedStats, MPH, PhD · Wendy Gunthorpe BPsych, PhD · Sheree J Cairney BAppSci, PhD · Sue M Sayers PhD

Indigenous health Body mind matters May 2011 Free

The transformative potential of young motherhood for disadvantaged Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander women in Townsville, Australia

Objective: To explore attitudes to pregnancy and parenthood among a group of Indigenous young people in Townsville, Australia.Design and participants: Mixed methods and a cross-sectional design involving Indigenous women from a Young Mums Group designing the research instruments and acting as peer interviewers. Data were collected in 2004 from young Indigenous people who had never been pregnant (171 students at three high schools and 15 people at a homeless youth shelter) using a computer-assisted self-administered survey; from 59 of this group who also participated in single sex focus group discussions; and from 10 pregnant and parenting young women in individual semi-structured interviews.Main outcome measure: Self-reported attitudes and behaviour about aspirations, pregnancy and parenthood.Results: Only eight of 186 young Indigenous people who had never been pregnant reported wanting to have a child as a teenager. Large proportions of this group of 186 reported idealised views about pregnancy, particularly young men, with 50.5% reporting that being a parent would always be enjoyable, and 62.6% reporting that being a mother or a father would not change their lives. Idealised views were associated with earlier sexual initiation (P = 0.001). Issues identified in the narratives of young mothers related to difficult backgrounds, pregnancy “just happening” to them, and the transformative impact of having a child on their lives and aspirations.Conclusions: Accurate parenting information may be necessary to address unrealistic views about parenting among Indigenous young people. Young Indigenous parents often come from extremely disadvantaged backgrounds, and becoming a parent may be the impetus for positive change.

Sarah L Larkins MB BS, MPH · R Priscilla Page Cert III Aboriginal Health Work (Clinical) · Kathryn S Panaretto MB BS, MPH, FAFPHM · Melvina Mitchell EN · Valerie Alberts MSocPol, GradCertTeaching, GradCertPHCResearch · Suzanne McGinty DipEd, MA, PhD · P Craig Veitch DipAppSci(RT), BA, PhD

Indigenous health Body mind matters May 2011 Free

Maternal smoking and smoking in the household during pregnancy and postpartum: findings from an Indigenous cohort in the Northern Territory

Objective: To describe the trends in maternal smoking and smoking in the household for a cohort of Indigenous women followed from late pregnancy to 7 months postpartum.Design and setting: Prospective cohort study embedded within a randomised controlled trial (RCT) performed in the Northern Territory involving participants recruited between 30 June 2006 and 4 May 2010.Participants: 215 Indigenous women aged 17–39 years who had been recruited into the RCT, 162 of whom had completed their last study visit at 7 months postpartum by 1 June 2010.Main outcome measures: Smoking status of women, and smoking within their households, in their third trimester, and at 1 month, 2 months and 7 months postpartum.Results: There were complete data on women’s smoking status for 121 participants. Among these, the self-reported smoking rate was 45% (95% CI, 36%–55%) during pregnancy, increasing to 63% (95% CI, 54%–71%) at 7 months postpartum. Of the 66 women who were non-smokers at the antenatal visit, 23 (35%; 95% CI, 23%–47%) were smoking by the time their baby reached 7 months of age. Thirty-one per cent (95% CI, 23%–39%) of households included people who smoked inside during the antepartum period, whereas 16% (95% CI, 10%–23%) included people who smoked inside at 7 months postpartum.Conclusions: While an apparent reduction in indoor exposure to tobacco smoke during the postpartum period is encouraging, this is offset by an increase in the proportion of antenatal non-smokers who subsequently reported smoking after the birth of their child. More health care service delivery and research attention needs to be directed to smoking during pregnancy and to postpartum relapse in this population.

Vanessa Johnston MB BS, MPH, PhD · David P Thomas MMedSc, FAFPHM, PhD · Joseph McDonnell MSc, GradDipCompSci · Ross M Andrews MAppEpid, MPH, PhD

Indigenous health Shalom Gamarada Ngiyani Yana Art Exhibition May 2011 Free

Shalom Gamarada Ngiyani Yana 2010

I have been living at Shalom College for four years. It has been a life-changing experience for me. I have had time to work hard at uni, in a racism-free environment in which Indigenous students can live proudly. Without this scholarship it would be impossible for me to study medicine as there is no way my family could afford for me to live in Sydney.— Josef McDonald, 5th Year Medicine, University of New South Wales, Shalom Gamarada Scholarship Recipient The Shalom Gamarada scholarship program is funded both by the sale of work by Aboriginal artists at the annual, week-long Shalom Gamarada Ngiyani Yana exhibition and by the provision of scholarships by private donors and corporate sponsors. The name of the program comes from the term “gamarada ngiyani yana” in the Eora language and translates to “we walk together as friends.” “Shalom” is a Hebrew word, meaning peace and is part of the name of the Shalom College at the University of NSW. The program was founded in 2005. In 2010, the sixth exhibition and sale will run from 27th June to 4th July. This year's contributors include the internationally renowned contemporary Indigenous artist, Judy Watson. Other artists include Regina Wilson, Weaver Jack, Jan Billycan and Shorty Jangala Robertson. There will be much sought after ceramic works from the Bagu community from Girringun in Queensland. This year, we will be displaying specially commissioned walls which will include works from Utopia and commissioned installations from Yuendumu and Peppimenarti. For the first time, the exhibition will present new work from the community of Martumili from the Pilbara. Exhibition audiences will be offered a unique opportunity to experience an incredible and diverse range of Indigenous art practice from across Australia. Shalom Gamarada will showcase an extensive range of more than 120 stretched artworks hanging and many more unstretched works, some of which can be seen in this issue of the Journal (Box 1, Box 2, Box 3, Box 4, Box 5, Box 6, Box 7, Box 8, Box 9, Box 10), with a total value of over one million dollars. All artworks will be available for purchase, with prices ranging from a modest $150 to more than $25,000. Commissions from all art sales go to residential scholarships for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Medical students at Shalom College. The Shalom Gamarada scholarship program was set up in 2005 to boost the numbers of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander medical students attending the University of NSW and runs in partnership with the UNSW’s Shalom College and the Muru Marri Indigenous Health Unit. Since its inception, the Shalom Gamarada Aboriginal art exhibition has been able to assist 24 students to study medicine, optometry and medical science, covering board and lodging expenses so students are able to focus solely on excelling in their studies. Each scholarship is valued at over $15 000 per year for the duration of the degree. We graduated our first Shalom Gamarada doctor in December 2009, Dr Beth Kervan. This year, another scholarship recipient and UNSW’s first Aboriginal optometry student, Jenna Owen — who was the top student in 4th Year Optometry in 2009 — will graduate. Details of the Exhibition and show Open: 11 am to 7 pm each day from 27 June to 4 July Address: Caspary Learning Centre, Shalom College, University of New South Wales, Kensington (enter via Barker St) Admission: Free More information: visit http://www.shalomgamarada.org/ or call Professor Lisa Jackson Pulver on 0404 859 989. Artist: Paddy Sims 1. Artist: Regina Wilson 2. Artist: Shorty Jangala Robertson 3. Artist: Jakayu Biljabu 4. Artist: Collaborative work by Mangkaja Arts, Fitzroy Crossing, WA 5. Artist: Wakartu Cory Surprise 6. Artist: Jimmy McKenzie 7. Artist: Judy Watson 8. Artist: Regina Wilson 9. Artist: Regina Wilson 10. Artist: Kathleen Petyarre The dance of life (cover image) Artist: Helen Milroy The dance of life painting is the last in a series depicting a multidimensional model of health and wellbeing from an Aboriginal perspective. The final painting brings all of the dimensions together to reflect the delicate balance of life within the universe. The dimensions include the biological or physical dimension, the psychological or emotional dimension, the social dimension, the spiritual dimension and finally, but most importantly, the cultural dimension. Within each dimension, there are additional layers to consider, including the historical context, traditional and contemporary views as well as gaps in our knowledge. The potential solutions for healing and restoration of wellbeing come from considering additional factors encompassing issues at the coalface of symptom presentation and service delivery, such as education and training, policy, sociopolitical context and international perspective. As this painting suggests, we can only exist if firmly grounded and supported by our community and spirituality, while always reflecting back on culture in order to hold our heads up high to grow and reach forward to the experiences life has waiting for us. The stories of our ancestors, the collective grief as well as healing, begin from knowing where we have come from and where we are heading. From the Aboriginal perspective, carrying the past with you into the future is as it should be. We are nothing but for those who have been before, and the children of the future will look back and reflect on us today. When we enable a person to restore all of the dimensions of their life, then we have achieved a great deal. When all of the dimensions are in balance within the universe, we can break free of our shackles and truly dance through life.

Lisa R Jackson Pulver

Indigenous health Shalom Gamarada Ngiyani Yana Art Exhibition May 2011 Free

Shalom Gamarada Ngiyani Yana 2011

Paintings from the Shalom Gamarada Ngiyani Yana Art Exhibition are featured throughout this issue (shown below). The sale of these artworks by acclaimed Aboriginal artists supports the Shalom Gamarada Indigenous Scholarship Program at the University of New South Wales (UNSW), a collaboration between Shalom College (a residential college at the UNSW) and the Muru Marri Indigenous Health Unit, School of Public Health and Community Medicine at UNSW. For more information about the exhibition and sale, and the scholarship program, see the Shalom Gamarada website: http://www.shalomgamarada.org. Artist: Shorty Robertson Artist: Lydia Balbal Artist: Shorty Robertson Artist: Lydia Balbal Artist: Regina Wilson Artist: Lydia Balbal Artist: Gloria Petyarre Artist: Alma Nungarrayi Artist: Elaine Thomas Artist: Judy Napangardi Watson Artist: Shorty Robertson

The health of urban Aboriginal people: insufficient data to close the gap

To the Editor: Eades and colleagues identify the scarcity of data on the health and health care needs of Aboriginal Australians.1 This is particularly so for Aboriginal children in urban settings. The Gudaga Study2 has actively worked to redress this shortcoming. The Gudaga Study (Gudaga being an Aboriginal word meaning healthy baby) is a longitudinal study of a birth cohort of Aboriginal infants born at a large outer urban hospital.2 Gudaga staff use methods that respect the values and beliefs of Aboriginal Australians3 to systematically collect information on the health, development, and service use of study participants at 6-monthly intervals. The Gudaga research team is working with the stakeholders in Aboriginal health in the region to discuss the implications of the information for policy and practice. A number of scientific articles are currently being prepared for publication. These include articles on birth outcomes, breastfeeding, universal health home visiting, health status and service use, development, and vaccination. Information collected by the Gudaga Study is contributing to the development of services for Aboriginal families in the region, and is changing the ways that service providers think about the health and service needs of Aboriginal families in the region. For example, the lack of data created difficulty in securing funding for services for pregnant Aboriginal women. Enumeration of the high rates of sudden infant death syndrome (3/149) and the removal of children by the Department of Community Services among participating infants (11/149 over 4 years) as a part of the Gudaga Study had two important effects. It influenced the public health service response to close the gap on Aboriginal disadvantage and influenced the decision to reorient child and family services and establish the Bulundidi Gudaga program with ongoing funding. The Bulundidi Gudaga program provides sustained home visiting of pregnant Aboriginal women and their infants by nurses, commencing during pregnancy and continuing until the infant is aged 2 years.4 This research developed over several years. It began during discussions with the Aboriginal community at Tharawal Aboriginal Corporation, Campbelltown, who raised concerns about the health of their children, difficulties in securing funding for an Aboriginal infant and maternal home visiting service that commenced 1999, the lack of relevant data on the needs of Aboriginal children, and receipt of National Health and Medical Research Council funding in 2003. The Gudaga Study commenced in 2005, and the first of the participating children are turning 5 years of age. The research is now part of a strong research program at the University of New South Wales into the health and development of Aboriginal children in urban settings.

Elizabeth J Comino · Lisa R Jackson Pulver · Jenny A Knight

The relationship between influenza and invasive pneumococcal disease in the Northern Territory, 2005–2009

To the Editor: Following the 1918 influenza pandemic, during which an estimated 50 million people died,1 the relationship between influenza and secondary bacterial infections such as Streptococcus pneumoniae (pneumococcus) became recognised as an area of considerable scientific importance. It has been shown that influenza infection results in epithelial damage, up-regulation and exposure of respiratory tract receptors, alterations in the immune response and increased adherence of pneumococcus.2 The most severe form of pneumococcal infection, invasive pneumococcal disease (IPD), has a mortality of 7%–9%.3 It occurs frequently in the Indigenous population of the Northern Territory, with an incidence of 70.5 per 100 000, compared with 7 per 100 000 in Australia overall.3 In population studies, 11%–20% of seasonal increases in IPD have been attributed to influenza.4,5 During the increase in influenza notifications in 2009 in the NT, as a result of pandemic H1N1 (2009) influenza, a concurrent increase in IPD notifications was also recorded. Our study aimed to investigate whether there was a relationship between influenza and subsequent IPD. We calculated the relative risk of IPD in the 4 weeks after laboratory-confirmed influenza compared with the background risk. Cases were defined as patients who were diagnosed with IPD within 4 weeks of laboratory-confirmed influenza being diagnosed. Data concerning cases of influenza and IPD between 2005 and 2009 were extracted from the NT Notifiable Diseases System and merged by date of birth using Stata, version 11 (StataCorp, College Station, Texas, USA), leading to 75 matches. The 75 matched records were checked individually to determine whether they met the case definition, resulting in eight potential cases. Demographic characteristics (name, sex, Indigenous status and address) were then checked to confirm the match. One case was excluded, leaving seven cases eligible for analysis. We identified 2567 cases of influenza and 346 cases of IPD in the study period. The risk of IPD within 4 weeks of influenza was calculated as 7/2567 (2.7 × 10-3). To calculate the background risk of IPD in a 4-week period, we first calculated the annual risk of IPD occurring without previous influenza (339/1 076 470 person-years) and divided this by the number of 4-week periods in a year (13). This gave a background risk of 2.42 × 10-5 and a relative risk of 112.5 (95% CI, 48.9–224.8; χ2 = 758.3; P < 0.001). This analysis is based on population surveillance data, and is therefore limited by the possibility of ascertainment bias due to variations in influenza testing. Nevertheless, our study provides additional evidence that IPD is an important complication of influenza, and reinforces the need for clinicians to promote influenza vaccination in high-risk individuals and to be aware of complications which may occur in the weeks after the initial viral infection. Additionally, achieving high coverage of pneumococcal vaccination in at-risk groups will reduce the impact of influenza.

Laura J Edwards · Peter G Markey · Heather M Cook · James M Trauer · Vicki L Krause

Indigenous health Public health February 2011 Free

Iodine status of Aboriginal teenagers in the Darwin region before mandatory iodine fortification of bread

Objective: To determine the iodine status of participants in the Aboriginal Birth Cohort Study who resided in the Darwin Health Region (DHR) in the “Top End” of the Northern Territory prior to the introduction of mandatory iodine fortification of bread.Design, setting and participants: Participants in our study had been recruited at birth and were followed up at a mean age of 17.8 years. Spot urine samples were collected and assessed for iodine concentration at a reference laboratory. The median urinary iodine concentration (MUIC) of residents of the DHR was calculated and compared with international criteria for iodine status. Analyses were conducted for subgroups living in urban areas (Darwin–Palmerston) and remote communities (rural with an Aboriginal council). We collected a repeat sample in a subset of participants to explore the impact of within-person variation on the results.Main outcome measure: MUIC for residents of the DHR.Results: Urine specimens were provided by 376 participants in the DHR. Overall MUIC was 58 μg/L when weighted to the 2006 Census population. Urban boys had higher values (MUIC = 77 μg/L) than urban and remote-dwelling non-pregnant girls (MUIC = 55 μg/L), but all these groups were classified as mildly iodine deficient. Remote-dwelling boys had the lowest MUIC (47 μg/L, moderate deficiency). Pregnant girls and those with infants aged less than 6 months also had insufficient iodine status. Correction for within-person variation reduced the spread of the population distribution.Conclusions: Previously, iodine deficiency was thought to occur only in the south-eastern states of Australia. This is the first report of iodine deficiency occurring in residents of the NT. It is also the first study of iodine status in a defined Indigenous population. Future follow-up will reassess iodine status in this group after the introduction of iodine fortification of bread.

Dorothy E M Mackerras MPH, PhD · Gurmeet R Singh MPH · Creswell J Eastman MD, FRACP, FRCPA

Indigenous health Public health February 2011 Free

Vitamin D insufficiency in Aboriginal Australians

Objective: To investigate the adequacy of vitamin D status in a South Australian Aboriginal population, and to examine the relationship between serum 25-hydroxyvitamin D (25-OHD) levels and biochemical variables of calcium and bone mineral homeostasis, as well as other factors which may influence vitamin D synthesis, storage and metabolism.Design, setting and participants: A single-visit, observational study of 58 adults from two Aboriginal community-controlled health services in Adelaide and Yalata, South Australia. Participants were recruited between May 2008 and December 2009.Main outcome measures: Serum levels of 25-OHD, parathyroid hormone (PTH), fasting glucose and fasting C-terminal telopeptides of type I collagen (β-CTx).Results: Serum 25-OHD levels showed clear seasonal variation, being higher in summer (P < 0.001). The overall mean level was 56.8 nmol/L (SD, 22.1), which is below the recommended target level of 60 nmol/L. Serum 25-OHD levels correlated significantly with β-CTx (P = 0.03), but not with age, body mass index (BMI), PTH levels or levels of fasting glucose. A significant association was found between BMI and PTH levels (P = 0.001). A significant inverse association between serum 25-OHD levels and BMI, observed in other studies, was not found in our study.Conclusions: Vitamin D insufficiency is highly prevalent in this population of adult Aboriginal Australians, with low mean values found in all seasons other than summer.

Simon J Vanlint MB BS, FRACGP · Howard A Morris PhD, FAACB, ARCPA · Jonathan W Newbury MD · Alan J Crockett MPH, PhD, FANZSRS

Azithromycin treatment levels inadequate for recommended trachoma control guidelines

To the Editor: Trachoma control guidelines from the World Health Organization1 and Communicable Diseases Network Australia (CDNA)2 recommend the “SAFE” strategy that includes surgery for trichiasis, antibiotic treatment, facial cleanliness and environmental improvement. Lack of access to antibiotics in isolated areas should not be a major contributor to the persistence of trachoma in Australia because special Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme arrangements (SPBSA) under section 100 of the National Health Act 1953 for the supply of medicines to remote-area Indigenous health services should enable a ready availability of azithromycin. The 1999–00 to 2001–02 evaluation of the SPBSA suggested that the program had led to major increases in the supply of medicines in remote areas, but that the supply of azithromycin did not change as a result of the introduction of the program.3 We assessed the relationship between reported azithromycin treatment of people with trachoma, their household contacts, and community members; levels of treatment recommended by WHO and CDNA guidelines; and the total number of courses of azithromycin available through the SPBSA. The National Trachoma Surveillance and Reporting Unit (NTSRU) provided 2008 data on treatment with azithromycin and trachoma prevalence in the Northern Territory, South Australia and Western Australia (refer to the report for limitations of the data).4 Data for 2007–08 on the supply of azithromycin to health services under SPBSA were obtained from Medicare Australia. The WHO guidelines recommend treatment of an entire community if the prevalence of active trachoma among children is above 10%.1,5 The CDNA guidelines2 recommend that contacts (> 6 months of age) of infected children within a household be treated. Our estimate of trachoma treatment according to CDNA guidelines is based on multiplying the number of infected children (from the NTSRU data) by the average number of members in remote Indigenous households.5 The impact of shared and multiple residence on estimates of household contacts could not be taken into account. The Box shows the numbers of azithromycin courses available through the SPBSA to remote-area Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander health services in the three states. In the NT, the reported number of courses given (3069) fell well below the level recommended by both WHO (by 34%) and CDNA (by 41%) guidelines. In SA, reported courses of azithromycin given (7) fell well below the 45 suggested by the CDNA guidelines. The prevalence of trachoma did not exceed 10% in any SA community, so no treatment was required under WHO guidelines. In WA, the reported number of courses given (2917) also fell below recommended levels, although the deficit (WHO, 35%; CDNA, 81%) varied substantially depending on which guidelines were used. Reported treatment with azithromycin was below levels recommended by the CDNA and the WHO despite health services having sufficient courses available to them to mostly meet these targets. All aspects of the SAFE strategy are important in the eradication of trachoma. However, improving the supply and distribution of azithromycin should be relatively easy to implement, fund and monitor. Azithromycin courses* available, 2007–08;† courses given, 2008;‡ and WHO- and CDNA-recommended courses,§ in three Australian states with remote-area Indigenous health services WHO = World Health Organization. CDNA = Communicable Diseases Network Australia. * Azithromycin courses are given to those with active trachoma, their household contacts, and community members. † Under special Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme arrangements and reported by Medicare Australia. ‡ Reported by the National Trachoma Surveillance and Reporting Unit (NTSRU). § Based on NTSRU data and using community population estimates.

Margaret Kelaher · Angeline S Ferdinand · Hugh R Taylor

Neuropsychological problems and alcohol availability appear to be key factors in continued heavy alcohol use by Aboriginal Australians

To the Editor: Significant morbidity and mortality are associated with excessive alcohol use, which, for Aboriginal Australians, generally occurs within a context of disadvantage. During 2007–2009, we assessed cognitive and psychological factors (using CogState1 and Strong Souls2 [CogState Ltd, Melbourne, Vic]) of 21 men and 11 women on admission to a 2-month Aboriginal residential treatment program in the Northern Territory. Participants’ mean age was 32 years (SD, 8.7 years) and the mean length of time for which they had used alcohol was 13.3 years (SD, 7.7 years). To determine the effect of age, number of years of drinking and other factors on continued alcohol use, we reinterviewed and reassessed participants in their home community with the same cognitive and psychological measures used at the initial assessment after a mean period of 11 months (SD, 4.4 months). At both baseline and follow-up, the number of participants for whom data were available varied for some characteristics. The Human Research Ethics Committee of the Northern Territory Department of Health and Community Services and Menzies School of Health Research (including the Aboriginal Ethics Sub Committee) approved the study. At baseline, 14 of 23 alcohol users reported drinking every day or most days, and 26 of 31 drank more than 10 standard drinks on each occasion. At follow-up in the community, 23 had resumed drinking at the same level, and nine had reduced their use (six had stopped using alcohol, and three had resumed drinking at lower levels). Compared with users who reduced their alcohol intake, users who did not showed poorer paired associate learning at the time of admission for treatment, and poorer performance at follow-up in visual attention, learning and executive function, visual learning and recall, and paired associate learning tasks (Box). This suggests that while subtle cognitive impairment may be a risk factor for continued heavy alcohol use after treatment, heavy alcohol use is also a likely cause of additional cognitive deficits.3 While reduced alcohol use may be associated with improvements in cognitive function, continued use may lead to further cognitive decline. Alcohol users who resumed drinking at the same level were significantly more likely to experience the psychological symptom “worry” after treatment (4/6; Fisher exact test, P < 0.05) than were users who reduced their alcohol use (0/6), which suggests that alcohol may have been used for self-medication or that excessive alcohol use may mask underlying psychological problems. Interestingly, a greater proportion of alcohol users who resumed drinking at the same level (10/16) were also using cannabis at follow-up, compared with those who reduced their use (1/9; Fisher exact test, P < 0.05). Cannabis use has been independently associated with psychological symptoms in other Australian studies, but with no impact on cognition.2,4 Our data indicate that there is a need to treat mental health problems concurrently with alcohol misuse problems among alcohol users undergoing treatment. Alcohol users who resumed drinking at the same level were less likely to return to remote communities with restricted alcohol availability (11/23), compared with those who reduced their alcohol use (9/9; Fisher exact test, P < 0.01), lending some support to the effectiveness of alcohol restrictions. Overall, our data show that cognitive problems and alcohol availability may be underlying factors in ongoing alcohol misuse by Aboriginal Australians. Charactersitics of alcohol users who resumed drinking at the same level and those who reduced their alcohol use after a 2-month residential treatment program, at baseline and at follow-up (n = 32) Characteristic Unchanged alcohol use, median Reduced alcohol use, median Z Significance No. of alcohol users 23 9 Age at baseline, years 31.3 29.0 − 0.15 ns Years of drinking, at baseline 13.0 11.6 − 0.59 ns Visual attention, speed (log transformed)* Baseline 2.81 2.76 − 1.67 ns Follow-up 2.79 2.71 − 2.10 P = 0.04 Working memory, accuracy (arcsine transformed)† Baseline 0.70 0.70 − 0.19 ns Follow-up 0.80 0.74 − 0.53 ns Psychomotor speed, moves per second† Baseline 0.77 0.95 − 0.35 ns Follow-up 1.17 1.37 − 0.75 ns Learning and executive function, moves per second† Baseline 0.44 0.47 − 0.39 ns Follow-up 0.58 0.76 − 2.32 P = 0.02 Visual learning and recall, moves per second† Baseline 0.48 0.46 − 0.21 ns Follow-up 0.73 0.84 − 2.20 P = 0.03 Paired associate learning, duration (seconds)* Baseline 307.81 214.11 − 2.52 P = 0.01 Follow-up 286.51 168.48 − 2.67 P = 0.008 ns = not significant; P > 0.07. * Higher values indicate poorer performance. † Higher values indicate better performance.

Kylie M Dingwall · Paul Maruff · Sheree Cairney

Indigenous health True stories December 2010 Free

From Northern Ireland to northern Australia: medicine in the Top End

On 8 June 2009, I started work as a locum gastroenterologist on the other side of the world and in a very different environment to the one I was used to. The inspiration for my visit came from an article in the careers supplement to the BMJ.1 A specialist trainee in infectious diseases wrote of his experiences working in Royal Darwin Hospital in the “Top End” of Australia’s Northern Territory. He described the hospital as modern and well equipped, but lacking a full-time gastroenterologist. On an impulse, I offered my services for 3 months, and my offer was accepted. I applied for a 3-month sabbatical — my first sabbatical — from my post of 18 years as a gastroenterologist at the Royal Victoria Hospital, Belfast, and a senior lecturer at Queen’s University Belfast, Northern Ireland, United Kingdom. I must confess that I wasn’t entirely naïve about life and work in Australia. I had previously worked at the Austin and Heidelberg Repatriation hospitals in Melbourne for 18 months in 1990–1991, and I had been back “Down Under” on holiday in 2007, visiting Sydney and Melbourne, as well as Uluru (Ayers Rock) and Port Douglas. Having enjoyed both my previous trips to Australia, I was keen to work there again, especially in the Top End with its particular challenges, not least of which is its remote tropical location, far from Australia’s major cities. After my impulsive decision, I had plenty of time to get used to the idea — negotiating my leave of absence and completing all the necessary paperwork for the Australian authorities took almost 2 years. With Australia’s NT designated as “an area of unmet need”, I was sponsored by the NT Government to obtain an advanced competency registration with the Australian Medical Council and a temporary residency visa for 3 months. I arranged to go during the European summer so that my wife and our two youngest children (who were on school holidays in July and August) could join me for a good part of the time. This also meant we would be in Darwin in the dry, winter season, when the daytime temperature is a comfortable 32°C with moderate humidity, and avoid the very humid wet season. On my first day at the hospital, I was given the role of general physician and put in charge of one of four admission teams, each consisting of a consultant, a registrar and one or two junior doctors. Each team was on duty for 24 hours one weekday per week, and one weekend day for three out of four weekends, and responsible for 15–30 patients at any time, with up to 15 patients admitted on a take-in day. The hospital has an excellent emergency department as well as a rapid assessment planning unit, which was used jointly by physicians and surgeons to assess their patients in the first 24 hours after admission. I soon discovered that there were three main categories of patients at Darwin Hospital: Aboriginal people from the Darwin area and much further afield; other local Darwinians, most of whom had moved to Darwin from other parts of Australia and South East Asia; and older, retired Australian tourists who come to the NT to escape the southern winter (the “grey nomads”). Patients from outside Darwin are brought in by air ambulance. The Royal Flying Doctor Service (RFDS) does not operate in the Top End of the NT, which has its own air ambulance service, but occasionally patients are flown to Darwin by the RFDS from Alice Springs or from areas of Western Australia and Queensland. It is often quicker to fly to Darwin than to one of the other major cities because of the immense distances involved. Although about 30% of the NT population are Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people, most living in remote areas, they make up a disproportionate 40%–60% of the patient population at the hospital. This reflects the relatively poor health status of Indigenous Australians compared with the non-Indigenous population. Their high level of diabetes, chronic renal disease, hypertension, heart failure and alcoholism is a disturbing fact, as is their lower life expectancy; the life expectancy gap at birth between Indigenous and non-Indigenous people is 12 years for males and 10 years for females.2 Furthermore, perinatal and infant mortality rates are two to three times non-Indigenous rates.2 My stay helped me to appreciate the complex reasons for this situation, which encompass social and economic as well as educational factors, not to mention the difficulties of delivering health care to remote communities. I greatly enjoyed the challenge of medical practice in a new environment. As well as the usual presentations of patients with neurological, cardiorespiratory and hepatic conditions, we were faced with cases of severe sepsis, tuberculosis, melioidosis (Burkholderia pseudomallei), rheumatic heart disease, severe complications of diabetes, meningitis and infected scabies. The radiological findings discussed at multidisciplinary meetings seemed to have been drawn from a textbook of septic complications. This contrasted with multidisciplinary meetings in the UK, which have been specifically set up to deal with patients with cancer. I rapidly learnt to prescribe ceftriaxone with or without gentamicin as the initial antibiotic regimen, which proved to be life-saving in many situations. My sabbatical coincided with the height of the swine flu outbreak; typically, six or more patients with this condition were admitted each day. The severity ranged from relatively mild to critically ill, with patients in the latter category requiring ventilation and intensive care. Darwin is soon to have its own medical school, but for many years it has functioned as a satellite centre for training students from the medical schools at James Cook University in Townsville, Queensland, and Flinders University in Adelaide, South Australia. I was hugely impressed by the high level of medical care delivered by all the staff in the hospital. Their dedication and professionalism were very evident and, in conversation, I became aware of a strong vocational motivation that elsewhere is becoming lost in an increasingly cynical world. Many of my colleagues relished the challenges of working in Darwin. They were all Australians but, with the exception of the senior physician, Dr Diane Howard, none were originally from Darwin. Their experience of medicine in the major cities in Australia, where they had previously trained and practised, was similar to mine in the UK. They looked upon their time in Darwin as something of an adventure, not dissimilar to my own experience. Of particular value were the hospital’s cultural awareness seminars, which enabled new staff to gain some understanding of the culture of Indigenous people. The key points that I gained from these seminars were an appreciation of the complexity and richness of Aboriginal culture, and the profound personal disruption for Aboriginal people that admission to hospital entails. Hospital admission is traumatic for anyone, but for people who live in small, isolated communities with strong family relationships, it is deeply disturbing and bewildering. First, they have to cope with being unwell, and then with being flown several hundred kilometres to a place which must seem alien in virtually every respect — uncomfortably cold air-conditioning, different food, a different language, and frightening procedures. I learnt that even small things like eye contact, which we regard as a polite courtesy when talking to another person, may be threatening and confrontational to Aboriginal people. Great efforts are made to bridge this cultural gap by providing interpreters and Aboriginal liaison officers, and by encouraging a friend or relative to travel with patients and stay with them at the hospital. These current efforts contrast with some of the misguided government interventions of the past, most notably in relation to the “stolen generation”, when Aboriginal children were removed from their families “for their own good”. I found that these events are still vividly remembered and resented. During my trip, I was fortunate in being able to visit a health clinic in Oenpelli (Gunbalanya), in West Arnhem Land, about 300 km from Darwin. I particularly noticed a mural in the clinic, prominently displaying the word “Reconciliation”. Coming from Belfast and having lived through “the Troubles”, I could not help thinking of the parallels with the situation in Northern Ireland, with our community also struggling with reconciliation — two cultures trying earnestly to understand one another and come to a working arrangement. Health care is often on the frontline of cultural divisions. In Northern Ireland, the health service served both sides faithfully and impartially and was undoubtedly a force for good. I sensed that the health services in the NT are in a similar position. I have now returned to my normal job in Belfast, facing up to old challenges and some new ones. On reflection, I consider myself very fortunate and privileged to have practised medicine in Darwin, to have been accepted so generously by new colleagues, and to have learnt so much from them and from the patients we cared for. I found it refreshing, humbling, often thought-provoking and at times inspiring. It is an experience that I and my family will never forget. Murals promoting Aboriginal health and reconciliation at the Oenpelli (Gunbalanya) Health Clinic, West Arnhem Land, NT (published with permission). I am dwarfed by one of the Northern Territory’s magnetic termite towers, with its accurate north-south alignment to control temperature.

R G Peter Watson MD, FRCP(UK), FRCPI

Cancer incidence and mortality in Indigenous Australians in Queensland, 1997–2006

Objective: To examine cancer incidence and mortality in Indigenous Queenslanders.Design, setting and patients: Assessment of indirectly standardised incidence and mortality ratios for Indigenous Australians in Queensland diagnosed with cancer from 1997 to 2006, compared with the total Queensland population.Main outcome measures: Standardised incidence and mortality ratios.Results: Compared with the total Queensland population, Indigenous Queenslanders had a lower overall incidence of cancer (standardised incidence ratio, 0.79; 95% CI, 0.75–0.82), but a higher incidence of some of the more fatal cancer types. Overall cancer mortality was higher (standardised mortality ratio, 1.36; 95% CI, 1.28–1.45) and similar to rates for Indigenous people in other Australian states.Conclusion: Cancer rates for Indigenous Queenslanders, a mostly urbanised population, are similar to rates for Indigenous Australians mostly living in remote areas.

Suzanne P Moore BHSc(Nursing), MPH, PhD · Peter K O’Rourke BSc(Hons) BA(Hons), PhD · Kylie-Ann Mallitt BSc(Hons) · Gail Garvey BEd, MEd · Adèle C Green MB BS, MSc, PhD · Michael D Coory MB BS, PhD, FAFPHM · Patricia C Valery MD, MPH, PhD

Indigenous health Indigenous health November 2010 Free

Haemodialysis outcomes of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander patients of remote Kimberley region origin

Objectives: To compare the clinical outcomes and mortality rates of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people of Kimberley origin receiving haemodialysis (HD) treatment with other subsets of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander HD patients (Northern Territory, Western Australia excluding the Kimberley region, the rest of Australia) and Australian non-Indigenous HD patients.Design, participants and setting: Retrospective identification of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander patients of Kimberley origin and analysis of secondary data from the Australia and New Zealand Dialysis and Transplant Registry; this group was compared with other Australian patients receiving HD treatment from 1 January 2003 to 31 December 2007.Main outcome measures: Clinical outcome measures; comorbid conditions; death rates per 100 patient-years, unadjusted and adjusted (for age, sex, comorbid conditions, late referral to nephrologist treatment).Results: Seventy per cent of HD treatments for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander patients of Kimberley origin was provided in the Kimberley. They had comparable adjusted mortality rates to non-Indigenous Australian patients (adjusted mortality rate ratio, 0.80; 95% CI, 0.51–1.23).Conclusions: This is the first report showing similar mortality rates for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people exclusively from a remote area of Australia and non-Indigenous Australians receiving HD treatment. HD treatment delivered closer to home can be safe and effective in remote areas.

Julia V Marley PgDipSc, PgDipPolSt, PhD · Hannah K Dent BSc(Hons) · Maree Wearne BNur, CertNephN, CertMid · Cherelle Fitzclarence BMed(Hons), MPHandTM, FRACGP · Carmel Nelson MPHandTM, FACRRM, FRACGP · Karen Siu BN, PGDIPNsg, NephrologyCert · Kevin Warr MB BS, FRACP · David Atkinson MB BS, MPH

Indigenous health Indigenous health November 2010 Free

The health of urban Aboriginal people: insufficient data to close the gap

The Australian Government has committed to reducing Indigenous disadvantage, including closing the life-expectancy gap within a generation, and to halving the gap in mortality rates for children under 5 years of age within a decade. Sixty per cent of the health gap between Indigenous and non-Indigenous Australians is attributable to the health of Indigenous people living in non-remote areas of Australia. We conducted a brief review of recent Australian original research publications on the health of the 53% of Indigenous people who live in urban areas, and found that data are sparse; there were only 63 studies in the past 5 years (11% of all articles about Indigenous health during this period). Although Indigenous Australians living in remote areas experience greater health disparity, the government will not achieve its aims without paying due attention to the non-remote-living population. More research is required, and particularly research that actually tests the impact of policies and programs.

Sandra J Eades BMed, PhD · Bronwen Taylor BTech, MSc · Sandra Bailey LLB · Anna B Williamson BPsych(Hons), PhD · Jonathan C Craig MB ChB, FRACP, PHD · Sally Redman BA(Hons), PhD

Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities forgotten in new Australian National Action Plan for Human Influenza Pandemic: “Ask us, listen to us, share with us”

The epidemiology of influenza pandemics demands that Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people occupy centrestage in future planning The first wave of pandemic (H1N1) 2009 influenza (pH1N1) broke more heavily on Australia’s Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander populations than on non-Indigenous Australians. The burden of disease in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people was highlighted by the first Australian death associated with pH1N1 infection: a young Aboriginal man from a remote area of Western Australia who died on 19 June 2009 in an Adelaide hospital.1 The differences between the populations are stark, with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people indisputably over-represented in severe pH1N1 disease. In the Top End of the Northern Territory, pH1N1 rates of notification, hospital admission and intensive care unit (ICU) admission were higher for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people than for the non-Indigenous population (3.5 times, 12 times and 5 times, respectively).2 Similar profound differences have been recorded for Aboriginal communities in New South Wales: Aboriginal people hospitalised with pH1N1 were younger than their non-Aboriginal counterparts (median age of 24.5 years compared with 31.7 years), and the age-standardised rate ratios for Aboriginal to non-Aboriginal admissions to hospital, admissions to ICU and death during the 2009 pandemic wave were 3.2, 4.0 and 4.5, respectively.3 Overall, from May to October 2009 in Australia, Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Australians, who comprise 2.5% of the population, accounted for 16.0% of hospitalisations with pH1N1 and 9.7% of pH1N1 admissions to an ICU.4 A fivefold increase in risk of death due to pH1N1 was also reported.5 This experience demands a greater focus on the needs of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities and their prioritisation in future pandemic planning. We should not have been surprised, as history tragically demonstrates disproportionate morbidity and mortality for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people in previous pandemics.6 It is thus exceedingly disappointing to discover no mention of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Australians in the revised National Action Plan for Human Influenza Pandemic (NAP).7 The 2010 NAP fails to identify Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people as a high-risk group during the H1N1 2009 pandemic, although it acknowledges other risk groups that have been recognised internationally and in Australia: severe cases occurred in people with underlying chronic conditions such as respiratory diseases, cardiovascular disease, diabetes, autoimmune disorders and obesity. Pregnant women were also at an increased risk of serious disease.7 It is inexplicable that while Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people were identified as a priority group for the rollout of the pH1N1 influenza vaccination — a commendable and necessary preventive strategy — they are overlooked in the NAP.8 Although the Australian Health Management Plan for Pandemic Influenza9 states an equity commitment, and a subsequent appendix10 produced during the “Protect” phase of the 2009 pandemic endorsed the need for partnership between all health care providers in case and contact management among the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander population, respectful partnership between governments and Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities to identify culturally appropriate and effective prevention and mitigation strategies enjoys no mention. Given that the NAP is the peak plan for guiding preparations for future pandemics, there is a fundamental need for governments to acknowledge and respond effectively to the specific requirements of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people. Prevention and preparedness must include government support of planning in respectful partnership with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities, health organisations and representative bodies. Mandating this support and partnership at all levels of government will allow a greater understanding of infection risk and identification of cultural, social, economic and health service factors that may contribute to poor health outcomes, and ensure culturally safe and effective prevention and mitigation strategies. A national project, funded by the National Health and Medical Research Council, working with Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities and health services in NSW, Queensland and Western Australia is learning about feasible and culturally appropriate containment strategies.11 A strong theme emerging from this work is the message to government: “Ask us, listen to us, share with us”. The ability of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities to develop novel practical mitigation measures has been a particular feature of this respectful engagement that has already informed government strategies in NSW.3 The epidemiology of the current and previous influenza pandemics demands that Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people occupy centrestage in future planning. Solutions to limit the burden on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander populations exist, but respectful partnership is necessary to unearth them. The partnership must not be a token one, but one developed through engagement with communities, and with the flexibility to be localised to meet the specific needs of diverse urban, rural and remote Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities in all states and territories. Health information delivered with a local flavour is a key message from the project. “Ask us, listen to us, share with us” is a strong message that governments must heed if the impact of pandemic influenza on Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities is to be limited.

on behalf of the Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Community Influenza Study Group

Indigenous health Medicine and the community September 2010 Free

Predictors of sexual intercourse and rapid-repeat pregnancy among teenage mothers: an Australian prospective longitudinal study

Objectives: To examine the determinants of pregnancy within 2 years of a teenager giving birth for the first time (rapid-repeat pregnancy [RRP]) and resumption of sexual intercourse after the birth.Design, setting and participants: Prospective cohort study between June 2004 and September 2006 at the sole tertiary obstetric hospital in Western Australia involving teenagers who gave birth for the first time. Data were collected using questionnaires at recruitment, 6 weeks and 3-monthly intervals for up to 2 years postpartum.Main outcome measures: RRP and time to a return to sexual intercourse after giving birth.Results: Of the 147 participants, 49 (33%) experienced an RRP. Sexual intercourse was independently significantly associated with using an oral contraceptive (odds ratio [OR], 2.83; 95% CI, 1.38–5.82); living with the birth father (OR, 8.43; 95% CI, 5.12–13.86); intending to become pregnant (OR, 3.20; 95% CI, 1.53–6.65); smoking marijuana (OR, 2.60; 95% CI, 1.38–4.79); and using alcohol (OR, 1.93; 95% CI, 1.17–3.20). Use of long-acting contraceptives was associated with reduced odds of RRP (OR, 0.27; 95% CI, 0.12–0.62), while teenagers who used an oral contraceptive had a similar risk of RRP compared with those using barrier methods or no contraception. Other factors predicting RRP were: being sexually active for more than 3 months (OR, 8.96; 95% CI, 1.97–40.74); intending to become pregnant (OR, 2.39; 95% CI, 1.62–4.93); and being an Indigenous Australian (OR, 2.38; 95% CI, 1.38–4.11).Conclusion: There are two options available to health care providers for reducing the rate of RRP: to facilitate teenage mothers’ access to long-acting contraceptives; and to gain clear understanding of their intention with regard to repeat pregnancy and to provide appropriate support.

Lucy N Lewis RM, BSc(Health Sciences), MN · Dorota A Doherty BSc(Hons), PhD(Medical Statistics) · Martha Hickey MB ChB, MD, FRANZCOG · S Rachel Skinner MB BS, PhD, FRACP

Chronic suppurative lung disease and bronchiectasis in children and adults in Australia and New Zealand. A position statement from the Thoracic Society of Australia and New Zealand and the Australian Lung Foundation

Consensus recommendations for managing chronic suppurative lung disease (CSLD) and bronchiectasis, based on systematic reviews, were developed for Australian and New Zealand children and adults during a multidisciplinary workshop. The diagnosis of bronchiectasis requires a high-resolution computed tomography scan of the chest. People with symptoms of bronchiectasis, but non-diagnostic scans, have CSLD, which may progress to radiological bronchiectasis. CSLD/bronchiectasis is suspected when chronic wet cough persists beyond 8 weeks. Initial assessment requires specialist expertise. Specialist referral is also required for children who have either two or more episodes of chronic (> 4 weeks) wet cough per year that respond to antibiotics, or chest radiographic abnormalities persisting for at least 6 weeks after appropriate therapy. Intensive treatment seeks to improve symptom control, reduce frequency of acute pulmonary exacerbations, preserve lung function, and maintain a good quality of life. Antibiotic selection for acute infective episodes is based on results of lower airway culture, local antibiotic susceptibility patterns, clinical severity and patient tolerance. Patients whose condition does not respond promptly or adequately to oral antibiotics are hospitalised for more intensive treatments, including intravenous antibiotics. Ongoing treatment requires regular and coordinated primary health care and specialist review, including monitoring for complications and comorbidities. Chest physiotherapy and regular exercise should be encouraged, nutrition optimised, environmental pollutants (including tobacco smoke) avoided, and vaccines administered according to national immunisation schedules. Individualised long-term use of oral or nebulised antibiotics, corticosteroids, bronchodilators and mucoactive agents may provide a benefit, but are not recommended routinely.

Anne B Chang MPHTM, PhD, FRACP · Scott C Bell MB BS, MD, FRACP · Cass A Byrnes MB ChB, MD, FRACP · Keith Grimwood MB ChB, MD, FRACP · Peter W Holmes MB BS, FCCP, FRACP · Paul T King MB BS, FRACP, PhD · John Kolbe MB BS, FRACP · Louis I Landau MB BS, MD, FRACP · Graeme P Maguire MB BS, FRACP, PhD · Malcolm I McDonald MB BS, FRCPA, PhD · David W Reid MB ChB, MRCP, FRACP · Francis C Thien MB BS, MD, FRACP · Paul J Torzillo MB BS, FRACP, FJFICM

Indigenous health Public health September 2010 Free

How much is too much? Alcohol consumption and related harm in the Northern Territory

Objective: Design, setting and participants: Descriptive study of alcohol consumption in the NT population, based on sales data and self-report surveys, and alcohol-attributable deaths and hospitalisations among people in the NT in the 2004–05 and 2005–06 financial years using population alcohol-attributable fractions specific to the NT.Main outcome measures: Per capita consumption of pure alcohol, self-reported level of consumption, and age-standardised rates of death and hospitalisation attributable to alcohol.Results: Apparent per capita consumption of pure alcohol for both Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal populations in the NT has been about 14 litres or more per year for many years, about 50% higher than for Australia as a whole. We estimated that there were 120 and 119 alcohol-attributable deaths in the NT in 2004–05 and 2005–06, respectively, at corresponding age-standardised rates of 7.2 and 7.8 per 10 000 adult population. Alcohol-attributable deaths occur in the NT at about 3.5 times the rate they do in Australia generally; rates in non-Aboriginal people were about double the national rate, while they were 9–10 times higher in Aboriginal people. There were 2319 and 2544 alcohol-attributable hospitalisations in the NT in 2004–05 and 2005–06, respectively, at corresponding rates of 146.6 and 157.7 per 10 000 population (more than twice the national rate).Conclusion: In recent years, alcohol consumption and consequent alcohol-attributable deaths and hospitalisations for both Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal people in the NT have occurred at levels far higher than elsewhere in Australia.

Steven J Skov MB BS, FAFPHM, MPH · Tanya N Chikritzhs BA(Hons), PostGradDip(Epi · Shu Q Li BM, BN, MPH · Sabine Pircher BNutrDiet, MPH · Steven Whetton BEc(Hons), MSc(Economics)

Indigenous health Letters September 2010 Free

Closing the gap — better health intelligence is required

To the Editor: National best practice guidelines recognise that accurate data on the health of Indigenous Australians are crucial to improving health service delivery.1 The draft revision of the RACGP Standards for general practices acknowledges the need for improvement and requires that a practice demonstrates how it routinely records, in active patient health records, self-identified Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander status.2 This is a commendable improvement but should be further strengthened, requiring that Indigenous status be recorded for at least 90% of active patients, the level required for a history of allergies. Improved record keeping in general practice has resulted in the potential to improve Indigenous identification among patients notified with a communicable disease. This enables the documentation of health disadvantage, and allows evaluation of measures aimed at closing the gap in health outcomes between Indigenous and non-Indigenous people. Demographic data in the NSW notifiable diseases database (NDD) were audited for all 258 Hunter New England (HNE) Salmonella infection notifications in 2007 by interviewing patients and their referring general practitioners. Interviews were completed for 83% of patients. Indigenous status was poorly recorded. The NDD listed three patients with salmonellosis as Aboriginal, but showed an unknown status for 87%. Among patients who had attended a GP during their illness (66%), practice records listed two as Aboriginal, but Indigenous status was unknown for 70%. Most GPs (95%) reported using electronic medical records, and 89% completed pathology requests with practice software. Many GPs (60%) requested information on how to appropriately ask about a patient’s Indigenous status. Interviews with patients who had been notified as having had salmonellosis identified 13 as Aboriginal, and no resistance to identification was encountered. The crude salmonellosis notification rates per 100 000 population were 42.2 (95% CI, 19.3–65.1) for Aboriginal HNE residents and 25.5 (95% CI, 21.7–28.6) for non-Aboriginal HNE residents which, while not statistically significant for this small sample, suggests a differential salmonellosis burden, consistent with studies elsewhere.3 The true burden of disease was likely to have been substantially higher, as many infections are not notified.4 The differential burden may also be an underestimate if Aboriginal HNE residents were less likely to be notified than non-Aboriginal residents due to, for example, reduced access to health services. The widespread availability of electronic practice software for generating pathology requests provides a new opportunity to substantially improve Indigenous identification in communicable disease notifications.3 Indigenous status should be routinely recorded by GPs and automatically included on their pathology request forms and subsequent laboratory notifications. There is now a need for a coordinated national approach to ensure consistent inclusion of Indigenous status on all laboratory notification data.

Anthony D Merritt · April R Roberts-Witteveen · David N Durrheim

Indigenous health Ross Ingram Memorial Essay Competition August 2010 Free

Cultural safety in health for Aboriginal people: will it work in Australia?

I was happy in my retirement and living on the old-age pension with my husband when I had a call in early 2009 from Curtin University requesting a meeting to discuss cultural safety in Aboriginal health. You can imagine my surprise! Here I was, a 70-year-old retiree, content in the knowledge that I had worked and studied my way up from being a housewife and mother to being a respected Doctor of Philosophy, writer, and promoter of Aboriginal issues through my writing. I was full of curiosity to know the reason for this out-of-the-blue telephone call. Arrangements were made to meet with Associate Professor (now Professor) Sandra Thompson to discuss her proposition. I was to work as an Associate Professor for Cultural Safety in the Faculty of Health Sciences at Curtin University’s Centre for International Health, which had recently added Indigenous Health to its program. I started work there in April 2009. The cultural safety for indigenous health movement began in New Zealand during the 1980s when a Maori student nurse, Irihapeti Ramsden, queried hospital policy on standard nursing practices by saying “You people talk about legal safety, ethical safety, and safety in clinical practices and a safe knowledge base, but what of cultural safety?”1 Clearly, cultural safety was not on the nursing agenda. Irihapeti Ramsden instigated the cultural safety movement in New Zealand. Although the Treaty of Waitangi recognised the Maori as being the first people of their country, Maori nurses knew that the Treaty was not being honoured in the nursing fraternity.1 Maori nurses and patients were being isolated from mainstream nursing practices and treated as second-class citizens because of their cultural differences. Maori nurses wanted to be acknowledged and treated as equals in the workplace. The Maori nurses and patients had strong cultural ties and began to question why they should maintain nursing practices that were contrary to their own cultural beliefs and customs. Gradually the concerns of Maori nursing staff and patients in hospitals were recognised, and cultural safety is now embedded in most schools of nursing in New Zealand. The Nursing Council of New Zealand has amended its standards for registration to include safe cultural practices.1 Now the concepts of cultural safety, including cultural awareness and cultural competence, are being introduced into the Australian nursing system through the universities. Unfortunately, it is taking longer to change the colonial mentality and inherent racist attitudes towards Aboriginal people in this country than in New Zealand. We have over 200 years of invisibility and exile to overcome before Aboriginal people can attain the ideal status of equality. After joining the Centre for International Health at Curtin University, my interest in cultural safety grew and I realised that it was the solution to many health problems facing Aboriginal people. They needed to feel worthy as individuals and not be denigrated for being Aboriginal, with all the negative connotations that that image conjures up. If medical, nursing and other health organisations could forget the policies of the past and accept Aboriginal people as equals instead of patronising them and treating them as children, the health and hospital systems would have a better chance of reducing morbidity and mortality rates among Aboriginal people. As my own awareness of the cultural safety issues grew, I remembered the past and the government policies I had lived through over the years. Before the 1967 referendum,2 Aboriginal people were wards of the state governments and had no authority over their own lives. They were subject to laws and policies that enabled state governments to monitor their movements and enforce those laws if Aboriginal people dared to show initiative by making their own decisions. They were a subjugated people. However, due to the United Nations policy on indigenous rights, attitudes were slowly changing towards indigenous peoples worldwide. The Universal Declaration of Human Rights was adopted and proclaimed on 10 December 1948 at the General Assembly of the United Nations.3 All countries were to give citizenship to their indigenous people, and Australia was no exception. But the Aboriginal people of Australia did not know about the Declaration, and it was not until almost 20 years later that they were made citizens of this country. The 1967 referendum, in which Australians voted 90.77% in favour of Aboriginal people becoming citizens in their own country,2 was an important landmark for us because it meant we were no longer wards of state governments but were free citizens. Improvements to the living conditions of Aboriginal people living on reserves in Western Australia began by providing the basic necessities of life, such as having easy access to tap water (instead of carrying water in buckets from public taps) and having ablutions blocks with laundry, bathing and toilet facilities. Two-bedroom wooden-slab housing was erected (with no electricity) to replace tin shacks, tents and bough sheds. But no one thought about Aboriginal health except Aboriginal people themselves, when they needed medical and nursing attention. The health and wellbeing of Aboriginal people were in a sorry state. On the positive side, teenage Aboriginal children were being sent to Perth to further their education and obtain training in different careers. I was one of those children. However, it wasn’t until March 1956, when I began training as a nursing aide at Royal Perth Hospital, that the issue of Aboriginal health was brought to my awareness. Training Aboriginal girls as nursing aides (a new program implemented by the state government of Western Australia) had only begun two months previously. But I found that while the hospital system accepted Aboriginal patients, the health personnel were indifferent to Aboriginal needs. In fact, at this time, native hospitals were situated in many country towns, and Aboriginal people with chronic illnesses were mainly admitted to these hospitals. The treatment they received was passable, but there was a definite paternalism that hindered quality patient care. Being an Aboriginal nursing aide in the mainstream hospital system was difficult at times, and I experienced racism from staff and patients. For example, one time when I was working in a country town after completing my training, I needed to have my appendix removed. On the morning of the operation, I had a shower and considered myself clean. But, according to the ward sister, I hadn’t washed the navel area clean enough for her liking, so she sent me back to scrub myself again. What can I say? I was 18 years old and gauche, and arguing with the ward sister was out of the question. In retrospect, I realise that my personal hygiene was being called into question. I felt degraded, because I always showered every morning. Other examples of racism occurred with patients in other hospitals — some didn’t want me to touch them when I had to bed-bathe them or see to their personal needs. When I told the ward sister, she berated these patients, but it was horrible to know that many of these people judged me by the colour of my skin and not my work ethic. These days, racist attitudes have become more covert, and are a subtle mixture of paternalism, arrogance and the assumption of white privilege. But there is an even more serious lack of cultural safety for Aboriginal people when receiving nursing care (as patients) or giving care (as staff). My own cultural upbringing made it very hard for me to tend to the personal needs of Aboriginal men who were hospital patients. I felt uneasy when they needed assistance with their bed-baths or toilet needs. It was embarrassing for both parties because, as a woman, it was culturally taboo for me to be tending to a man’s personal needs. It was a matter of cultural protocols gone awry. Knowing and understanding Aboriginal protocols would be a starting point for many who work in the hospital system. Nevertheless there are many fair-minded Australians who want to improve Aboriginal health and the hospital system through introducing cultural safety to those who have the power to implement change. It needs to be widely recognised that achieving cultural safety in health programs for Aboriginal people will advance good health practices and boost positive health statistics through the acceptance of Aboriginal people for their differences from mainstream Australians. In other words, we are the first peoples in Australia — people in our own right, with our own cultures, customs and protocols. At the Centre for International Health, we intend to implement programs in the curriculum that will include Aboriginal studies and protocols for cultural safety in all schools of health. Talking to Aboriginal students in high school is also on the agenda because it is important for students to think about training for a career in health. Knowing and understanding Aboriginal protocols would be a starting point for many who work in the hospital system. I remember when my father was sick just before he passed away in 1992. The staff at Sir Charles Gairdner Hospital, in Perth, let members of the family visit him regardless of the time limit on hospital visits or the number of family members present. This was at a time when cultural safety was unheard of, but the hospital staff had the common decency to realise that my father had a large family and we all wanted to say goodbye. The human kindness shown by the hospital staff is remembered with gratitude and proves that cultural safety for Aboriginal people can be attained. In this instance, the nursing staff chose to show respect for a grieving family rather than passing negative judgement on us because we were Aboriginal people. The number of workshops and seminars teaching cultural awareness is increasing, but making people aware does not mean they are culturally competent or that they understand cultural safety as a health practice. People working in remote areas generally have more knowledge and acceptance of Aboriginal people than those who live in the cities and suburbs, although there are exceptions, as the above example of my family’s experience shows. Urban and foreign medical and nursing staff working in city and country hospitals should take a crash course in Aboriginal studies and protocols, as many have had no contact with Aboriginal people, let alone experience with treating them as patients. Aboriginal people themselves must change their attitudes to ill health, and understand the necessity of maintaining the treatment that medical and hospital personnel advise. For instance, diabetes sufferers should follow appropriate diets, have regular exercise and remember to take their medication. It is very important that Aboriginal people take responsibility for their own health, provided they are not too old, too young or too infirm to do so. They need to work with medical staff to find mutually acceptable solutions to combat their own or their family’s health problems. Working with medical and nursing practitioners would enhance the practice of cultural safety. Finally, to the question posed in the title of my essay: “Cultural safety in health for Aboriginal people: will it work in Australia?” — I believe it could work. Attitudinal changes of medical and nursing staff will change the status quo of Aboriginal health, and changing antiquated images of a past era is a step in the right direction. We can alter the negativity associated with Aboriginal people and their cultures by recognising their unique value to Australia’s past, present and future. If implementing and maintaining cultural safety for Aboriginal people means improving their wellbeing and survival, then it should be compulsory in all spheres of health practice in this country.

Rosemary van den Berg PhD

Health service attendance patterns in an urban Aboriginal health service

Objectives: To describe the health service attendance patterns of urban Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander (Aboriginal) Australians and make comparisons with those of the general Australian population.Design and setting: General practitioner-completed survey of all attendances over two separate 2-week periods in 2006 at an urban Aboriginal health service in Canberra, which provides services for about 3500 patients per annum.Main outcome measures: Standardised attendance ratios (SARs) for a range of health problems, using patients attending Australian general practice for the same reasons as the reference population.Results: Patients attending the Aboriginal health service were significantly younger than the Australian general practice patient reference population. The most common conditions managed were psychological, encompassing substance misuse; psychological problems accounted for 24% of all attendances. Patients attending the Aboriginal health service had higher rates of attendance for psychological conditions (SAR, 2.14; 95% CI, 2.01–2.28), endocrine conditions (SAR, 2.44; 95% CI, 2.29–2.60) and neurological conditions (SAR, 2.90; 95% CI, 2.71–3.09), as well as for circulatory, digestive and male and female genital conditions, than the reference population. Patients attending the Aboriginal health service had significantly lower attendance rates than the Australian population for respiratory illnesses, and conditions related to eyes or ears.Conclusions: At this urban Aboriginal health service, attendance patterns reflected complex health care needs that are different from those expected of a population of this age. Urban Aboriginal health service attendance appears to reflect significant ill health among the patients, aligning more with Aboriginal health statistics nationally rather than health statistics for urban non-Aboriginal Australians.

Karen M Flegg MB BS(Hons), FRACGP, MIPH · Christine B Phillips MB BS, MPH, FRACGP · Anne L Collins BA, BSc · Peter G Sharp MB BS · Meetali Kanagasundaram BSc(Hons), BBiomedSc, MB BS · Ray W Lovett BN, BHSc, MAppEpi · Marjan Kljakovic MB ChB, FRNZCGP, PhD

Subscribe to
MJA email alerts

No spam, you can unsubscribe anytime you want.

By providing your information, you agree to our Terms of Use and our Privacy Policy.

Good one! Your updates are coming

Thank you for subscribing to the MJA email alerts. Receive the latest content in your inbox.