Volume 192 - Issue 11
A lifetime pursuit of diabetes through chance
Author: Wladyslaw W Smolilo
Med J Aust 2010; 192 (11): 670-671. || doi: 10.5694/j.1326-5377.2010.tb03678.x
Published online: 7 June 2010
Published online: 7 June 2010
To the Editor: In the December 2009 issue of the MJA, I came across an interesting article by Dr Paul Zimmet, “A lifetime pursuit of diabetes through chance”.1 This is an account of his impressive achievements in medicine.
However, I disagree with the statement that describes his father’s situation in 1930s Poland: “He returned to an unpaid position in the Tarnopol Hospital — unpaid because Jewish doctors could not be ‘officially’ employed in Poland.”
I argue that, in Poland at that time, there was no discrimination against national minorities, and this applied to the Jewish minority as well.2 I have done some research on the subject. There were 3.5 million Jewish people in Poland before the war — 10% of the population. According to numerous historical sources, Jewish doctors represented 34% of doctors in Poland in 1938. In the Polish capital, Warszawa, this percentage was 66%. The same sources quote the percentage of lawyers of Jewish origin as 55%.3,4 These numbers are a tribute to the talents and assertiveness of Polish Jews; however, they do not support the statement by Zimmet that I am disputing.
In Polish archives, I have discovered statistical documents containing alphabetical lists of all doctors registered in Poland between 1936 and 1938.5 According to these documents, there were two hospitals in Tarnopol at that time: the General Hospital and a Jewish hospital. In the official register of all Polish doctors practising between 1936 and 1938, I have not found the name of Dr Jacob Zimmet. He was not registered as a doctor, and therefore could not legally be employed as a doctor in Tarnopol or any other Polish hospital.
References
- Zimmet PZ. A lifetime pursuit of diabetes through chance. Med J Aust 2009; 191: 632-636.
- Davies N. Norman Davies on Polish history. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=3OoSdnebLxw (accessed May 2010).
- Micinska M. [Jewish intelligentsia in Poland] [Polish]. The Canadian Foundation of Polish-Jewish Heritage, May 2002. http://polish-jewish-heritage.org/pol/inteligencja_zydowska.htm (accessed May 2010).
- [Webpage of the contemporary Jewish Community in Poland. History of Polish Jews. Second Polish Commonwealth.] [Polish]. http://www.badacz.org/izrael/zydzi_w_polsce/dzieje_rzeczypospolita.html (accessed May 2010).
- Digital Library of Wielkopolska. [Medical Statistics Yearbooks of the Commonwealth of Poland, 1936–1938; Official Register of Doctors In Poland, 1936–1938] [Polish]. http://www.wbc.poznan.pl/publication/55999 (accessed May 2010).
Prisoner of war pathology in Changi, 1942–1945
Kate Ariotti, Elizabeth Roberts‐Pedersen
Should medical eponyms continue to be used in everyday practice?
Leya Nedumannil, Diana Lewis
100 years on: the first use of insulin in Australia
Sophie Templer
Reflections on the life and career of Professor Dame Valerie Beral AC DBE FRS FRCOG FMedSci (1943–2022)
Karen Canfell, Bette Liu, Emily Banks
The Honourable Dr Donald James Grimes AO
Michael Kirby, Patti Warn
From wipeout to drill out: a history of exostosis management and Australian surfing
Alon Taylor, Hannah North, Narinder P Singh, Paul A Fagan