Topics
Ethics
Potential solutions to improve the governance of multicentre health services research
To the Editor: As Clay-Williams and colleagues,1 we have also experienced frustration at the time-consuming, expensive2 and protracted processes required as a prerequisite before undertaking research involving identified patient data across Australia. Ironically, in the case of clinical quality registries, we collect data designed to measure quality of care so that patients may benefit from improved clinical processes. Yet, the system conspires to delay and undermine these efforts. There are lessons we have learned in developing clinical quality registries that deal with some governance issues identified by Clay-Williams and colleagues. They describe developing a legal agreement, which 21% of hospitals refused to accept. The Southern Eastern Border States (SEBS) Committee was developed with representatives of health departments from Victoria, New South Wales, Queensland and South Australia to streamline and prevent duplication of legal agreements.3 We worked with a SEBS Committee representative to develop special clauses and conditions to include in the Medicines Australia Clinical Trials Research Agreement schedule, subsequently endorsed by the SEBS Committee. Participating sites, both public and private, recognise and routinely accept this agreement. This same committee, or one with a similar construct, could determine nationally whether research is low risk to address the confused and contradictory advice given by ethics committees. We agree that standardisation of forms and processes is required — participating sites should not be permitted to introduce their own forms, causing confusion to researchers and introducing additional delays. A national information portal and repository for protocol amendments which governance officers can access to review or approve changes would be welcomed. However, while Clay-Williams and colleagues recommend that there should be no requirement for principal investigators to be employees of the participating site, we believe that for clinical quality registries, having a local principal investigator provides a vital link between researchers and local staff. As previously suggested,4 limits should apply on an acceptable time period to provide a definitive determination on study conduct within an institution, as occurs in Europe with clinical trials.5 It is unacceptable that this process lasts more than 60 days. As researchers usually have no capacity to have an impact on institutional authorisation processes, greater accountability should vest with governance offices. The current costly and dysfunctional system is stifling research in Australia.
Sue M Evans · John R Zalcberg · Ri Scarborough
Potential solutions to improve the governance of multicentre health services research
In reply
Jeffrey Braithwaite · Robyn Clay-Williams · Natalie Taylor
The efficacy of medical student selection tools in Australia and New Zealand
To the Editor: In their recent article, Shulruf and colleagues1 concluded that prior academic achievement constituted the most effective means of predicting timely graduation. This outcome measure overlooks a more important graduate attribute: professionalism — the values and skills that the profession and society expects of doctors. This attribute is identifiable at admission, and it is possible to test for and select for this.2 When considering the desired outcome of satisfactory performance at junior medical officer level, the authors state that the “outcome of subsequent workplace performance, while important, is moderated by influences beyond the undergraduate environment”.1 This statement contradicts extensive literature suggesting otherwise. An erosion of vicarious empathy during medical education programs is well documented and is evident across other health care professions.3 Medical school education fails to consistently foster the development of advanced moral reasoning in medical students, with particular problems developing during the period of clinical immersion, when the influence of the “hidden curriculum” becomes evident to students.3 The above have been linked to the experience of burnout in students, which can manifest as professionalism lapses in both pre-clinical and clinical rotations.4 Papadakis and colleagues5 suggested that disciplinary action by a medical board was strongly associated with prior unprofessional behaviour in medical school. Most complaints against doctors are due to conduct, not competence. Many organisations have developed guidelines to ensure medical students adhere to professional standards. Academic and intellectual qualities alone cannot predict the ideal candidate for admission to medical school, and facets of professionalism such as moral orientation, resilience and self-control are acknowledged to contribute to one’s efficacy as a doctor. Furthermore, prioritising timely completion may promote students not seeking help, perpetuating poor performance in an effort to ensure timely completion. This perpetuates a workplace culture where people do not feel able to seek help, with significant repercussions as seen in the recent suicides of young doctors. Timely completion may indeed be predicted by prior academic success; however, attitudinal and behavioural factors are highly relevant at selection and throughout subsequent careers. An overemphasis on prior academic achievements may de-emphasise student characteristics associated with the development of professionalism.
Mark H Arnold · Jennifer Smith-Merry · Andrew S Lane
Glycaemic control apps for diabetes: lifting the lid
We need to establish guidelines and a framework to ensure the development of effective, safe and relevant health apps, with appropriate regulatory oversight
Rahul Barmanray · Esther Briganti
Ethics and site-specific governance approvals for multi-centre, inter-sector health care research
Time is ticking: administrative delays to undertaking low risk health research need to be minimised
Holly Foot · Ian A Scott · Grant M Russell · Neil Cottrell · Nancy Sturman · Christopher R Freeman
Regulating consumer use of transcranial direct current stimulation devices
Despite limited evidence of improvements in cognition, transcranial direct current stimulation devices are being marketed to healthy consumers for performance enhancement.
Anne-Maree Farrell · Adrian Carter · Nigel C Rogasch · Paul B Fitzgerald
Mandatory data breach notification requirements for medical practice
By establishing well functioning internal procedures and by informing patient expectations as to how their information is managed and by whom, the aftermath of a data breach may be reduced in severity
David J Carter · Samuel Hartridge
Informed consent and internet-based research in epidemiology
National guidelines are needed for internet-based research and to provide guidance on acceptable standards for storing evidence of informed consent
Laura Goddard · Fiona J Bruinsma · Graham G Giles
Children as haematopoietic stem cell donors: ethically challenging and legally complex
Clinicians should be aware of the particular physical and psychological risks of haematopoietic stem cell donation in the paediatric setting, and the varying laws between states and territories
Shih-Ning Then · Ian H Kerridge · Michael Marks
Potential solutions to improve the governance of multicentre health services research
We need to improve bureaucratic behaviour in health services research
Robyn Clay-Williams · Natalie Taylor · Jeffrey Braithwaite
The other source of government funding for medical research that needs reform
Gifted funding runs the risk of bypassing peer review
Anthony F Jorm
Compassion and evidence in prescribing cannabinoids: a perspective from the Royal Australasian College of Physicians
The RACP emphasises the need for caution until there is sufficient quality evidence to support the use of medicinal cannabis
Jennifer H Martin · Yvonne Bonomo · Adrian DB Reynolds
Disease prestige and the hierarchy of suffering
Suffering should not be hierarchical, and care should not be predicated on the prestige that a disease attracts
Louise Stone
Legal does not mean unaccountable: suing tobacco companies to recover health care costs
The potential benefits of holding tobacco companies to account through litigation may affect future Australian tobacco control strategies.
Ross MacKenzie · Eric LeGresley · Mike Daube
Euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide: focus on the data
To the Editor:Emanuel1 enjoins readers to focus on the data concerning euthanasia and physician-assisted suicide (PAS), and to aim at improving the care of dying patients, but advances straw arguments on the basis of three claims in the end-of-life debates that are disputed by neither advocates nor opponents of assisted dying. From the fact that euthanasia and PAS are rarely requested and rarely cause death, Emanuel argues that legalising them will not help solve the problem of inadequate symptom management or improve palliative care. But he adduces no evidence that supporters of legalisation make this claim. Describing legalisation as “really a sideshow in end-of-life care — championed by the few for the few” minimises the plight of those who would avail themselves of euthanasia and PAS, and is belied by the consistent majority support in Western communities for legalisation.2 Pain is recognised, by both advocates and opponents of legalisation, to not be the primary reason why people seek euthanasia and PAS. To claim that the real motivators of requests for assistance (eg, depression, loss of control and loss of dignity) “are not relieved by increasing the dose of morphine, but by antidepressants and therapy”, perpetuates the myth that medicine can, and should, always provide therapeutic answers to such personal dilemmas.3 Emanuel describes requests for euthanasia and PAS as amounting to “traditional suicide condoned and assisted by the medical community”, on the grounds that they are motivated by psychological factors. This statement begs the question about the ethical and legal propriety of euthanasia and PAS by equating PAS with other categories of suicide, without adequate analysis. No one would be surprised at the data supporting Emanuel’s claim that all medical procedures have problems and complications, and that euthanasia and PAS are no exceptions. But to conclude from this that “the common view of euthanasia and PAS as quick, flawless, and painless ways to die is unrealistic” introduces an alleged “common view” that is also unsupported. These are all examples that seem to advance evidence-based arguments in support of a particular ethical and policy position, but one that has been decided ahead of the evidence.
Malcolm H Parker
The right to know versus the right to privacy: donor anonymity and the Assisted Reproductive Treatment Amendment Act 2016 (Vic)
Recent Victorian legislation is ethically defensible but will need to be closely monitored
Xavier Symons
No Jab, No Pay and vaccine refusal in Australia: the jury is out
To the Editor:While vaccine refusal is but one contributor among several to failures of vaccine-preventable disease control, as stated by Beard and colleagues,1 there are important ethical aspects of vaccine refusal. Intentionally opting out of vaccination imposes risks on others, and policies allowing some to opt out weigh their freedom to do so against the rights of others not to be harmed by vaccine-preventable diseases.2 In particular, people who cannot be safely vaccinated (eg, infants) or maintain immunity (eg, the immunosuppressed) are at increased risk of severe disease — including death — and depend on the immunity of others.2 It is true that herd immunity has no “magic threshold”:1 even with high population vaccination levels, severe harm may be caused when just one unvaccinated person has contact with an infectious person and then a vulnerable person. The death of an immunosuppressed woman from measles pneumonitis in the state of Washington, United States, in 2015 is a case in point.3 Tighter legislation on universal vaccination does not unfairly target vaccine refusal. Indeed, Victorian No Jab, No Play legislation has a general objective: “to increase immunisation rates for young children,”4 which applies equally to people who have unintentionally failed to vaccinate and those who intentionally opt out due to hesitancy or refusal. Policy should make vaccination the norm and aim for the highest possible coverage. Moreover, while we should revise financial penalties if they unfairly burden poor families (while the wealthy may pay to opt out), policy should, in some way, recognise that conscientious objection to vaccination has consequences for others.5 Measles outbreaks are correlated with vaccine refusal6 and lead to significant social costs, which Australia may avoid if high levels of vaccination are maintained. Though the true epidemiology is certainly more complex, if measles vaccination leads to immunity in 99% of vaccine recipients, and 95% of people are vaccinated,1 the population level of immunity would be 94.05%. Threshold concepts have limitations, but whether this is “comfortably exceeding” 94%,1 or perilously close to recurrent measles outbreaks — which impose avoidable risks of harm on others — is a matter for debate.
Euzebiusz Jamrozik
No Jab, No Pay and vaccine refusal in Australia: the jury is out
In reply
Frank H Beard · Julie Leask · Peter B McIntyre
Performance data and informed consent: a duty to disclose?
Evidence mounts for a legal duty to disclose performance data as part of informed consent
Rebekah E McWhirter
Robotic prostatectomy took off, despite a lack of evidence and risks of inequity
Editor’s note: The Lancet recently published an important Australian randomised controlled trial of robotic and open prostatectomy. We publish the following non-commissioned correspondence by Hutchison and colleagues together with an invited response from the corresponding author of the trial, Robert Gardiner, because of the relevance of the debate to Australian health care. To the Editor: Robotic prostatectomy took off quickly, despite the cost. In Australia, most prostatectomies are now done with a robot that costs almost $10 000 in capital and maintenance per procedure, or between $442 and $3548 more than an open prostatectomy.1 The robotic option was meant to reduce side effects relating to impotence and incontinence; however, preliminary findings from the world’s first randomised controlled trial suggest that this is not the case.2 Uptake of innovative surgery tends to outpace evidence because it is hard to design and run randomised studies. In addition, placebo surgery is rare and controversial, and recruitment is challenging, as surgeons and patients often prefer one option. Trial results may also be difficult to interpret: if the same surgeon performs both operations, they may be better at one; or if different surgeons operate, one may be superior.3 Australia is not immune to these challenges, despite local initiatives to improve quality of care4 and evaluate the benefits of the robotic procedure.5 The industry understands this. Intuitive Surgical aggressively marketed its robot while the jury was still out on its comparative benefits. Celebrity stories have also driven demand; for instance, radio personality Alan Jones has been an outspoken advocate.6 But even when evidence commends a surgical innovation, introducing it to the public health care system may create or exacerbate inequity. Suppose that the robot, or some successor, eventually proves superior to alternatives. Expensive equipment and difficult procedures require high patient throughput to justify the costs and maintain surgeons’ skills, so they tend to be concentrated in the biggest, busiest hospitals. Therefore, patients in regional areas are often expected to travel for treatment, with little or no financial support; and the barrier is even higher for people who do not have the social and economic resources to get themselves to a big city hospital.7 We should resist the hype of a new technology and wait for good evidence before expending scarce health care dollars. This will sometimes mean lagging behind other countries and saying no to patients. However, it will also mean safeguarding patients and the public purse from innovations that turn out to be no better, or maybe worse, than existing options. Moreover, when a new technology is introduced, we should also fund the supports that people need to access it.
Katrina Hutchison · Drew Carter · Jane Johnson
Including minority populations in research: we must do better
Time, money and commitment are needed to increase the value of medical research — and to respect participants
for the CREATE Methods Group
Exclusions from clinical trials in Australia based on proficiency in English
One in five registered clinical trials in Australia documented exclusion of participants with low English proficiency
Fiona Stanaway · Robert G Cumming · Fiona Blyth
Psilocybin-assisted therapy for anxiety and depression: implications for euthanasia
Contemporary research suggests potential benefits of psychedelic drugs in treatment-resistant depression and terminally ill patients
Nigel Strauss
Premature deaths of nursing home residents: an epidemiological analysis
A national policy framework is needed to reduce the number of premature deaths in nursing homes
Joseph E Ibrahim · Lyndal Bugeja · Melissa Willoughby · Marde Bevan · Chebiwot Kipsaina · Carmel Young · Tony Pham · David L Ranson