Volume 199 - Issue 8
Suicide risk assessment: where are we now?
Authors: Michael S Gordon and Glenn A Melvin
Med J Aust 2013; 199 (8): 534. || doi: 10.5694/mja13.10761
Published online: 21 October 2013
Published online: 21 October 2013
Can assessing risk factors for suicide attempts help in predicting suicide risk?
To the Editor: We applaud Ryan and Large for their timely editorial reviewing suicide risk factors.1 We agree that, with current knowledge, we do not know how to combine risk factors to produce a reliable predictor of suicide risk in the short to medium term.
However, we note that many risk factors for suicide are also risk factors for suicide attempts.2 For adolescents, attempts occur at a rate of between 400 and 3000 for each suicide.3 Therefore, detection of suicide risk factors also contributes to identifying those who are at risk of attempting suicide, something not discussed by Ryan and Large. Suicide attempts lead to medical morbidity and family suffering and are a considerable burden on emergency departments.4
We find Ryan and Large’s advice that, “here and now, clinicians should not be conducting ‘comprehensive suicide risk assessments’” problematic. They do not provide a meaningful alternative.
We are concerned that medical practitioners who read the editorial will abandon asking about suicide altogether. We are unclear what the authors define as constituting “psychological crisis” and wonder how feasible it would be for general practitioners to make crisis plans with possibly a large number of their patients. We are also interested in the opinion of medical indemnity organisations regarding the authors’ advice to not conduct comprehensive risk assessments, in the event that a patient who presents with suicidal thinking comes to any harm.
Competing interests
No relevant disclosures.
References
- Ryan CJ, Large MM. Suicide risk assessment: where are we now [editorial]? Med J Aust 2013; 198: 462-463.
- Beautrais AL. Risk factors for suicide and attempted suicide among young people. Aust N Z J Psychiatry 2000; 34: 420-436. 0_i1142869
- Mann JJ, Emslie G, Baldessarini RJ, et al. ACNP Task Force report on SSRIs and suicidal behavior in youth. Neuropsychopharmacology 2006; 31: 473-492. 0_i1142873
- Larkin GL, Smith RP, Beautrais AL. Trends in US emergency department visits for suicide attempts, 1992-2001. Crisis 2008; 29: 73-80. 0_i1142876
Reorienting Allied Health Into Community-Based Care for People Experiencing Trauma and Social Disadvantage
Simon Rosenbaum, Grace McKeon, Gulsah Kurt, Oscar Lederman, Kemi Wright, Sabuj Kanti Mistry, Jackie E. Curtis, Philip B. Ward, Zachary Steel, Hamish Fibbins, Rachel Morell, Melissa C. Eaton, Andrew Watkins, Ben Harris-Roxas, Brendan Goodger, Eleanor Beck, Megan Teychenne, Joseph Firth, Davy Vancampfort, David Burns, Russell Roberts, Tristan Favaloro, Danielle Weber, Rosanna Barbero, Vasili Maroulis, Melissa Holmes, Stefan Mackenzie, Chiara Mastrogiovanni, Afsana Anwar, Uzma Choudhry, Catherine Sherrington, Jane Currie, Thomas Gadsden, Scott Teasdale
Stigmatising Attitudes Towards People With Depression, Bipolar Disorder, Borderline Personality, ADHD and Early and Long-Term/Untreated Schizophrenia: Representative Survey of Australian Adults
Amy J. Morgan, Anna M. Ross, Gayle McNaught, Rachel Green, Nicola J. Reavley
Psychosocial Hazards for Healthcare Workers: Supporting the Second Victim Also Helps the Primary Victims
Sarah Michael
Supporting Population Mental Health in the Wake of Mass Tragedies
Susan J. Rees, Derrick M. Silove
In the Wake of the National Suicide Prevention Strategy 2025–2035: Suicide Prevention in Type 1 Diabetes
Rigel Paciente, Keely Bebbington, Alix Woolard, Helen Milroy
The risk of death after hospitalisation following intentional self‐poisoning: a retrospective observational study (PAVLOVA‐2)
Firouzeh Noghrehchi, Nicholas A Buckley, Rose Cairns