Topics

Social determinants of health

Substance‐related disorders Correction January 2005 Free

Correction: The hidden tragedy of offender deaths

Re: “The hidden tragedy of offender deaths”, the editorial by Stuart Ross in the 1 November issue of the Journal (Med J Aust 2004; 181: 469-470). The reference numbering in the text is incorrect because of a computer error. In the first 3 paragraphs, references 12, 13, 14 and 15 should be references 1, 2, 3 and 4, respectively. All other references are correct, except for reference 13 in the last paragraph of the text, which, again, should be reference 2. The html and pdf versions of the article published in the eMJA were corrected on 17 December 2004.

Stuart Ross

Social determinants of health South Pacific December 2004 Free

Taking the family to East Timor

How did I come to be in East Timor? That is the exact question I asked myself upon arriving in Dili, the national capital, with my husband Ben, our 2-year-old son Oscar and 6-month-old daughter Chloe in tow. It was very hot and humid and there was a real threat of a looming dengue epidemic from Indonesia. My anxiety for the health of our children was in no way eased when, a few days after our arrival, an Australian expatriate asked, “What sort of a place is this to bring kids?”. Main entrance to the Dili National Hospital I had been aware of a program coordinated by Eugene Athan, an infectious diseases physician, whereby Australian physicians could work at the Dili National Hospital. As an infectious diseases physician with an interest in medicine in developing countries, and having been assured of the political stability of the country, I put up my hand to go. Ben was able to take time off work to care for our children. After many months of planning, multiple vaccinations, and reassuring family and friends of our safety and wellbeing, we arrived in Dili in late January 2004. The Dili National Hospital is run by the East Timor Ministry of Health. The hospital medical staff consists of overseas visiting specialists, Indonesian emergency department doctors, and Timorese resident doctors working on the wards and in the outpatient department. There are no locally trained specialists — a major limitation to the long-term goal of having an autonomous Timorese hospital. I worked on the women’s medical ward for 2 months. While not arduous, the work was emotionally draining. In my first week, there were three postpartum deaths due to presumed sepsis. Like anyone, I found this difficult to deal with, but being there with my family, and still breastfeeding Chloe, made it even harder. My emotions were fuelled by the thought that one family now consisted of a husband without a wife, and four kids without a mum. The harsh reality of the estimated maternal mortality in Timor (around 800 per 100 000 live births) is that this family circumstance is not uncommon. Despite Portuguese being the official language, the majority of Timorese people speak either Tetum, Indonesian, or one of 16 indigenous languages. As my Tetum capabilities were limited to pleasantries, I relied heavily on certain hospital staff to interpret for me. Needless to say, taking an adequate history and communicating with the patients and hospital staff proved to be a challenge — like a combination of charades and Pictionary. The language barrier became even more difficult towards the end of my stint, when a Chinese medical team arrived that included doctors, a nurse and a translator. They had spent 6 months learning Portuguese, which, despite the best of intentions, was of no practical use to the majority of people at the hospital. One of the beaches within an hour’s drive of Dili. These were a favourite place for expatriates and United Nations staff to gather on Sunday afternoons. The hospital was serviced by hospital and national laboratories that performed basic testing, which was intermittently available and of variable standard. Malaria films were regularly performed, with frequent positive results. Biochemical tests, including tests for urea and creatinine, were not available during my stay. Minimal microbiological investigations (including tuberculosis smears, and serology for HIV, hepatitis B, hepatitis C and syphilis) were available. Pathology specimens were sent to Australia, with a 6–8-week turnaround time. The major medical problems I encountered at the hospital included tuberculosis, malaria, renal failure, heart failure, thyroid disease and hypertension. As all patients had varying degrees of malnutrition, I kept them in hospital for as long as possible, knowing that the hospital would provide nutritious meals. Of concern was the lack of a single positive sputum smear test for acid-fast bacilli during my stay. For whatever reason (be it deficiencies in collection, transport, processing, laboratory technique or reporting), all sputum smears were negative. Aware that this could not be accurate, I introduced antituberculosis therapies in patients for whom there was a high suspicion of tuberculosis based on clinical features and x-ray results. Of greater public health concern was the lack of mycobacterial culture and sensitivity testing facilities. A national tuberculosis control program has been established to monitor patients during treatment, but some patients did not complete their therapy and it is unclear whether drug resistance is a problem. It was hard to believe we were only a 1-hour flight away from Australia. Drug therapy options were limited to an essential drug list; however, even these, at times, were unavailable. Although we had previously worked in Africa, we found it difficult to comprehend that the national hospital of one of Australia’s close neighbours could have such limited resources. Despite their many hardships and difficulties, I was touched by the loving nature and strong sense of family among the Timorese people. They were very receptive to us as a family, but we certainly raised some eyebrows. For starters, I was working while Ben stayed at home with the kids, which many locals found amusing! Ben spent most of the time fighting off malaria and dengue-carrying mosquitoes and keeping the kids and himself cool by whatever means, including a staple diet of ice-cream for the kids and beer for himself. During weekends off, we were able to hire a car and explore many beautiful parts of the country. Having spent only a short period of time at the Dili hospital, I was grateful for the welcome I received and the warmth of the hospital staff. Upon leaving, I felt I had contributed to the health of my patients, and yet had a deep sense of sadness because it seemed that the healthcare system may worsen before it improves. So, were we foolish to take our kids to Timor? On the contrary — we believe that we took them to a place full of caring, loving and welcoming people who deserve the chance to live a better life.

Carolyn L Beckett MB BS(Hons), FRACP

History and humanities Power of one December 2004 Free

Following fortune’s path

Your position never gives you the right to command. It only imposes on you the duty of living your life so that others can receive your orders without being humiliated. Dag Hammarskjöld, UN Secretary-General, 1953–1961 awarded the Nobel Prize for Peace I grew up in Canberra in the 1920s and ’30s, then, as now, a planned and favoured town awash with politics, politicians and public servants. Although interested in these dynamics, our caring, skilled family doctor was the person who most impressed me. John James FRCS was our community’s quiet medical leader, later recognised through the John James Medical Centre, now part of Canberra’s teaching hospital system. My parents were typical of their time. My father had emigrated from Britain in his teens and served in France in World War I. He was a public servant with the Federal Capital Commission (which from January 1925 was responsible for the planning and development of Canberra). He had a vocational flair for amateur theatricals of music hall and comedy genre. My mother was a capable homemaker. We became aware of the Great Depression just about the time my sister was born. My parents combined to have our large yard supplement our pantry. Mother became a genius in food preserving with the Fowler Vacola steam preservation kit, providing a great variety of foods. As children, my sister and I had warm and strong emotional, social and aspirational support, but our choices for our futures were our own. My parents offered two aphorisms: “Hard work is not lethal” and “Loyalty and fairness are necessary for success”. I have not found either to be wanting. In choosing a career, medicine held no competitor for me, although I dallied momentarily with veterinary science. I experienced the grief of three of my school classmates succumbing to diseases that now rarely cause death: poliomyelitis, mastoiditis and diphtheria. Polio returned to the class several times, and, although not lethal, it was damaging beyond reason, both physically and psychologically. Polio, in particular, marginalised those it affected. I felt that more could be done to alleviate this unfairness. “The effect of a teacher may be infinite”My undergraduate days during World War II were spent at the University of Sydney and at St Vincent’s Hospital, Darlinghurst. I commuted daily on the on-time “red rattler” (today we say “if only”) and travelled between campuses on the tram. Hospital life as a student was immensely fulfilling, and I matured among competitive peers. Two of my tutors made these days particularly memorable: Justin Markell, the meticulous, kindly physician in outpatients, and Douglas Miller, later Sir Douglas Miller, who became a leader in neurosurgery and President of the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons. Both encouraged and taught a careful approach to physical examination, diagnosis and patient care. They provided a sound basis for my future clinical endeavours. I became a junior resident at Marrickville District Hospital in 1947. At that time, 18 months to two years after graduation saw most graduates enter general practice. I also aimed to do so. Marrickville Hospital was general practitioner oriented, with specialist honorary staff drawn from Royal Prince Alfred Hospital. These included role models like the late Sir Thomas Greenway, a charismatic, thoughtful and instructive physician, and Frank Mills, a friendly, insightful surgeon who had made his reputation in Changi and Sandakan in World War II. He visited his patients often and always left a dusting of his knowledge on the junior staff. Looking further afieldAfter 18 months and still attracted to general practice, it was time to move forward. Two positions presented themselves: one for a medical officer on Macquarie Island, the most southerly point of Oceania in the Australian Antarctic Basin; and the second, for Medical Superintendent at Collinsville, a small coal mining town in north Queensland. My colleague Bob Allison and I applied for both and were interviewed together by the Antarctic pioneer, Phillip Law, in front of the dying embers of the log fire in the common room of the (old) University Club in Phillip Street, Sydney. Bob went to Macquarie Island and I to Collinsville. As the only doctor in town, I enjoyed 18 months of rich clinical experience. Post-term obstetric deliveries, head injuries, critically ill children, motor vehicle accidents and accidents involving horses all hastened my clinical maturity. I remember a young jackeroo with a perinephric abscess after a nasty horse-related accident. As we were stranded by floods at the time, a surgeon in Mackay took me through the operative steps by phone. All ended well. The community was full of reliable, loyal Aussies with enormous hearts. They were openly friendly and had a great bank of skills, and gave their local doctor the comfort often absent today. An outbreak of croup in some young children was the most formidable of my experiences. They desperately needed steam inhalation, but I was a little nonplussed as to how to supply it. One father spoke with his boss at the mine workshop, who rapidly produced a large galvanised watering can with four arms, each capped with a watering-can rose. Placed on a primus stove, this device effectively dispensed steam to four mosquito-netted cots simultaneously. Problem solved! Surgeon by serendipityI was no longer sure that I wanted to pursue general practice and planned to undertake postgraduate work in the United States. I applied for several positions and was appointed to a rotating internship at Albany Medical College, New York State. At my request, it included a term of psychiatry. I arrived to take up my appointment in 1950, just as the Korean War began. Given my previous surgical experience, I was promptly moved from psychiatry to surgery. The experience was life-changing. As the American surgical residents were drafted to Korea, I was promoted after six months, subsequently accepting the offer of five years’ graduated surgical training in the Halsted tradition at Albany Medical Center. William Halsted had been Foundation Professor of Surgery at Johns Hopkins University in Baltimore, and laid the basis for graduated surgical training. This proved to be five years of restricted finances, but top professional fulfilment and growth. My workday would start with 5.30 am ward rounds (before the chief arrived at 7.30 am), followed by a day in theatre, then admissions and lab work before falling into bed. How much more civilised work practices are today. I was embarrassed when my previous senior resident returned from Korea to be my junior, and his view “c’est la guerre” was most generous and the basis of a long friendship. My training was predominantly in general surgery (with much exposure to thyroid surgery) and included my introduction to clinical investigation, which initially centred on bleeding varices and the monitoring of serum ammonia concentration.1 A three-month exchange with the Women’s Clinic at Johns Hopkins in Baltimore allowed me to work under the dynamic Richard Te Linde, Head of the Gynecology Department. Another privileged memory was witnessing the early development of cardiac surgery, as Alfred Blalock, under the watchful eye of cardiologist Helen Taussig, performed his “blue baby” procedure for tetralogy of Fallot and for alleviating the effects of congenital cardiac defects.2 My final 18 months were spent in Albany in thoracic surgery at the time of its greatest development, as the pump oxygenator was introduced. These five years were shared with a global workforce from 27 nations including Japan and Germany. The chiefs of medicine and surgery offered opportunity and education to all, hoping to heal wounds from World War II. This global experiment was clearly ahead of its time, and resulted in many firm international friendships. Being Australian was a significant plus, as Australia was popular after its Pacific role and genuine friendliness to US troops. In 1953, I married Mary Jo, whom I met in the operating room at Albany Medical Center. She has been my loyal supporter and valued confidante since. Return to Australia — spreading my wingsI returned to Sydney in 1955. Many doors were initially closed, but, with recommendations from mentors, I was eventually employed by Frank Rundle, Director of the Unit of Clinical Investigation at Royal North Shore Hospital (RNSH). After six months I received a full-time research fellowship with clinical responsibilities in my areas of interest, giving me the opportunity to be involved in thyroid surgery and studies; isotopes and cancer chemotherapy; a prospective database for thyroidectomy; and ultrasound of the breast. Thyroid clinic: I worked with Rundle in his multidisciplinary thyroid clinic and helped develop an animal experimental facility. This brought me into contact with Ian Monk, a cardiothoracic surgeon, who, with a pump expert, Viv Ebsary, was exploring open-heart surgery.3 The use of animals for experiments caused significant angst, especially when clandestine activity was required — such as transporting anaesthetised sheep by wheelbarrow to a ground floor angiographic facility for experimental studies. From such humble beginnings, the entire unit later evolved to become the Wellcome Laboratories. Rundle was a perfectionist, demanding that our every activity be of the highest safety and quality. The preoperative checklist was instituted (now indispensable in modern risk management) to ensure nothing was omitted in preparing patients. Every operative step was to be as haemostatic as possible,4 and postoperative care empathic and supportive. These requirements became expected of all who worked or trained in what later became the University of Sydney Academic Surgical Unit at RNSH. Cancer chemotherapy: A grant from the NSW State Cancer Council in 1958 enabled me to spend four months with cancer specialists Joe Burchenal and David Karnofsky (known for the Karnofsky Performance Scale for assessing terminally ill patients) at Memorial Sloan-Kettering Cancer Center in New York. I returned to initiate the provision of cytotoxic therapy at RNSH, which later established a formal medical oncology unit. Even then, the need to embrace randomisation and the careful accrual of evidence was seen as crucial.5-7 Thyroid database: On leaving the United States in 1955, I had been encouraged by my surgical mentors to embrace the computer age and “develop a prospective databank to record progress and results” — “outcome” as a word was still aborning. Our first cases at RNSH were accrued in 1957 and, over time, we honed the database into a useful clinical and research resource. All thyroid and parathyroid surgical procedures by the Endocrine Surgical Unit at RNSH are recorded, and at my retirement in 1988 numbered 10 000 entries. Intrathoracic goitre: During the period of compulsory mass x-ray surveys for pulmonary tuberculosis in Australia between 1948 and 1975, many people were diagnosed with intrathoracic goitre. A prevalence study we conducted in metropolitan Sydney in 1953–1956 showed that intrathoracic goitre occurred in 1/5040 subjects examined (compared with 1/750 with active tuberculosis and 1/3500 with lung cancer) (Box 1). Unexpectedly, the prevalence of intrathoracic goitre was about three times greater among people born in England (then the main source of immigrants) than in those born in Australia.8 Diagnosis of intrathoracic goitre improved with the introduction of computed tomography scanning, as did the safety of operative procedures. We used a surgical approach based on embryology — a transverse incision in the lower neck (a collar incision) — delivering the goitre into the neck, which, with appropriate control of vascularity, resulted in minimal sternal splitting and avoided a transthoracic approach.9 This technique was refined over time with much input from surgical colleagues Alan Poole and Leigh Delbridge (and the surgical registrars) and particularly our anaesthetist Bruce White. Superb scrub and bedside nursing helped to ensure success. This led to a rethink in the treatment of recurrent goitre and provided leadership in optimising total thyroidectomy for nodular goitre, now a widely accepted procedure despite earlier controversy.10-13 Breast ultrasound: A visit to RNSH in 1962 by George Kossoff (who with David Robinson in 1961 built the first ultrasound scanner at the Commonwealth Acoustic Laboratories) led to another fortunate and fruitful long term collaboration — ultrasound of the breast (Box 2). Surgery — academic and vascularIn 1961, Academic Clinical Units were established at RNSH, with the support of Sir John Loewenthal, then the Chair of Surgery at the University of Sydney. I was appointed Senior Lecturer in Surgery and subsequently became the inaugural Professor of Surgery in 1974. I believed, like Osler (quoting John Henry Newman), that: “An academical system without the personal influence of teachers upon pupils, is an Arctic winter.”18 Students were involved as far as possible in all unit activities, and teaching students and residents in the operating theatre became a major thrust of our program, although initially we were limited by a lack of full-time teachers.19,20 Graham Coupland was appointed senior lecturer in surgery in 1967 and was as great a friend and associate as I could have hoped for. With fellow surgeon Harry Cumberland, and encouraged by Douglas Piper, Professor of Medicine, he refined the investigation and surgical treatment of peptic ulcer, for which their preferred procedure was highly selective vagotomy.21 Coupland’s untimely death in 1982 came at a time of unit growth, as we taught exceptional undergraduates, trained bright young people of integrity, and produced quality surgery and research. Vascular surgery was developed by Douglas Tracy with my assistance.22 However, with his departure to the University of New South Wales in 1961, this specialty grew very demanding of those remaining — Ray Hollings, myself, and later Graham Coupland. Ruptured aneurysms, which require immediate surgery, became the bête noire of our social and family life. At that time, pagers, which were the size and weight of a house brick, only emitted an alarm, and a telephone call determined the reason for the call. In 1977, RNSH agreed to the appointment of a full-time academic vascular surgeon, Michael Appleberg, an excellent leader who took the department through to substantial strength in surgery,23 research and training. A stream of overseas and domestic visitors and interactive visits between the RNSH unit and overseas units promoted clinical and research strengths (Box 3). RetirementAll these activities have provided a springboard for continued enjoyment of life after I retired from academia in 1988. Elected President of the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons in 1989, I have travelled extensively in Australia and New Zealand. This experience has reinforced my perception that the exceptional compassion and service given in war are still given in peace. Australasian surgery and surgeons stand high with me. I was asked to report on quality assurance in clinical management to the Australian Government Department of Health,24 and now follow with interest the progress of the Australian Council for Safety and Quality in Health Care. As Chair of the working party developing the Clinical Practice guidelines on the management of early breast cancer25 and as a member of the board of the National Breast Cancer Centre (1995–2003), I have found it very satisfying to see women empowered to handle a life-threatening disease. Working with the Cancer Council Australia and the Clinical Oncological Society of Australia to develop the Australian Cancer Network has, since 1994, also kept me happily in contact with clinicians and consumers in promoting better cancer care. I have also maintained a clinical interest through surgical assisting. I have more time to “smell the roses” and travel with Mary Jo to see friends and enjoy our grandchildren in the United States, with side trips to Europe. I read more, but am unable to keep up with all the good books that are published. I also have time to think over the contrasts between then and now and what is to come. Surgery in 1947 was more uneven than today. There were top-level surgeons who performed to their level. A good deal of surgery, however, was done in small hospitals across the community, and too frequently exploratory laparotomy was performed for an obscure diagnosis. The limitations were primarily in training and diagnostic technology. The idea that doctors “owned” the patients was diminishing, but still prevalent. This limited patients in obtaining a second opinion, when perhaps it should have been embraced. I have observed changes and been pleased to have the opportunity to be involved, and sometimes been supportive in promoting change. Strong academic units centred in training hospitals across Australia have, together with the Royal Australasian College of Surgeons and specialist surgical societies, embraced strong mentoring and graduated and proficient training. The quality of surgery and hospitals has been improved by these educational and vocational developments. Australian patients have access to surgery of the highest quality. The future for surgery should know no limits, with increasing precision of diagnosis, limited wounding associated with surgical access, and developments in pharmacological and genetic interventions. Surgeons will be expected to understand and fully explain the complexities of many new approaches to treatment, some of which will not be operative surgery. The psychosocial aspects of surgery will reinforce the benefits patients should enjoy from the science and art of surgery, in which the level of trust between surgeon and patient must remain inviolable. I am delighted that opportunity for betterment for patients expands apace. Fortune has indeed smiled on me. As I look to the future, remembering colleagues, nurses, students and patients, I remain aware that I have gathered a posy of other men’s flowers and only the ribbon which binds them is mine (Sanskrit). 1 Age distribution of intrathoracic goitre detected by mass x-ray surveys for tuberculosis (1953–1956) Source: Reeve et al8 2 Development of breast ultrasound imaging — from weather maps to quality images Initial attempts to develop breast ultrasound involved many women volunteers and a bistable waterpath machine, which provided linear, sector and compound scans. Sonograms were initially derived through a water bath in contact with but above the patient. Water sometimes spilled (Figure A), or leaked (Figure B), saturating staff and patients, but not dampening their enthusiasm. Technology (Figures B and C) rapidly improved the quality of sonograms, and, in 1974, the patient’s comfort (Figure C). With Kossoff and his associate, Jack Jellins, ultrasonographer Kaye Griffiths and her team, surgical registrar Bruce Barraclough, and sonograms from our volunteers, we were able to determine the “normal” sonographic appearance of the breast. It was hard going until Kossoff introduced “grey-scale” contrast into sonography,14,15 which allowed tissue contrast and better identification of breast disease, a principle later applied to virtually all tissues16 and “leading to the widespread adoption of ultrasound throughout the world.”17 Ultrasound now plays a significant role in breast cancer diagnosis — no more wet shoes and soaked patients! A. CAL Closed water bag breast echoscope (1966). The bag was lowered onto the chest, and the transducer moved through the waterbath. Coupling with the skin was incomplete and the breast compressed. B. CAL Open water bag breast echoscope (1968). This method allowed for improved coupling to the breast and removed the problem of compression of tissue. The breast floated freely in a water bath. C. CAL Open water tank breast echoscope (1974). A new approach, patient prone and breast freely floating, thus eliminating the need for coupling drapes. (Photos courtesy of George Kossoff.) 3 International Surgical Week — International Association of Endocrine Surgeons, Hong Kong 1993. Back row: Joe Tjandra (Melbourne), Tom Reeve, Leigh Delbridge (Sydney). Front row: Raj Nambiar, Abu Rauf (Singapore), Martin Liepins (Riga, Latvia).

Tom Reeve AC, CBE, FRACS, Emeritus Professor of Surgery, The University of Sydney

General medicine Power of one December 2004 Free

An accidental career in a new discipline

At seventy-seven it is time to be in earnest Samuel Johnson — A journey to the Western Isles of Scotland Nothing about my life has been planned, including medicine. When, to my surprise, I obtained one of the rare scholarships then available to the University of Sydney after the Leaving Certificate, I asked my father what I should do. “Medicine”, he said, “that’s a good career for a woman”. So, despite having no sciences and braving the fierce opposition of my Latin teacher, I obeyed. Nor did I know, even after graduating, what field of medicine to aim for, having spent much of my undergraduate years at Arts lectures and playing bridge. After doing the odd locum and a bit of general practice, I married a naval aviator and had six children. This removed me from medicine for 13 years. Returning to Sydney from Perth (following the fleet) and being short of money, I went to Royal North Shore Hospital (RNSH) and asked to do a refresher course by attending outpatient clinics. Although feeling like a middle-aged frumpish housewife, I was treated by each of the senior consultants, all men, with the utmost courtesy. I have honoured RNSH ever since. It was not easy to get a job. I worked first at Grosvenor Diagnostic Centre, assessing children with intellectual disability. The medical officers were at the fringe of a revolution in genetics, constantly learning about recently discovered syndromes and how to identify these as the underlying causes of the conditions in the people we saw. Yet, we were not esteemed by the medical profession, who referred to us as “guardians of the waiting list”, because we assigned priority to those most urgently in need of the few residential care places available. Our chief concern, however, seemed to be for the parents, and how to reconcile them with the pain of accepting that their children were “different”. From institutions to community careWhen my husband was posted to Melbourne, I worked in a large institution in Victoria, which taught me a lot about institutions and the danger of just accepting what occurred in them. I remember admitting a teenage boy, clinging to his tearful mother. She was at last persuaded to leave, too soon to notice that his bed had no pillow. I asked for one, but the busy charge nurse’s reply was, “I won’t allow pillows in my ward. They might fight with them or smother themselves”. Of course, we were understaffed, the few staff we had were overworked, and the residents had little supervision. So little, in fact, that one girl wandered out of her ward one night and fell into an uncovered hole containing a steam pipe — she was scalded to death. When I recollect this tragedy, I find it hard to accept the pious phrase “the dignity of risk”, which is too often used to justify neglect of people in residential care. Returning to Sydney, I was lucky to be at the start of the deinstitutionalisation program in New South Wales, but soon realised that this was not to be an easy path. Among the first people to move were a group from a large institution on Peat Island. They moved into a small cottage in Hornsby, and soon the neighbours were complaining, not because of discrimination, but because of the frequent noisy quarrels among the four residents about who should do the dishes! Human nature is no different whatever the IQ level. This same quartet looked marvellous — dressed for the first time in dinner jackets and evening gowns — for their first formal, a ball in Hornsby. As I grew older, I became interested in exercise and nutrition. I started to jog in the streets near where I lived, embarrassing my children and husband. It felt so good that I wondered how exercise would work for people with a disability. I obtained a Master of Public Health degree by doing a simple research project on this subject. Then RNSH allowed me to start a health promotion clinic for adults with developmental disability. This was soon enhanced by the arrival of a dietitian, Lyn Stewart, and an exercise physiologist, Caroline Bruce, and we became very busy. It was obvious to me that my colleagues, using nutrition and exercise, improved health faster than I did. Caroline also organised the people into teams and they went for trips at weekends, playing indoor cricket and soccer, and returned with amazing stories of their hijinks. This was a time of fanatical adherence to the philosophy of normalisation — all people with disabilities should live in the community, whatever their special needs, and participate in all community activities. Our staff struck some unrealistic expectations, including carers who refused to be involved in our sports programs, one proclaiming, “We’d rather our residents sat at home all day and never exercised, than take part in segregated activities.” We ignored these thought police, and took one group ourselves for their first sight of snow to luxurious quarters donated by a generous hotelier. At breakfast they sat down to silver and snowy table linen. “Oh look!” said one delighted young man, “we are going first class!” A trip to the snow Royal North Shore Hospital Health Promotion Clinic for Adults with Developmental Disability enjoying a weekend in the mountains. Latin and the logic of epidemiologyThe best teacher I ever had was a Dominican nun, Sister Anselm. She made me love Latin as much as she did. I later took the same delight in epidemiology, the closest thing I have found to thinking in Latin. This prompted my postgraduate studies in public health, completed with a part-time scholarship (awarded to promising public servants in the enlightened practice of the day). I applied epidemiology to the little-studied burden of disease in our patients, in whom I noticed diverse chronic and complex health problems. I obtained a Research and Development Grant from the Commonwealth Department of Community Services and Health for the first population study of health disorders in people with intellectual disability. This showed that, of a random sample of 202 adults with intellectual disability, each had an average of 5.4 medical disorders, half of which had not previously been detected.1 Colleagues in Victoria and Queensland reported that these findings supported their argument for specialised health clinics in those states. Not so enlightened were authorities in NSW, who closed the RNSH Health Promotion Clinic, in the face of many objections. The Department of Community Services’ mys-terious decision ended what was, as far as I know, the first health promotion clinic of its kind in the world. Since then I have tried unsuccessfully to reopen this clinic. An attempted retirementAt that stage, RNSH enforced retirement at the age of 65 years. I was a bored, cross, retired person, so I leapt at the chance to work for a while at Stockton Centre, a large NSW institution for people with intellectual disability. The enlightened administrator at the time, Lorraine Yudaeff, asked if I could find someone to assess the nutrition of the residents. I recruited Lyn Stewart, who had worked with me at RNSH. Lyn ran a tape-measure over some emaciated residents and recommended an enriched diet. This resulted in another study showing that 69 of the multiply-disabled residents in this 550-bed institution were severely underweight, with low levels of vitamin D, iron and folate. They were given a diet with increased caloric density for 12 months, with significant improvements in weight, in serum calcium and vitamin D levels, and in haematological indicators.2 We succeeded in increasing the weight of some very hungry people, but not without protest: one carer said we had ruined the quality of life of an adult resident who now weighed more than his previous 20 kg. He required two people, instead of one, to lift him, and was considered too heavy to take on outings, as they had no hoists. However, the noble staff of Stockton rose to the challenge. Several residents now verge on the overweight, not underweight! As a result of this work, there is now a policy of screening the nutritional and swallowing status of all people with intellectual disability in residential care in NSW. Microarrays — miniaturised assay systems allowing the structure and expression of thousands of genes to be evaluated My mentors and medical detective work I first met Professor Gillian Turner as her locum at Grosvenor. Gillian is now known internationally as a geneticist and has done the fundamental work on identifying the Fragile X syndrome, the most common inherited genetic cause of intellectual disability. This work began when Gillian was a medical officer at Grosvenor and introduced me to the intellectual fascination of dysmorphology and genetic disease. I enjoyed being a medical detective and identifying syndromes. The explosion then occurring in genetics is about to recur, with new technologies such as microarrays (Figure) that will make diagnosis more accessible. Given that a diagnosis can make all the difference to prognosis and treatment of associated physical disease or behavioural phenotype, a group of people much ignored by medicine will be taken more seriously in the future. I once excitedly asked Associate Professor Aidan McElduff (Endocrinologist) in the corridors of Royal North Shore Hospital whether a patient I had referred to him could have Kallman’s syndrome. Aidan looked surprised and said he supposed she could. This turned out to be the underlying aetiology. I was in awe of Aidan’s many qualifications and his far greater knowledge of medicine, but he has since become a mentor, a coauthor of published articles, a collaborator in studies on osteoporosis and hypogonadism, and an expert on the endocrinology of intellectual disability. Aidan once thanked me for introducing him to a new medical specialty, Intellectual Disability Medicine. Battling medical nihilismIt was generally considered inevitable that people with intellectual disability die young, which prompted Seeta Durvasula (Medical Lecturer in Developmental Disabilities, Centre for Developmental Disability Studies, University of Sydney), Wes Baker, Senior Planning Officer, Northern Sydney Health, and myself, to investigate mortality rates in a previously identified cohort of 693 people with intellectual disability in northern Sydney.3 We found that the death rate was five times higher than that of the general population of Sydney’s Lower North Shore.4 Furthermore, the causes of death were quite different from those in the general population, being predominantly respiratory disease and accidents. Seeta Durvasula recently presented data from this ongoing study at an international conference, showing that up to a quarter of these deaths were preventable. Contributory factors, such as inadequate supervision, delayed presentation and delayed diagnosis of illness, were identified. The challenge is now to reduce premature mortality and to treat remediable disease. The NSW Ombudsman is charged with the responsibility for reviewing all deaths of people with disabilities in care, looking at the causes and patterns of death and recommending ways of improving services to reduce early or preventable deaths. This important initiative has been noted internationally and may be replicated in Scotland. We also need to beware of medical nihilism. It is one thing to strive officiously to prevent the demise of an elderly person ravaged with disease. It is another thing to deny treatment to a young person with spastic quadriplegia who is enjoying life but swallows unsafely. I am reminded of a senior consultant with whom I discussed the need for supplementary feeding in some young individuals. “Why treat them”, he said, “aren’t they just vegetables?”. An international movement in intellectual disabilityI presented papers at meetings of the International Association for Intellectual Disability (IASSID) every four years, but found health professionals at these conferences often cowed by our non-medical colleagues, who considered us relics of the past, detested institutions. Encouraged by the then Australian President of IASSID Professor Trevor Parmenter (now Foundation Chair and Director, Centre for Developmental Disability Studies, University of Sydney), a Dutch physician Professor Heleen Evenhuis and I formed the Health Special Interest Research Group of IASSID. This Research Group now has yearly international meetings, and its achievements include developing health targets for adults with an intellectual disability.5,6 These targets address conditions that are highly prevalent, easily identified and amenable to available treatments (eg, regular assessments of hearing, especially if communication problems exist, and of dental and ocular health). The targets have been accepted by IASSID and presented to the World Health Organization for ratification. The future: developmental disability medicineA medical specialty will be established in this field. In The Netherlands, such specialists already exist, while, in the United Kingdom, psychiatrists who have specialised in learning disability are often attached to multidisciplinary teams working with people who have learning disabilities. It is clear, too, that doctors with such specialist knowledge must collaborate with nurses, psychologists, dietitians, speech pathologists, physiotherapists and occupational therapists. If it is possible to have multidisciplinary teams in aged care, such teams should also be available for people with disabilities. Of Australia’s total population, 1.86% have an intellectual disability.7 Thus, this group of people constitutes a population about the same size as our Indigenous population. In my opinion, a specialist clinic at each teaching hospital in Australia is required to support general practitioners caring for people with intellectual disability. In Victoria and Queensland, at least, university-affiliated academic centres for developmental disability provide government-funded medical services. In NSW, the Centre for Developmental Disability Studies at the University of Sydney is not so funded, but has helped me to establish a medical clinic with two other doctors, funded by billing Medicare. Our six-month waiting list illustrates the level of unmet need. Australians with disabilities —predominantly receiving pensions and with no political clout — are caught in a dysfunctional system. Formal responsibility for health and other services has largely passed from the federal to the state governments, with further buck-passing between health and social service departments within the states. Yet, much of their healthcare rests with GPs, funded by the federal government. I was founding chair of the NSW-based Association of Doctors in Developmental Disability (ADIDD), which lobbied for people with disabilities and their need for specialised health services. As it became obvious that this was a national problem, we have now formed the Australian Association of Developmental Disability Medicine (AADDM), which aims to establish national standards in healthcare delivery, lobby federal politicians, issue policy documents and position statements, and, eventually, train specialists in this field. I am lucky to have been present at the beginning of a new branch of medicine. I hope that advances in genetics will eventually lead to a therapeutic revolution for people born with intellectual disability. Meanwhile, we need more medical champions for this vulnerable but silent minority. Receiving an award Member of the Order of Australia (AM) in 2004, receiving the award from Her Excellency Professor Marie Bashir, Governor of New South Wales (left).

Helen P Beange AM, MB BS, MPH, FAFPHM

Health services administration Overseas-trained doctors December 2004 Free

What’s in a name?

Weeks after beginning its winding journey, a redirected letter finally finds its destination. In our eagerness to open it, we almost tear in half the neatly folded crisp white sheet that lists a series of results: angina, pass; asthma, pass; preeclampsia, pass; bulimia, fail, could not elicit history of vomiting; croup, pass. The list continues to a dispassionate conclusion that the candidate has demonstrated adequate knowledge at the examinations of the Australian Medical Council (AMC) to secure a passing grade. The accompanying card graciously thanks us for our tutoring 1 year ago. We stare wordlessly at the sheet, our joy obliterating its sterility. So far, he has fled state persecution, worked 10 years in a factory, and supported a family of four on a minimum wage. The iatrogenic death of his father served as a powerful impetus to return to his calling in life, medicine. Forty years old, he has juggled swimming and soccer lessons, school homework and, lately, running a small business to steal time to prepare for his own examinations. “I promised myself at my father’s bedside that I would go back to medicine. Every day in the factory, I used to dream about becoming a doctor again, but we needed that job to survive.” Now he will forever be known as an “AMC”. As we exuberantly write him a congratulatory note, a vision of his journey ahead involuntarily crosses our mind. As he begins his quest for a job, he will quickly learn that, although all foreign graduates seeking to enter the Australian medical system must take the AMC exam, the term “AMC doctor” automatically carries the connotation of inferiority. Irish, American and German doctors will be identified by country, while he and his peers from the developing world will be separated by an invisible, but distressingly tangible, line. Deeming himself unsuitable for the elite hospitals, he will apply instead to those considered more “foreigner-friendly”, their reputation earned not necessarily for their greater tolerance of foreign graduates, but because of their inability to attract the more aspiring. These hospitals too will first select local graduates before yielding the leftover spots to the AMCs. At the scant interviews he secures, he will be summarily discarded at some on account of his thick (yet understandable) accent and his slow (yet considered) speech. At others, he is unlikely to receive ticks in the boxes that say “team player”, “enthusiastic” and “makes good eye contact”, because he is unfamiliar with the buzzwords and gestures (although not the inherent concepts) that interviewers seek. His first job is almost certain to be in a hospital staffed largely, if not almost exclusively, by foreign doctors. Collegial support will be tentative, the focus being on surviving each day without raising the staff’s ire. He will be greeted cautiously, unaware of an unspoken probation, and he might only enjoy a few days’ grace before barbed remarks escape their loose restraint. Despite his commitment, he will be slow, never having had the benefit of observing local protocol as a student or a subintern. Despite having passed his exams, he will hesitate with most tasks, including the essential ones of documenting directions, checking blood tests and making a physiotherapy referral, because he is a stranger to them all. Some doctors and nurses might lend a kind and guiding hand, but he is more likely to (over)hear the following: “You are the resident — it’s your job!” “Why do I always end up with the AMCs?” “He might be a nice person, but he doesn’t have a clue!”. Occasionally, the remarks will be deliberately hurtful: “Excuse me, this desk is for doctors only!” “Why don’t they just go back where they came from?”. He is most likely to miss tutorials because of unfinished work, and, when he does get to one, he is the diminutive figure in the corner, too self-conscious to ask a legitimate question. He is the one you will see biting on a stale sandwich most evenings as he ploughs through piles of paperwork between braving phone calls to the registrar, irate at his inability to articulate a problem in 30 seconds. When the desperately needed interpreter is hours away, he will meekly announce his grasp of two other languages. Relief and gratitude on the part of the staff will be somehow inexplicably replaced by righteousness. “At least he can do that!” He will often wonder why his best attempts to contribute meaningfully seem antagonistic, why there is such a glaring lack of encouragement, and why he is finding this initiation harder than he had ever imagined. In a private wish list, he craves for a little more understanding and a little less hostility; then, scoffing at such imagined luxuries, he returns to face another day. Slowly, one unit then another shares the AMC burden, each one “preparing” the next, so that his perceived shortcomings always precede him. Soon he must think about the following year’s jobs. What should he do? Who knows him well enough to provide the references? Who are his role models? Should he follow the majority of his AMC peers and enrol in general practice training or should he make a concerted attempt to pursue a long-desired specialty? The obstacles seem magnified in advanced training. Even if he manages to enter a specialty program, who will supervise the children’s homework? Who in the hospital appreciates the needs of an older foreign doctor, also a son, father, husband and small business owner? The conflict between personal aspirations and life’s larger concerns routinely ravages his mind. In the course of our own training, we have been frequent witness to, and no doubt creators of, the hurdles that the medical community puts in the way of foreign medical graduates. These hurdles are not only academic, but also personal, based on our uninformed and unchallenged perception of their culture, education and work ethic. Every foreign graduate we have taught has understood the rationale for an Australian exam, but, after attaining the very standard demanded by the profession, it is the indignity of working in an unsupported and hostile environment as a second-class doctor that turns out to be the insurmountable hurdle. Although the issues surrounding foreign medical graduates are genuinely difficult and bear no glib resolutions, we suggest the following considerations. Integrate foreign medical graduates preparing for the AMC exam into hospitals by allowing them to observe educational seminars, outpatient work and grand rounds. Knowledge of local medical practice is far more accessible in this manner than by spending countless lonely hours in the library in search of assimilation. Access should not be limited to peripheral hospitals, which are often difficult to travel to and lack consistent teaching programs. Expand the educational program for foreign graduates by encouraging local physicians to teach. (With the assistance of just one other colleague, each of us spent just 2 hours a week to adequately address the exam syllabus.) It is crucial that program directors sanction such activity rather than be dismissive of its goals — a volunteer teaching program will enjoy success only if personal gain is sometimes set aside. Assign a specific mentor for foreign doctors at each institution. Such a mentor must be sensitive to the different goals and needs of foreign doctors compared with those of their local counterparts. Neither excessive pressure to conform nor total immunity from compliance with local standards should take the place of a deliberate process of integration. Practise what we preach. Medical students are taught from inception about the value of empathy and communication. We repeatedly examine their grasp of such skills, yet, once they are doctors, these skills are perceived to be an optional extra. Apply the open-ended question to foreign doctors: “Tell me how you feel.” Appreciate the worth of foreign doctors as a pillar of our increasingly cosmopolitan society. The very doctors we may deride will go on to serve entire populations, which the average Australian graduate is ill-equipped, and hence uncomfortable, to serve. The statistics on migrants, ageing populations and chronic illnesses do not bear repetition, but the overwhelming need to help our foreign doctors to help us take care of all our patients does. In medicine, the road is long for us all, but for the foreign medical graduate it is inevitably more winding and rough. It is our obligation to not abandon our colleagues along the way, but to seek to ease their journey with small, personal gestures and larger, administrative measures. While they tend our society’s sick, we must not deny them their own bruises that often lie just beneath the surface. It is only then that as physicians we can truly call ourselves healers.

Ranjana Srivastava MB BS(Hons) · Declan J Green MB BS(Hons)

General medicine Cry from the heart December 2004 Free

The Brazil Project

How can we restore some semblance of sanity to a world spinning out of control? Some years ago now, Terry Gilliam (of Monty Python fame) produced something of a screen gem, enigmatically entitled Brazil. It was set in some indeterminate period in the near future, at which we now seem to have arrived. The world of Brazil was a world out of control — a world in which the infrastructure of daily living had become so complex that it required the intervention of a quasi-supernatural being when things went wrong in the lives of its inhabitants. Played (brilliantly) by Robert de Niro, this being descends (like Superman) from nowhere to rip open the offending section of wall — behind which there pulsates an incredibly complex, almost organic, mass of wires, tubes and other assorted technological viscera — “fix” the problem and then disappear once more. While immensely grateful, the mortals whom he has thus aided are none the wiser as to how he has effected this minor miracle, which leaves them very much at his mercy the next time the system fouls up. This threat is never far off, as the more complex things are the more often they go wrong. It would be possible to run a society with such a quasi-supernatural saviour at hand, assuming, of course, that some terrible mishap does not befall your hero. The gamut of potential mishaps must be extensive: kryptonite, alien forces, death rays, evil geniuses, or even the appearance of a Bizarro-quasi-supernatural being. But, in Brazil, hero de Niro did not succumb to any of these. He succumbed to paper. Yes, you heard me: paper. One day, he is walking along a road when a wind springs up. A piece of paper blows up against his leg, then blows away. Then a second, then a third — before a veritable barrage. Some of these papers are whisked away, while others adhere to his flailing limbs as he struggles to free himself. Soon he is trapped, struggling to breathe in this swirling, smothering maelstrom. But the onslaught of the paper is relentless, torrential, unforgiving. Soon, his struggles falter, and he drops to his knees. We sense that he has lost the battle. His struggling figure wanes, the paper begins to disperse, and soon there’s nothing left where de Niro once stood. He has been utterly subsumed — drowned and obliterated — by paper. Any of this sound familiar to you? It should. Simply substitute “computerisation” for “complex infrastructure” and “red tape” for “paper”. But what is red tape? Red tape consists of the requirements of a complex bureaucracy. How is it manifest? As documentation. Why is it seen as necessary? In order to prove that we are doing what we say we are doing. But to whom are we demonstrating this proof? Ultimately, to a bunch of lawyers, whether they are the hired guns of a litigious patient or the hired “suits” of a government department. Our society is drowning. It is on the verge of being utterly subsumed by the complexity of its own systems. Anyone who doesn’t realise this is ready for a wake-up call. This is that call! Litigation was originally put in place to protect the rights of the individual, but it now oppresses the very people it was sent to protect! Every day around the world, billions of ordinary citizens — from doctors to nurses to accountants to engineers to shopkeepers to craftsmen to fishermen to you-name-it — spend a substantial part of every hour devoting themselves to the documentation of their job as opposed to its execution. And with every year that passes, the level of documentation becomes more exacting, more oppressive, more intrusive, less conducive to the effective management of the job and, perhaps most damaging of all, insidiously undermining of trust. Everybody out there is hurting. A patient of mine who runs a small woodwork workshop for children (in which no child has ever been injured) told me that he now finds himself paying out $15 000 a year in insurance to an insurer he had to hunt for interstate. A well-known fishing identity from Sorrento, near Melbourne, speaking on a local radio station, said that he spends half his working day on dry land filling out government forms. Another of my patients, a family accountant, has to drop all of her loyal, regular, small clients because the documentation requirements of even the simplest transaction have placed the cost of her accounting services out of reach of these people — the very people for whom she set up her business in the first place. On a macro scale, in my opinion, the productivity of modern society has been virtually halved by the requirements of documentation (while the consumption of paper has sextupled). The situation is no longer sustainable. As a society, we can no longer afford the luxury of mistrust. Yes, it’s nice to have the right to sue, but the other side of that coin is that each of us must expend half of our working lives in efforts to prevent others from suing us. Ironically, the exponential rise in documentation that was supposed to protect us from such litigation has failed miserably. We are being sued more than ever before. At a recent risk management seminar I learnt that the United States experience of capping damages is that it doesn’t work and that lawyers simply launched more actions so as to bring their total income back to what it was before the capping. We need to create legal systems that virtually exclude lawyers entirely (eg, the New Zealand system of compensation for medical mishap), and we need to limit their numbers quite sharply — as it seems to me that each lawyer will fill the litigious airspace available to him or her. And, we need to become aware of the price we pay for each so-called “right” we claim. Moreover, we need to trust one another more. The world is spinning out of control, and nobody is yelling: “Stop!” “The Brazil Project” is about doing just that. It is about bringing these issues into the public eye in a balanced fashion, without compartmentalising them to the point of meaninglessness. It is about calling a moratorium on worthless documentation — ie, any documentation that is not essential to the actual running of a particular enterprise. It is about loosening the stranglehold of lawyers, whom we ourselves have aided and abetted with our actions. It is about recognising that there is another way of conducting our society — a way based on trust rather than adversarial acquisitiveness. My intention is to make The Brazil Project a functioning reality — not an institution bound by meetings and minutes and mission statements, but a loose association of like-minded individuals whose aim it is to restore to the world some semblance of sanity. This will take time, effort, energy, faith, determination and, yes, some money. As a 70-hour-per-week medico, I can’t do it alone (although success in this venture would probably render me a 35-hour-per-week medico!). If you are interested in joining me in this endeavour, please contact me. I do not pretend to have all the answers, nor am I entirely certain of the way to proceed, but there has to be a better way, and I believe the first step in achieving a better way is a cry of protest. The more voices that join in this cry, the better it will be heard.

Ron Elisha MB BS

Ageing Christmas offerings December 2004 Free

The perils of pet ownership: a new fall-injury risk factor

Objective: To describe fall-related injuries due to pets in an older population.Design: Case series.Participants and setting: Patients aged 75 years and over presenting to the emergency department of a metropolitan hospital in northern Sydney over 18 months, with a fracture directly related to their pet.Main outcome measures: Type of fracture; circumstances of injury.Results: 16 cases (mean patient age, 81 years) are described; 13 (81%) involved women. Animals of five species were involved, with cats and dogs being the most common pet hazard.Conclusions: Pets are a potential environmental hazard in the occurrence of fall-related injuries in older people, with dogs and cats most likely to be involved. Women appear more likely than men to be injured.

Susan E Kurrle PhD, DGM · Robert Day FACEM · Ian D Cameron PhD, FAFRM(RACP)

Institutional racism in Australian healthcare: a plea for decency

To the Editor: While the article by Henry and colleagues provides food for thought and possible action,1 do they exhibit the fairness they exhort to solve the problem they perceive? There appears to be a distinct lack of logic in some of their deductions in the Box on page 517. “Body part funding” is not confined to Aboriginal health. For the 43 years I was associated with NSW Health, it was an integral part of the system and, together with its variations, increased as the years passed. The authors claim that as only $80 per head being spent on medical and pharmaceutical benefits in a remote Aboriginal community compared with the $900 spent in Double Bay is an example of racism. Surely, it is only a reflection of the lack of both a pharmacy and doctor in the remote community compared with the easy access to both in the inner-Sydney suburb. Comparison between the remote Aboriginal community and an all-white community of similar characteristics would have more validity.

Raymond S Hyslop

Institutional racism in Australian healthcare: a plea for decency

To the Editor: In their challenging article, Henry and coauthors assert that the poor health of Australian Aboriginals is the result of the “divided, divisive, racist, socially unjust society” of “this Australia”.1 I cannot agree. The health standards enjoyed by “white Australia” are not an isolated phenomenon, but rather a part of the fabric of an advanced technological society. Efforts to bring Australian Aboriginal health to the same standard without the Indigenous Australians being fully part of this 21st-century society will never be successful, even with limitless resources and endless goodwill. It is possible to maintain cultural identity and remain cognizant of past hurts while playing a full, if not leading, role in this technological society. If the Aboriginal elders were to lead their people into mainstream society they would find, I’m sure, an inclusive, tolerant, exciting and advancing society where they could play a full role, enjoy the same health as the rest of Australia, while still maintaining their unique identity.

Christopher R Strakosch

UK health inequalities: the class system is alive and well

To the Editor: The Postcard from Heller, Weller and Jamrozik1 may reflect a nostalgic and unrealistic view of how good things are back home. They suggest that, in New South Wales, the health chances of both advantaged and disadvantaged populations are improving, and, in relative terms, social inequalities in health may also be showing “some improvement”. In fact, despite impressive overall declines in mortality, there remain important differences in health status between NSW populations. Figures for the mid-1990s show that life expectancy at birth for both Aboriginal males and females is markedly less (by 20 years and 18 years, respectively). Similarly, socioeconomic disadvantage shortens life expectancy for both rural men and women (by 14 and 10 years, respectively) and urban men and women (by 10 and 7 years, respectively).2 The relative gap is also widening for some important health indices. For example, from 1980 to 2000, the percentage difference in premature death rates (< 70 years of age) between high and low socioeconomic groups has increased from 30% to 52% for men and from 24% to 32% for women, and for potentially avoidable mortality from 34% to 63% for men and from 27% to 40% for women.3 How should one respond to such inequalities? Heller et al suggest universal rather than targeted programs, as they are based on sound population health principles. To construct this as a simple choice is not helpful. Unless we recognise and address the barriers facing people in adverse social circumstances, universal programs may unintentionally widen health inequalities. For example, universal access to healthcare in the UK and Australia has not equally benefited those from the most disadvantaged circumstances compared with wealthier and better-educated populations.4 The Postcard authors suggest that Australia is saved from class divisions by the established “fair go” tradition, where shared values overcome structural inequalities in “socioeconomic status”. In fact, social class continues to be a powerful but complex and changing influence in Australia.5 It is important to acknowledge the evidence that structural inequalities are significant and worsening in Australia,6 and that the most disadvantaged experience continued social exclusion.7 We need to shift from a “trickle down” perspective that sees the greatest health gains accruing to the most advantaged — with a hope that these benefits will eventually be achieved by everyone — to a more explicit social justice perspective that ensures that resources for health are allocated in ways that produce fair outcomes. This may help address “socially entrenched self-denial of the chance for better health”.

John Furler · Elizabeth Harris · Don Nutbeam · Mark Harris

The hidden tragedy of offender deaths

The justice system could go further in supporting the needs of those it detains after they are returned to the community Nearly 20 years ago, public attention was drawn to the previously hidden tragedy of deaths in prison and police custody. Initially, attention was focused on deaths of Indigenous people. However, it quickly became apparent that the death rate for all people held in custody was much higher than that for the general population. The result was a detailed investigation into the causes of the problem, in the form of the Royal Commission into Aboriginal Deaths in Custody.1 The Royal Commission made over 300 recommendations on penal policy, cell design, custody management regimens, treatment programs, services to Indigenous offenders and a host of other topics. In addition, the Deaths in Custody Monitoring Program was established at the Australian Institute of Criminology (AIC) to scrutinise and report on deaths in prison or police custody.2 In parallel with the acknowledged problem of deaths in custody, there is an equally significant tragedy in the form of high death rates among released prisoners3-5 and offenders in the community.6,7 In the decade after the Royal Commission (1990 to 1999), the AIC monitoring program recorded 628 deaths in police or prison custody. Over the same period, in Victoria alone, 820 men and women who had been released from prison died unnatural deaths.4 The study by Coffey and colleagues in this issue of the Journal (page 473) shows that the problem is not confined to adult offenders but affects juveniles as well.8 The high rate of unnatural deaths among offenders living in the community is a major public health issue, but what can we do to reduce these rates? One of the groups at greatest risk is injecting drug users — over half of the unnatural deaths examined in the earlier Victorian study were heroin related,4 and drug-related offences were an indicator of high mortality risk in the study by Coffey et al.8 Drug treatment and maintenance (methadone) programs lower the risk of death by overdose.9 However, many of those at greatest risk are profoundly alienated from society, and we need to find ways to engage them. For example, heroin-dependent Indo-Chinese offenders frequently face rejection by their families and community, and are isolated from the mainstream community as well. Female offenders often come from backgrounds of extensive sexual and physical abuse, their heroin dependency is often supported by prostitution,5 and any interventions need to take account of their responsibilities as parents.10 Treatment and maintenance programs need to be delivered in ways that meet the material, social and cultural needs of those at risk. Overdose risk can be dramatically lowered by behaviour changes, like not using drugs by yourself, being aware of variations in the purity of heroin, and not taking heroin in conjunction with alcohol or benzodiazepines. Again, the problem is partly that those at greatest risk are also the most difficult to communicate with, and tend to be unrealistic in judging risks to themselves. Peer-based education and information dissemination programs have shown they can transmit the key messages about risk reduction to this group (eg, how to avoid overdose and recognise its signs),9 but, again, a range of approaches tailored to the needs of specific groups at risk is required. Such approaches could include maximising the effectiveness of needle and syringe program workers by having them provide standardised, evidence-based messages and materials on safe injecting, overdose prevention and support options.9 The importance of heroin as a cause of unnatural death should not obscure the other dangers that offenders face. Individuals who have the combination of mental disorder and drug and alcohol misuse experience much higher risks of both overdose and suicide and can find it difficult to obtain the kind of treatment and support services that might alleviate their problems. Older offenders are at increased risk of a variety of general health problems, such as diabetes, cancer and liver disease, and there need to be programs that link at-risk offenders with healthcare and support services.11 People who are released from custody are at greatly increased risk, in part because their tolerance for heroin is reduced, and also because return to the community can be a time of great emotional stress. Prisoner release support programs like the Victorian Bridging the Gap program have shown that the period before release can be an important “window of opportunity” when offenders are motivated to plan for their release.12 A key feature of this program is intensive, outreach-based support, with the support agency helping the releasee to identify his or her specific needs and brokering access to material support, healthcare and social services. Releasees who participated in Bridging the Gap had improved outcomes as measured by accommodation stability and engagement in drug-treatment programs, and these in turn translated into lower rates of reoffending.12 Finally, we need to attend to an important lesson from the Royal Commission. Despite real improvements in custodial management, the number of deaths of Indigenous people in custody has continued to increase because there are now more Indigenous people in custody.2 The high rate of unnatural deaths among offenders is a public health problem that requires changes in the way that healthcare services are delivered to this vulnerable population. However, we also need to recognise that the justice system has a key role to play in ensuring that its goals of punishing offenders and preventing crime are properly balanced by a consideration of the health and support needs of the people who are the subjects of its interventions.

Stuart Ross

Testosterone prescribing in Australia

There is yet no convincing evidence that testosterone therapy is safe or effective in counteracting any effects of ageing One of the most challenging and time-consuming aspects of medical practice is discussing with patients what they have gleaned from the Internet or popular lay publications. One topic of such discussion is the use of testosterone in male ageing, with public interest fuelled by persuasive publications like Maximising manhood,1 The testosterone revolution2 and Male menopause.3 Much of the information gained from these books may seem to be very convincing, but is, at best, “ahead of the evidence”. It is often difficult for doctors not to appear old-fashioned, ignorant or downright contrary when showing scepticism or advising caution in the face of such conviction. . . . beware when entrepreneurial business ventures overtake evidence-based medicine. In this issue of the Journal, Handelsman (page 419) has documented temporal and regional trends in testosterone prescribing in Australia.4 He has shown increases in prescribing corresponding to popular promotion of androgen therapy in ageing. This rise has been particularly marked in Western Australia, coincident with the opening in that state of entrepreneurial clinics aimed at the ageing-male market. There is no doubt that testosterone therapy benefits patients with documented hypogonadism associated with conditions such as Klinefelter’s syndrome and hypopituitarism. Current prescribing guidelines allow for this, regardless of age. However, for the use of testosterone in men of middle age and older with borderline low serum levels of testosterone, the evidence for both efficacy and safety is yet to be established. The original description of the efficacy of testosterone therapy for the vicissitudes of age has been shown to be no more than a powerful placebo effect.5 Nevertheless, it would seem that those who espouse testosterone therapy in this setting have identified an expanding market. The Australian population is ageing: 28% of men are over the age of 50 and 12% over the age of 65 years. It is projected that by 2021, 4.0 million Australians will be over the age of 65, an increase of 1.7 million from today’s estimate.6 Together with a documented fall in testosterone level with age, where it is estimated that 20% of men over the age of 60 will have a testosterone level below the reference range, this predicts a large population of men as potential customers for androgen therapy.7,8 Although most studies have shown a gradual decline in testosterone level with age, the clinical consequences of this are not known. Conditions such as muscular frailty, loss of bone mass, cognitive decline and erectile dysfunction are also age related, but whether testosterone deficiency has a causal role is not clear. More importantly, it has not yet been established that testosterone therapy has any role in correcting these conditions. It has been a widely held belief that androgen deficiency is a common and correctable cause of erectile dysfunction. However, in a cohort of 1455 men presenting with erectile dysfunction, we found that testosterone deficiency constituted a correctable cause in only 3%.9 All of those who responded to testosterone therapy for erectile dysfunction had a testosterone level < 7 nmol/L, well below the reference range of 11–37 nmol/L. The use of testosterone therapy in patients with normal or slightly depressed androgen levels seems to be of little benefit.10 A similar finding has been documented in the response of bone density to testosterone therapy. The largest and longest-term study in this setting examined testosterone treatment in 108 men aged over 65 years with a baseline testosterone level more than 1 standard deviation below the young adult mean (ie, < 16.5 nmol/L).11 Lumbar spine bone density rose significantly only in those with a baseline testosterone level below the reference range (ie, below 10 nmol/L). Another, smaller study has shown a significant increase in lumbar spine density with androgen therapy in men with a baseline testosterone level < 12.1 nmol/L.12 Muscle mass and strength decrease with age, and it is tempting to link this with the decline of testosterone. In hypogonadal men, testosterone therapy improves muscle strength. In men aged over 65 years, testosterone treatment leads to a fall in fat mass and a rise in lean body mass, together with a perception of increased strength. However, although a perception of improved muscle function was reported, no objective change in measured physical function, such as walking or stair climbing, knee flexion or in muscle strength as measured by dynamometer, was demonstrated.13,14 The safety of sex hormone therapy in menopausal women, used widely for the last 60 years, has recently been scrutinised and reassessed.15 Knowledge about the safety of sex hormone replacement in men is, by contrast, in its infancy. No studies have been conducted for long enough to identify the long term risks of androgen therapy in ageing. Because of lack of statistical power in studies, it is not known whether testosterone use will increase the incidence of androgen-dependent disease such as prostate cancer, although a sustained rise in prostate-specific antigen level has been observed.13 Two other side-effects of testosterone treatment have been identified in short term studies, namely an increase in obstructive sleep apnoea and increased haematocrit and polycythaemia, both of which may have implications for cardiovascular risk.13,16 Handelsman has documented the effect on testosterone prescribing of entrepreneurial clinics aimed at the ageing-male market.4 Daily, we see advertisements for similar commercial enterprises which deal in unregistered and/or unproven prescribing, including DHEA (dehydroepiandrosterone) or testosterone to men and women, progesterone cream, and lozenges of variable mixes of oestrogens, progestins and androgens. We should beware when entrepreneurial business ventures overtake evidence-based medicine. What is needed now regarding testosterone therapy in ageing are large, long-term, prospective, randomised, placebo-controlled studies to establish if there is, indeed, benefit for specific symptoms and to identify potential risks.17

Bronwyn GA Stuckey BA, FRACP

Mental health Supplement October 2004 Open Access

"How much more can we lose?": carer and family perspectives on living with a person with depression

Objective: To explore the experiences of carers and families of people with depression.Design and setting: Structured focus groups conducted in six Australian capital cities between February 2002 and July 2002. Thematic analyses were conducted using the QSR NUD*IST software package for qualitative data.Participants: Thirty-seven carers or family members.Results: Thematic analyses highlighted five key themes. Most notably, the carer’s role is made more difficult by the lack of community awareness about depression, and, in some instances, an unwillingness of other family and friends to provide ongoing support. Carers experience a resulting sense of isolation, often exacerbated by adverse experiences with healthcare providers. Carers and family members are frequently excluded when key decisions are made, and report that emergency services are relatively unresponsive to their concerns. By contrast, community support organisations usually provided a sense of inclusion and common purpose.Conclusions: The experiences of carers and families of people with depression highlight the urgent need for more extensive community education about the illness and more productive collaboration within the healthcare system.

Nicole J Highet DPsych · Bernard G McNair GradDip(Nursing Management) · Tracey A Davenport BA(Hons), GCM · Ian B Hickie MD, FRANZCP

Mental health Supplement October 2004 Open Access

Experience with treatment services for people with bipolar disorder

Objective: To describe the experiences of people with bipolar disorder with primary care and specialist mental health services.Design and setting: Focus groups and indepth interviews were conducted in seven Australian capital cities between July 2002 and April 2003. Thematic analyses were conducted using the QSR NUD*IST software package for qualitative data.Participants: Forty-nine people with bipolar disorder participated in the focus groups and four participated in the interviews.Results: Thematic analyses highlighted eight key themes. Most notably, respondents identified a lack of awareness and understanding about bipolar disorder within the Australian community, which contributed to apparent delays in seeking medical assessment. The burden of illness was exacerbated by difficulties experienced with obtaining an accurate diagnosis and optimal treatment. The healthcare system responses were described as inadequate and included inappropriate crisis management, difficulties accessing hospital care, inappropriate exclusion of carers and families from management decisions, and frequent discontinuities of medical and psychological care.Conclusions: People with extensive experience of bipolar disorder report barriers to optimal care because of lack of community understanding and healthcare system shortcomings. These barriers exacerbate the social, interpersonal and economic costs of this illness.

Nicole J Highet DPsych · Bernard G McNair GradDip(Nursing Management) · Marie Thompson BSc(Hons) · Tracey A Davenport BA(Hons), GCM · Ian B Hickie MD, FRANZCP

Unexpected infant death: lessons from the Sally Clark case

John M N Hilton Associate Professor, Department of Pathology, University of Sydney; and Consultant in Forensic Medicine, PO Box 45, Katoomba, NSW 2780. kornhilATiinet.net.au To the Editor: Byard’s succinct dissertation on the Clark case1 omits one crucial aspect in redressing this miscarriage of justice. Without the vigorous and persistent efforts of a vocal and well directed support group, which included Mrs Clark’s legal team, their scientific and medical advisors, the Law Society of England, and her family, she would still be serving a life sentence in jail. An Australian example of the effectiveness of such a support group in combating injustice is afforded by the Lindy Chamberlain case.2 Historically, Sir Arthur Conan Doyle spearheaded the efforts — sustained over nearly 20 years — to exonerate Oscar Slater,3 an unfortunate German–Jewish immigrant to Glasgow who was condemned to death after a conviction for murder based largely on identification evidence given by one of the probable perpetrators. Slater was granted a reprieve from the death sentence at the last moment, only to serve some 17 years in a grim Scottish penitentiary. Less fortunate was Timothy Evans,4 who was convicted and hanged for murdering his wife and daughter on the evidence of one of London’s infamous mass murderers, John Christie. Evans was eventually pardoned — unfortunately, too late to save his life — largely thanks to a very active support group headed by the journalist Ludovic Kennedy. In contrast, those who lack such a support group are exemplified by Ziggy Pohl,5 who was convicted, despite rather than because of the evidence, of killing his wife in Queanbeyan, NSW. He served more than a decade in prison, only to have the true perpetrator confess after Pohl was released on parole. Byard highlights evidentiary shortcomings in one recent English case. How many other people have suffered the ignominy, distress and dire consequences of unjust convictions because they lacked the support of an individual or a group prepared to question the propriety of the conviction process?

John M N Hilton

Ageing Editorials August 2004 Free

Cardiac surgery in octogenarians and beyond

Should we do it, is it worthwhile, and who should decide? In the Western world, the number of people living beyond 80 years is increasing. In the United States, it is expected that 43% of the population will reach the age of 80.1 In Australia, men and women who reach 80 years may expect a further 7 and 10 years of life, respectively, the majority being disability free.2 Cardiac surgery in Australia has entered its fifth decade, and is now commonly performed (18 000 cases/year). The total cost (including salaries, equipment, building depreciation, etc) of having coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG) (which constitutes 75% of all cardiac surgery) at Western Australian teaching hospitals is about $12 000 per case (WA Department of Health, 1994, unpublished data). Over the past decade, the proportion of cardiac surgery patients aged 80 years or more has risen from negligible to 7% in selected centres.2-4 Surgical outcomes are encouraging: a 2002–03 report from six Victorian public hospitals revealed mortality rates of 2%–4% for elective CABG and 10%–12% for aortic valve replacement.4 However, follow-up assessment by direct patient contact has not been universal — commonly, outcome analyses rely solely on physicians’ perceptions.2 In a series of 64 octogenarians having cardiac surgery over a 5-year period at three Australian hospitals, our research group prospectively assessed outcomes and directly spoke to patients at several time intervals.2 The need for surgery was compelling — all had class III/IV symptoms of angina and/or dyspnoea. The total in-hospital mortality was 6.3% (nil in those having elective surgery and 10.5% in those requiring urgent surgery). The incidence of significant complications was low (perioperative myocardial infarction, 1.6%; stroke, 1.6%). At a mean follow-up time of 2.8 years, 44 patients were still alive, 42 (95%) were free of cardiovascular symptoms, and 42 remained independent, with a significantly improved quality of life. Kaplan–Meier actuarial survival for hospital survivors at 4 years was 74%. Interestingly, 8 patients (18%) had remarried and 8 had commenced on sildenafil. Not surprisingly, 43 (98%) of the patients said they would recommend cardiac surgery. Despite these favourable outcomes, one in five of the study participants had been originally advised by their general practitioner and/or physician not to proceed with surgery because of their age. Discrimination based on age alone is not uncommon.1,5 Performing surgery in these octogenarians was on a needs basis — other patients on waiting lists were not disadvantaged. If people over a certain age are to be barred access to healthcare, it is for society to debate and for governments to legislate. In Australia, Katrina Bramstedt (a bioethicist at the Department of Community Medicine and General Practice, Monash University) has cogently argued that age discrimination is common. Yet there is no ethical justification for denying cardiac surgery to octogenarians,5,6 particularly as empirical evidence validates the potential benefit of this treatment.5 It has been stated that “survival is not the most important outcome in the elderly”.7 Not so. Of the 102 patients on whom we have now operated, all wished to continue to live independently. So what have we learnt? Firstly, that surgery can be safely performed in octogenarians. The best people to make the decision whether to operate are the surgeon and the cardiologist, working in conjunction with one another. Secondly, that the success of surgery is critically dependent on the quality of anaesthesia and postoperative intensive care. There must be ongoing clinical governance so that expected outcomes match actual results.8 Not only are more and more octogenarians choosing to have cardiac surgery, but the chances of a good outcome are improving. Advances in surgical techniques in recent years mean that the risks of cardiac surgery, for all patients but especially those over 80 years, have been substantially reduced. The availability of “off-pump” technology (ie, doing coronary artery anastomoses without the use of cardiopulmonary bypass [CPB]), including mechanical aortocoronary anastomotic devices, allows CABG to be done not only without CPB, but also without manipulating the aorta, thus reducing atheroembolic risk.9 Furthermore, the duration of CPB and global myocardial ischaemia can be minimised by combining off-pump techniques with CPB (eg, valve replacement with CABG). Also, selective use of ventricular fibrillation (rather than cardioplegic arrest) when repairing a mitral valve avoids global myocardial ischaemia. Surgeons have several options for the technical performance of these operations. While there may be no surgical consensus on the optimal technique for a given patient, in my view a “one shoe fits all” surgical approach may prove hazardous. It is important to prepare the patient optimally before surgery. This includes universal carotid screening and judicious use of prophylactic carotid endarterectomy, together with preoperative optimisation of renal function and maintenance of perioperative enforced diuresis.10 Although none of these innovations has been tested in randomised controlled trials, myocardial, cerebrovascular and renal complication rates are now low. A critical factor determining surgical outcomes is whether the patient is in need of urgent surgery (ie, surgery required as a hospital inpatient because the patient cannot be satisfactorily stabilised with medical treatment).2-4 Delays in referring symptomatic patients are invariably associated with rapid clinical deterioration and poor results. The role of percutaneous coronary intervention (PCI) versus surgery for coronary artery disease requires comment. Neither surgery nor PCI is benign.11 For comparable patients of any age in experienced hands, the risks of inducing death, myocardial infarction, stroke or neurocognitive deficits are the same with either approach.12,13 With surgery, the failure rate is lower and there is less need for repeat interventions. However, surgery requires a sternotomy and graft harvest incisions on the leg. A number of clinical factors are associated with increased risk of PCI failure (eg, left main coronary artery or multivessel disease, diabetes).14 Before PCI is undertaken, it is essential that the cardiologist and the surgeon carefully assess which procedure is optimal for a particular patient. If PCI fails, performing emergency surgery (ie, within 24 hours of hospital admission) is associated with markedly increased risks, particularly in octogenarians. Which octogenarians should be offered cardiac surgery? Many, if not the majority, should be readily identifiable as unsuitable because of advanced comorbidities. However, the 20% of patients in our series who were advised not to proceed with surgery had no clear features distinguishing them from the 80% advised to proceed. It is impossible to provide unambiguous criteria for refusing surgery. Nor am I suggesting that all octogenarians be offered this treatment. What I am advocating is that age alone must not be a barrier to accessing cardiac surgery. We can be heartened that careful evaluation allows us to pick the right patients and that these patients are achieving acceptable outcomes. Patients should be offered a choice. Those who have had cardiac surgery believe it is worthwhile and are very grateful.2

John MP Alvarez FRACS

Environmental health Postcard from the UK August 2004 Free

UK health inequalities: the class system is alive and well

The NHS was founded on the principle of access to adequate healthcare for all Roman society in Britain was highly classified. At the top were . . . the legions, the provincial administration, the government of towns and the wealthy traders and commercial classes who enjoyed legal privileges not generally accorded to the majority of the population. In 212 AD, the Emperor Caracalla extended citizenship to all free-born inhabitants of the empire, but social and legal distinctions remained rigidly set between the upper rank of citizens known as honestiores and the masses, known as humiliores. At the lowest end of the scale were the slaves . . .1 In the United Kingdom today, the widening gap between upper and lower “social classes” is regularly presented by politicians and health bureaucrats to professional and lay audiences alike, and used to justify the public health agenda. Health inequalities have become the driving force for public health initiatives. The government under Thatcher explored “variations” in health outcomes and in health service provision. Subsequently, the Blair government replaced “variations” with the more class-oriented “inequalities”. All too often, however, attempts to deal with the real and frequently demonstrated social gradient in disease and in health service provision is limited to “hand-wringing epidemiology”. In any case, discussion of a widening gap reflects a failure to understand the difference between relative and absolute risk, as well as demographic change and the type of outcomes amenable to prevention. . . . unless public health programs are based on sound theoretical bases, they will fail. The debate in Australia is rather more sophisticated: for example, in the report of the Chief Health Officer of New South Wales,2 trends over time in the social gradient are presented in terms of absolute risk, as well as for diseases in which social interventions are likely to be effective. Presented in this way, the social gradient persists, but does not necessarily appear to widen over time, and some improvement in the experience of the least affluent may also be apparent. Are we carping and nit-picking to criticise the UK approach? No, because unless public health programs are based on sound theoretical bases they will fail. Implausible and non-achievable targets aimed at “narrowing the gap” have been established. These include: reducing, by 10%, the difference in infant mortality between the children of manual workers and the whole population; and reducing, by 10%, the gap in life expectancy at birth between the quintile of local council areas with the lowest life expectancy and the whole population. Far better would be to aim at the more important goal of improving the health of the whole community, as well as the disadvantaged part. The NHS was founded on the principle of access to adequate healthcare for all. Selectivity, even well intentioned selectivity, not only flies in the face of this ideal, it ignores the late Geoffrey Rose’s astute observation3 that small changes in the average for the whole population can bring great benefits to those at greatest risk, provided the change involves the whole population. People in the UK still talk about, and measure, social class. Although the use of the term “socioeconomic status” may be an example of political correctness, the fact that “class” is still an acceptable form of scientific terminology in the UK reflects the underlying acceptance of its existence. People typically “know their place”. They measure themselves against a social standard. Those who are “working class” stoutly defend their place in the social hierarchy and are proud of it. Expectations of health and of access to healthcare are firmly rooted in the class system. It is “posh” to eat healthy food, and “posh” is a derogatory term. If men (and women) are born into such shackles of social convention, their freedom to improve their health is distinctly limited. The claim that Australian society is classless is oft made but open to challenge. The concept of social class, as developed by Weber and Marx, is a complex one that involves consciousness of social position and sharing of values and outlooks within the group. If Australia has social classes, they are probably blue collar, white collar, “squattocracy” and those on the dole, but ranged against this are the acknowledged rights of all to “have a go” and to “a fair go”. These maxims make attempts to improve everyone’s health possible, as well as socially and politically legitimate. Why should we care if socially entrenched self-denial of the chance for better health exists in the UK? The reason is that attempts to deal with health inequalities are doomed to failure in such a climate. The debate about equity and health is complex and wide-ranging, and has an international component — all countries have inequality and inequity. The ancient Romans introduced a rigid social class structure into Britain, but the current inhabitants of the British Isles have made its perpetuation an art form.

Richard F Heller MD, FRCP, FRACP, FAFPHM · David P Weller MPH, PhD, FRACGP, FAFPHM · Konrad Jamrozik DPhil, FAFPHM, MFPH

Child health Letters August 2004 Free

Temporary protection visas and child refugees

Christine B Phillips,* Suzanne Manning† * Senior Lecturer, Academic Unit of General Practice and Community Health, Australian National University Medical School, PO Box 254, Jamison Centre, Jamison, ACT 2614; † Intern, Department of Psychology, Australian National University, Acton, ACT. christine.phillipsATcalvary-act.com.au To the Editor: Since 1999, most asylum seekers in Australia who have been detained and subsequently found to be genuine refugees have been issued temporary protection visas (TPVs). Missing from much of the debate about management of asylum seekers has been the impact of the provisions of TPVs on children. A comparison of the entitlements of refugees on permanent and temporary protection visas is given in Box 1. To estimate the proportion of TPVs issued to children under 18 years of age, we analysed data provided by the Department of Immigration and Multicultural and Indigenous Affairs (DIMIA). The denominator population was drawn from data on numbers of temporary and permanent protection visas issued between June 1999 and June 2002.1,2 Numerator data were drawn from information provided by DIMIA on request.3 As shown in Box 2, we found that between October 1999 and June 2002, 23% of all TPVs were issued to children under the age of 18. Some of these children are now over 18 years of age. However, as children born to TPV holders in Australia are also given TPV status, more children will be recruited into this visa category. Australia is a signatory to the UN Convention on the Rights of the Child, which enshrines key rights for children, such as the right to health and safety.4 However, we believe that several of these basic rights are undermined by the lack of provisions afforded to TPV holders: they are prohibited from sponsoring family members, and they have limited access to settlement services for refugees (Box 1). Withholding of family reunion provisions increases the risks for children, as it makes it more likely that parents will take their children with them when they undertake hazardous travel to seek asylum. This is in contrast to the traditional model of families sending an index person, who then sponsors other family members. The lack of a comprehensive settlement package for TPV holders, and the temporary and indeterminate nature of the visas, is likely to compound the psychological distress experienced by both adult and child refugees. Children who have experienced ongoing adversity are vulnerable to developing psychological disorders.5 The children of TPV holders must also live in families where the parents bear an ongoing burden of fear and destabilisation. The effects of TPVs are borne by large numbers of children. There is a need for concerted advocacy by health professionals to ensure that the health consequences of TPVs for children are recognised and addressed. Addendum 13/07/04. While a recent federal government initiative will allow current Temporary Protection Visa holders to apply for permanent Australian residency, we urge ongoing review of refugee visas. 1 Comparison of entitlements of refugees on permanent and temporary protection visas Services funded by the Australian Government Refugees with permanent visas Refugees with temporary protection visas Settlement services Translating and interpreting service Eligible Not eligible Accommodation support Eligible Not eligible Assistance from Migrant Resource Centre Eligible Not eligible Early health and intervention service Eligible Eligible Torture and trauma counselling Eligible Eligible English language tuition Free tuition for adults and children Adults not eligible. Children eligible from July 2002 Family reunion May apply to sponsor family members Not eligible Employment Access to all assistance programs Not eligible except for most basic services Income support Eligible for full range of social security benefits Restricted entitlements Medicare Eligible Eligible Education Primary and secondary education Eligible Eligible Tertiary education Eligible for HECS Must pay upfront fees Travel Right of return if holder travels overseas No right of return if holder leaves country HECS = Higher Education Contribution Scheme. 2 Proportion of temporary protection visa (TPV) holders who were children when visa was granted (1999–2002) Years* No. of TPVs granted No. (%) < 18 years when TPV granted 1999–2000 871 108 (12.4%) 2000–01 4456 907 (20.3%) 2001–02 3196 952 (29.8%) Total 8523 1967 (23.1%) * Financial years.

Christine B Phillips · Suzanne Manning

Privacy: bad for your health?

Gaston R B Arnolda Honorary Associate, Department of Public Health, University of Sydney, QEII Institute for Mothers and Babies, Building DO2, Sydney, NSW 2006. garnoldaATperinatal.usyd.edu.au To the Editor: O’Grady and Noland, concerned about the consequences of privacy legislation,1 draw attention to “. . . the findings of an Australian survey in which 61% of adults believe that even their de-identified health information should not be used for research purposes without their consent”. Unfortunately, they do not point out that the survey,2 commissioned by the Office of the Federal Privacy Commissioner, had a 20% response rate, making it effectively useless in determining what Australian adults really think about the use of their de-identified health information. Alarmed at the possibility that “evidence” of this quality could be used to aid decision-making that had important implications for rigorous research, I turned to Google (<www.google.com>) for assistance. A Google search using the words “61% de-identified health information roy morgan” generated 21 hits, 15 of them unique, and only five related to the subject. One of the five was the letter by O’Grady and Noland, one was the report of the survey, and three specifically cited this survey result: Privacy Victoria,3 Privacy NSW,4 and the Office of the Federal Privacy Commissioner5 all used the result in formal submissions to reviews of privacy-related issues — without revealing the survey’s appalling response rate. We have privacy commissioners who are powerful advocates of the principles of respect for privacy and autonomy. Perhaps the time has come for Australia to have “public interest commissioners” who can powerfully advocate for the public interest in high-quality health research.

Gaston R B Arnolda

Privacy: bad for your health?

Gary C Morgan Executive Chairman, Roy Morgan Research Pty Ltd, PO Box 2282U, Melbourne, VIC 3001. Gary. MorganATroymorgan.com In reply: In a world in which people are increasingly busy and mobile, increasingly concerned about invasions of privacy and increasingly approached to participate in surveys, survey response rates that could be readily achieved 25 years ago are now very much more difficult to attain. High response rates (ie, 60% and over) are still very desirable and can still be achieved. We have conducted surveys on sensitive issues, such as drug-taking, and achieved response rates that would probably satisfy even Arnolda. But this requires very intensive field activity that is not always justified by the nature of the project. The survey in question was not a health survey. It set out to provide general background information, exploring comparative levels of concern about, and the relationships between, a very wide range of privacy issues on a scale adequate to allow relatively small groups within the population to be examined. It was not intended to yield precise and critical measurements. Measures of “concern” or “reluctance” are highly context-dependent, “soft” measures, subject to interpretation, both by the respondents and by end-users. External validity is therefore not the issue: a response rate of 80% would not have made the figures demonstrably more “accurate”. Given the imprecise nature of the measures obtained, overengineering the sample relative to other components of the survey design would have been a waste of (public) money, better devoted to further research. The survey was part of a wider-ranging project and was planned in close consultation with the Office of the Privacy Commissioner in the light of their needs and priorities. It is appropriate that this issue arose out of a debate on privacy. As privacy constraints bite harder, whether imposed by statute or codes of practice, or arising through increasing resistance from subjects, medical researchers are going to have to come to terms with problems of non-response in the same way that social-survey researchers have. How are researchers going to react when only 20% of potential subjects consent to have their information used? Will they use words like “appalling” and “effectively useless” to dismiss any studies based on such a subset? Or will they perhaps learn to use them, with due caution, for the valuable information they nevertheless contain? One does not have to look very far in the history of medicine or public health to find major advances in knowledge using less than perfect statistics.

Gary C Morgan

Cancer Medicine and the Community – 90th anniversary July 2004 Free

Changes in beliefs about cancer in Western Australia, 1964–2001

Objective: To assess changes in people’s knowledge and beliefs about cancer between 1964 and 2001.Design: Questions in a 1964 survey of beliefs about cancer (randomly selected households) were replicated in a 2001 telephone survey (random-digit dialling).Setting: Perth, Western Australia.Participants: 984 and 491 participants aged 20 years or older in the 1964 and 2001 surveys, respectively (response rates, 86.8% and 47.0%).Main outcome measures: Changes in knowledge and beliefs about cancer.Results: Between 1964 and 2001, there were major improvements in knowledge about the causes of cancer, with several myths dispelled. In 1964, the proportion of Perth residents surveyed who believed that cancer is contagious was 20% (95% CI, 18%–22%), compared with 3% (95% CI, 2%–4%) in 2001. Similarly, the proportion who believed cancer is caused by “a knock” was 25% (95% CI, 22%–28%) in 1964, compared with 1% (95% CI, 0–2%) in 2001. Cancer screening participation rates also greatly improved, from 18% (95% CI, 16%–20%) in 1964 to 77% (95% CI, 73%–81%) in 2001. Changes in participants’ sources of knowledge about cancer were also evident, with family members and television increasing markedly as sources of information.Conclusions: Improved education of the public in health matters over the past four decades appears to have had a major and positive impact on knowledge about cancer.

Robert J Donovan BPsych(Hons), PhD · Owen B J Carter BPsych, DPsych · Geoffrey Jalleh BComm, MPH · Sandra C Jones BA, MPH, PhD

Complementary therapies Complementary and alternative medicine June 2004 Free

CAM practitioners and “regular” doctors: is integration possible?

Integrated clinics have already been established in response to community demand. The growing evidence base for complementary and alternative medicine (CAM) and its widespread community use compels doctors to understand complementary therapies and to refer patients to CAM practitioners where appropriate. Most general practitioners have patients with chronic illness who could benefit from the services of CAM practitioners, and virtually all CAM practitioners have patients who require access to mainstream diagnosis and therapy. Collaboration requires shared respect and trust, and education. Dangers of not integrating care include delaying or depriving patients of safe and effective management, and the potential for harmful interactions. Integration is currently being supported by government initiatives such as the new MedicarePlus package, as well as by initiatives from organisations such as the Australian Medical Association, the Royal Australian College of General Practitioners and the Australasian Integrative Medicine Association.

Marc M Cohen MB BS(Hons), PhD, BMedSc(Hons)

Patient attitudes to donation of embryos for research in Western Australia

Objective: To ascertain patients’ attitudes to embryo donation for research purposes.Design: Anonymous questionnaire survey.Participants and setting: 235 couples who had embryos in storage at Concept Fertility Centre on 30 March 2003 that had been cryopreserved between 1 January 2000 and 30 June 2002.Main outcome measures: Participants’ choices with regard to donating embryos to another couple, to research to improve in-vitro fertilisation (IVF) techniques or to stem-cell research, and the likelihood of couples choosing to use a range of sources to help them with their decision.Results: The response rate was 57%. Twenty-nine per cent of respondents (36/126) reported they would donate their embryos to research that would improve IVF techniques and 27% (34/126) reported they would donate their embryos to stem-cell research. Fifteen per cent (19/126) would donate their embryos to another infertile couple. Willingness to donate to research was not influenced by whether the couple had previous children, or age. Women and men with moderate to strong religious beliefs were less likely to donate to research. Over 90% of respondents indicated they would seek outside help to decide the fate of their embryos.Conclusion: This study suggests that about 30% of couples would donate their embryos to research, and highlights the need to provide support and information to help couples through their decision-making process.

Peter J Burton PGDip(Sci), PhD · Katherine Sanders BSc(Hons), PhD

Complementary therapies Complementary and alternative medicine June 2004 Free

The rise and rise of complementary and alternative medicine: a sociological perspective

Major reasons for the growth in the use of complementary and alternative medicine (CAM), in Australia and elsewhere, are general societal changes rather than specific reasons internal to medicine. There are problems of definition of CAM, as well as the extent to which CAM modalities can be considered a unified paradigm. The general changes examined include the consumer and green movements, as well as postmodernism. The movement surrounding evidence-based healthcare may provide some answers, but will not settle the issue of compatibility. CAM is here to stay and will continue to present challenges for conventional medicine on how to respond.

Ian D Coulter PhD · Evan M Willis PhD

Health services administration Indigenous health May 2004 Free

Institutional racism in Australian healthcare: a plea for decency

Fairness and compassion are the bases for improving Aboriginal health There is no dispute that Aboriginal health in Australia is both poor and very much worse than that of non-Aboriginal people, and their life expectancy at birth is about 21 years less for men and 19 years less for women. Among Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander males, 6.8% die in infancy, compared with 1% for the rest of the population. For females the figures are 6.7% and 0.8%. A large array of diseases are much more prevalent among Aborigines.1 Institutional racism in Australian healthcare — some examples Funding inequity: Overall funding of Aboriginal healthcare is not commensurate with extra need.8 Different performance criteria for black and white: For example, in Perth, Derbarl Yerrigan Aboriginal Medical Service funding was cut when an “overspend” arose because of success in attracting clients; at the same time the teaching hospitals’ overspend was 120 times as great as that at Derbarl Yerrigan. The teaching hospitals were given an extra $100 million to cover their overspend.9 “Body part” funding: For instance, separate streams of money for conditions such as diabetes and heart disease for a health service which is intended to be holistic — 26 funding streams (and hence 26 separate accounts and 26 demands for accountability) for the Danila Dilba Aboriginal Medical Service in Darwin. Differences in treatment regimens: Aboriginal people in Western Australia born in the 1940s received low-cost nursing care; in contrast, a white cohort of the same age received higher-cost technological care.10 Inequitable Medicare Primary Health Care (Medicare Benefits Schedule plus Pharmaceutical Benefits Scheme): In Katjungka (a remote Aboriginal community), $80 per head per year; in Double Bay (an affluent Sydney suburb), $900 per head per year.11 Cultural barriers to Aboriginal use of healthcare services: Inadequate funding to reduce these barriers (such as language barrier and lack of recognition of different constructs of health) for Aboriginal people. This is not news. The question is how to improve this situation. The argument presented in this article rests on two core and related ideas: that our health services are “institutionally racist” and that such racism stems from Australia being, or at least having become, an uncaring society. The way forward that we propose is recognising and addressing institutional racism. This would provide a framework for improving Aboriginal health. We believe, however, that acceptance of the need to address such racism can only come about through building a more compassionate and decent society. To suggest that healthcare in Australia is institutionally racist may be confronting for some, but we argue not only that it is institutionally racist, but, more importantly, that such racism represents one of the greatest barriers to improving the health of Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people. We will also indicate what might be done to overcome this institutional racism and improve Aboriginal health. Defining institutional racismInstitutional racism “refers to the ways in which racist beliefs or values have been built into the operations of social institutions in such a way as to discriminate against, control and oppress various minority groups”.2 It has been claimed that “Institutional racism is embedded in Australian institutions”.3 Often, institutional racism is covert or even unrecognised by the agents involved in it. In recent years, interest in both the concept and practice of institutional racism has increased. In the United Kingdom, it was sparked by the Stephen Lawrence Inquiry,4 published in 1999. This examined the events which followed the completely unprovoked murder in 1993 of Stephen Lawrence, a young black man, which was “unequivocally motivated by racism”. It found that the investigation was marred by a combination of professional incompetence, institutional racism and a failure of leadership by senior officers. It claimed that “officers approached the murder of a black man less energetically than if the victim had been white and the murderers black”. In the context of racial and ethnic disparities, Camara Jones,5 an Assistant Professor at Harvard University School of Public Health, has called for “a growing national conversation on racism”, one key aspect of which is “institutionalized racism”. This she sees as being “often evident as inaction in the face of need”. An increasing focus on institutional racism in Aotearoa (New Zealand) was prompted by a visit there by Camara Jones in 1999.6 In Australia, institutional racism has been an almost constant feature of our history, from the British designation of the continent as terra nullius, through the 1897 Convention on Federation (where the question of whether Aboriginal people should be counted as “people” in the national census was covered in just 195 words7), to the stolen generations and the failure of the federal government to issue an apology. Examples of institutional racism are shown in the Box. Clash of culturesWe believe that any healthcare system is a social institution built on the cultural stance of the population it serves. It follows that cultural values should provide the value base for health services. Between Aboriginal and non-Aboriginal Australians, there is not only a difference in culture, but a clash of cultures. We think some white people are at least dimly aware of this. However, the extent of their understanding of the difference between a culture based on individualism, where the individual ranks above the community in importance, and a communitarian culture, in which each individual is less important than the whole, is limited. One of us, S H,7 a Gungulu man, has written: “Aboriginal Peoples have built a communitarian solidarity that includes an awareness and affirmation of the [cultural] difference [of Aboriginal people]. Such communitarian solidarity is a form of civic friendship between peoples that is distinguishable from other forms of friendship because it unites people who are members of the same particularistic cultural community — persons who share a common worldview and use the same primary moral vocabulary.” Yet that value base is inadequately recognised in the planning of healthcare services in this country. Where societies or social entities have a greater awareness of and concern for mutuality, reciprocity and sharing, trust in institutions will be fostered and racism will diminish. Many Australians have embraced the individualism of neoliberalism. Uniting as a community around little other than the successes of its sporting teams, today’s white Australia lacks these “communitarian” traits. While communitarianism need not always be a force for good (the Nazi vision of the “master race” is a case in point), it can be and has been a beneficial force in Aboriginal culture. Here it is best seen in terms of what the distinguished public servant Coombs12 describes as “the Aboriginal ethic of accountability to others”. This, he writes, “is required by their commitment that autonomy, at a personal and group level, will be exercised so as to ensure that what is done contributes to the care and nurture of others with whom they are related; so that personal behaviour remains socially grounded”. In current health policy there is little attempt to recognise the differences in culture between black and white. The holism of Aboriginal health involves not just a “wholeness”, but a series of mutual obligations. Aboriginal Medical Services attempt to provide culturally “secure” services (ie, services based on Aboriginal preferences where differences in culture do not create additional barriers to use). Their poor funding levels, however, severely restrict them in this. Mainstream services make almost no effort to understand or provide culturally secure services. To deliver such services might increase primary healthcare costs for Aboriginal people by more than 50%.9,13 This is because, for example, questioning with respect to history has to be indirect, and preceded by time spent in building trust and confidence between the doctor and patient. This process, to be done well, can be time consuming. Also, advocacy on behalf of the client with other agencies, such as those providing housing, is often expected by Aboriginal clients as part of a GP’s role. The prospects for creating a cohesive Australian community, advancing social capital, furthering equity and reducing racism are not bright. For example, the Human Rights and Equal Opportunities Commission conducted a series of consultations across Australia which showed racism to be widespread and institutionally based, especially with respect to Aboriginal people.14 We believe that the current Australian federal government puts at risk our social capital in its pursuit of divisive policies. This applies not only to Aboriginal people, but also to other minority groups, defined racially or otherwise. For example, extending upfront fees for universities gives the affluent greater access compared with the poor; and ignoring the principle of universality (which did not rate a mention in the Prime Minister’s media release as one of his three pillars of Medicare15) on Medicareplus creates yet more of a two-tier healthcare system. The government’s policies on immigration have been severely criticised by many, including Father Frank Brennan, the Jesuit priest and lawyer, who concludes his book on the subject with an appeal to re-create social capital in Australia: “Many of us would like to return collectively to being a warm-hearted, decent international citizen.”16 We believe that Aboriginal people have lost their trust in the institutions of government, including healthcare services. Lack of respect by white Australians for Aboriginal values, the discounting of these values by those who have sought, patronisingly and paternalistically, to “do good” to Aboriginal people (according to a “good” defined by white fellas), leads to further erosion of trust. The lack of trust by Aboriginal people in white people and white institutions is obvious. More tellingly, we believe there is a lack of trust by Aboriginal people in themselves as a people — a lack of confidence in their culture. It is this last, a legacy of colonisation and its aftermath, that has wreaked the greatest havoc of all. We also believe that there is a lack of political will and of leadership to deal with inequalities generally in Australian healthcare. The most glaring example in recent times lies in the government’s schemes to promote private health insurance. The cost of increasing spending on primary healthcare for Aboriginal people to a level which would take into account such considerations as greater health problems, cultural-access barriers and equity (ie, increasing it to five times the per-capita level for non-Aboriginal people17) might be measured by the benefit forgone if the government were to halve the rebate (from 30% to 15%) for private health insurance.18 Progressing from institutional racismCurrently, cultural differences and ignorance create racism, and indifference nurtures it. Cultural differences must be celebrated, rather than denigrated. Former Prime Minister Paul Keating’s Redfern Speech on reconciliation pointed the way forward: “I think what we need to do is open our hearts a bit. All of us. Perhaps when we recognise what we have in common we will see the things which must be done . . . If we open one door others will follow.”19 That was 12 years ago. Today, the converse is true. As we have closed one door, others have followed. So many doors on social justice are closing in this society. We closed the door on a Norwegian freighter carrying abandoned refugees. We close the door on children in detention centres, on poor youngsters trying to get a university place. We close the door on opportunities for Aboriginal people and on the richness of an ancient culture which is potentially there for all Australians to learn from and take pride in. What scope is there for building compassion? Not much, it might seem, in this neoliberal society and this globalising world. Yet, as the social commentator Richard Titmuss remarked 30 years ago about the UK National Health Service, altruism and compassionate acts are infectious not only to other people, but to other events and circumstances.20 Compassion is good for us. What to do?Firstly, white Australia must learn to understand Aboriginal culture, particularly with respect to its fundamental philosophy of “communitarian solidarity”. Only then can social institutions, such as healthcare services for Aboriginal people, be built on a genuine understanding followed by accommodation of the hopes and aspirations of Aboriginal people. More directly, only then can Aboriginal people have the chance to have health services delivered to them that are, by right, as accessible (in the broadest sense) as they are to white Australians. Secondly, those white people who were described (above) as patronising and paternalistic would cease to be so when, in their “doing good”, good was defined by Aboriginal preferences. Thirdly, Aboriginal communitarian preferences must drive Aboriginal health services, their funding and their performance indicators. Unless the governance of Aboriginal organisations is based on Aboriginal cultural values, these services will not function effectively or efficiently. Fourthly, public compassion must be built into the Australian social fabric. The “fair go”, if it ever existed, has gone, but Australia needs a leadership that will articulate that fair go. The philosopher Martha Nussbaum argues against “impoverished models of humanity” with “numbers and dots taking the place of women and men”.21 She continues: “. . . when one’s deliberation fails to endow human beings with their full and complex humanity, it becomes very much easier to contemplate doing terrible things towards them . . . if you really vividly experience a concrete human life, imagine what it is like to live that life, and at the same time permit yourself the full range of emotional responses to that concrete life, you will . . . be unable to do certain things to that person. Vividness leads to tenderness, imagination to compassion.”21 Finally, our call is for a more compassionate society. Attitudes to asylum seekers, to Aboriginal people, to people who are in any way disadvantaged, are linked. Social attitudes need to be more compassionate to all who are disadvantaged, and not just to Aboriginal people. ConclusionAboriginal people merit so much more from white Australia. First and foremost, they deserve white Australia’s trust — trust that Aboriginal people know better than white Australians what is good for Aboriginal people. They deserve (and not just in their music and dancing) recognition of their culture. Two things are necessary — first, Australian society needs to listen and hear the calls of the disadvantaged (and there are so many in Australia today, especially Aboriginal people); then, those who have compassionate voices need to use them. Many people working in healthcare and in universities have social consciences and believe in social justice. They need not only to give voice to the voiceless, but to give themselves voice as decent, white Australians. In this Australia — this divided, divisive, racist, socially unjust society that we have built — we now need institutions and policies that will unbuild it. We need to acknowledge that the “fair go” is struggling to survive, if not already dead. Fairness and compassion need to be once again the guiding principles of our leaders and our democracy. Only then can we build a society where decency can become the fundamental in addressing Aboriginal health. There will be no sudden breakthrough; there is no magic pill. Decency, however, is a good place to start.

Barbara R Henry GradDipHE · Shane Houston PhD · Gavin H Mooney MA

Subscribe to
MJA email alerts

No spam, you can unsubscribe anytime you want.

By providing your information, you agree to our Terms of Use and our Privacy Policy.

Good one! Your updates are coming

Thank you for subscribing to the MJA email alerts. Receive the latest content in your inbox.