Issues
Volume 223 Issue 9
Cover image credit: Shidlovski/shutterstock.com
Editor’s choice
Evidence synthesis for stronger health systems — necessary but not sufficient
A strong and agile health workforce and evidence‐based practice are two important elements that sustain our health system. These elements do not operate alone — obviously funding and resource allocation and infrastructure, among others, are also of great importance. Together, however, they are important elements that shape both the experience of the patient and the practitioner. The Australian health workforce continues to face considerable challenges, including shortages, geographic maldistribution, burnout and attrition, demographic pressures and training issues. For our health system to function optimally, our health workforce must meet these challenges. Despite previous recommendations, there is no current national health workforce policy in Australia to provide overarching guidance and direction.1 In this issue of the MJA, Topp and colleagues2 present their review of policy documents relevant to the Australian federal health workforce, which they undertook as a starting point for improving policy coordination and reform. Their review included 121 relevant policy documents, and enabled them to describe the fragmentation that exists within federal health workforce policies. In their associated editorial, Bates and colleagues3 reinforce the importance of the health workforce within a sustainable health system, and the importance of a policy framework that facilitates the availability of workers in the areas in which they are required. In addition to this evidence synthesis of policy documents, this issue of the MJA also includes evidence syntheses that will inform practice across two diverse areas of medicine: assessment and management of mild traumatic brain injury and concussion, and genetic testing for monogenic diabetes. Public awareness of the health effects of concussion, and particularly repeated concussions, has increased markedly over the past 25 years. This increased awareness appears to be mostly driven by sports‐related concussions, although falls are the leading cause of concussion hospitalisations in Australia.4,5 Nonetheless, many people with concussion do not receive appropriate care, with management varying across health care settings. In this issue of the MJA, Barlow and colleagues6 discuss the recent, and first, Australian and Aotearoa New Zealand guidelines for the management of concussion, mild traumatic brain injury and persisting post‐concussion symptoms. These guidelines provide over 100 recommendations to inform the management of both acute presentations and longer term persisting symptoms, and should provide greater clarity and confidence for clinicians across diverse health care settings. As indicated by its name, monogenic diabetes describes cases of diabetes caused by a single gene variant. Although relatively rare — monogenic diabetes accounts for less than 5% of all diabetes cases — identifying these variants can have important implications for therapy. In this issue of the MJA, the representatives of multiple societies present a consensus statement on genetic testing for monogenic diabetes in adults, with a focus on recommendations for which patients to test, the benefits of appropriate genetic counselling, and testing methodologies.7 Furthermore, the consensus recommendations detailed in this article not only directly inform accurate diagnosis of monogenic diabetes in adults but also inform the delivery of individualised treatment. However, consensus statements and guidelines do not always fully align with the realities of practice — getting evidence into practice is one of the hardest challenges for health systems. Thomas and colleagues8 highlight the difficulties of managing chronic non‐cancer pain in rural settings. Using qualitative methods, they describe the experiences of rural general practitioners with prescribing opioids for chronic non‐cancer pain. Although the rural practitioners were aware of the guidelines, systemic constraints such as limited consultation times, and limited access to multidisciplinary pain management resources were both factors that influenced the continued prescription of opioids for chronic non‐cancer pain. The latter, which includes allied health support, physical therapy and weight management strategies, highlights the importance, and difficulties, of applying a holistic approach to health and reinforces the call by Topp, Bates and their colleagues for a comprehensive federal health workforce policy.
Michael Skilton
Perspective
Mild traumatic brain injury and concussion and persisting post‐concussion symptoms: new guidelines to support evidence‐based assessment and management in Australia and Aotearoa New Zealand
Research into the implementation of the guidelines on concussion and persisting post-concussion in the context of the differing Australian and Aotearoa New Zealand geographical areas will be important to ensure adequate uptake
Karen M Barlow · Jennie L Ponsford · Alice Theodom · Gill Cowen · Gavin A Davis · Vicki Anderson · Franz E Babl · David Cole · Jennifer Cullen · Stuart R Dalziel · Melinda Fitzgerald · Howard Flavell · Caroline Yates · Rebecca Kimble · John H Olver · Rhonda Orr · Mark Ralfe · Michael Rose · Nick Rushworth · Julia Treleaven · Gary Browne · Nathan Delang · Sarah Harris · Gary Mitchell · Sean Tweedy
Medical education
Splenic injury in severe cases of the zoonoses Q fever and rickettsial infection: diagnostic challenges
A 45-year-old man presented to a regional New South Wales emergency department with five days of malaise, lethargy and dyspnoea
Ashleigh Drury · Philippa Harrison · Aiveen Bannan
Ethics and law
Medicolegal consequences of doctors accepting bequests and gifts under a patient’s will
The development of specific professional standards and/or guidelines for doctors, coupled with education, could reduce the medicolegal risk of doctors becoming entangled in civil litigation about will validity and/or receipt of testamentary gifts
Nicole E Kroesche · Tina L Cockburn · Kelly Purser · Karen A Sullivan
Editorial
Building a health workforce to meet future population needs
Any new policy must consider the complex systems within health care, as well as the other systems with which it interacts
Shona M Bates · Ben Harris‐Roxas · Patricia M Davidson
Research
Federal health workforce policy in Australia and its implications: a descriptive policy document review
The absence of a unified federal health workforce strategy exacerbates policy fragmentation, undermining coordinated workforce planning and equity
Stephanie M Topp · Thu Nguyen · Lana M Elliott
Opioids and the challenges of managing chronic non‐cancer pain in rural Australia: a qualitative study
We found a marked disparity between evidence-based guidelines for chronic pain management and the reality of rural medical practice
Jessica A Thomas · Jill Benson · Philip Davidson · Paul R Ward
Cause‐specific mortality among Queensland people with cirrhosis, by cirrhosis aetiology and decompensation status, 2007–22: a retrospective cohort study
Targeted public health measures for particular patient subgroups are required to save lives among people with cirrhosis
Vikas Bhasker · Jessica R Fong · Paul J Clark · Gunter F Hartel · Richard Skoien · James O’Beirne · Elizabeth E Powell · Patricia C Valery
Research letter
The detection of avian influenza virus in human pathology laboratories in Australia, New Zealand, and South Pacific nations
Avian influenza viruses can be detected by human diagnostic testing platforms routinely used for testing for influenza A viruses
Lisa M Sedger · Vishal Ahuja · Katherine A Lau · Deane L Byers · Torsten Theis · Peter D Kirkland · Catherine Pitman
Consensus statement
Australian and New Zealand joint society consensus statement on genetic testing for monogenic diabetes in adults
A molecular diagnosis of monogenic diabetes can guide family planning, cascade testing and surveillance for other manifestations
Sunita MC De Sousa · Timothy ME Davis · James Harraway · Mark Greenslade · Kathy HC Wu · Ryan G Paul · Juliet Taylor · Aleena S Ali · Elif I Ekinci · Rinki Murphy · Jerry R Greenfield
Supplement
Future Healthy Countdown 2030: learning and employment pathways for healthy children and young people
Med J Aust 2025; 223 (9 Suppl).
Widening the lens of the social and commercial determinants of health
Elizabeth Zuccala
Dousing the burning inequity of global warming for people experiencing homelessness
Timothy English · Alejandro Vásquez Hernández · Glenn Miller · Nuala Fogarty · Charles Cosgrove · Paul Rosenthal · Matthew Larkin · Jon Swain · Danielle Austin · Jo River
Homelessness and cancer care: a missing priority in the Australian Cancer Plan
Amy Stearn · Jennifer A Baldock · Julia N Morris · Joanne Flavel · Fran Baum
Adult attention deficit hyperactivity disorder in Australia: how its current commercial model for diagnosis and treatment is encouraging misdiagnosis
Richard CJ Bradlow · Ferghal Armstrong · Edward Ogden
The importance of universal child and family health services for equitable early development
Anna MH Price · Elodie O’Connor · Sharon R Goldfeld
From words to action: time for Australia to take shared decision making implementation seriously
For the Australian Shared Decision Making Research Network