Issues
Volume 220 Issue 9
Editor's choice
Respecting the role of general practitioners
Recently, my partner and I have been trying to relate some of the disciplining that we do as a family with our almost 3‐year‐old child back to respect: for boundaries, for feelings and for our elders. The two of us have also been reflecting on what respect means to us currently within our profession between various specialties. In this issue of the MJA focusing on general practice, Suetani and colleagues (https://doi.org/10.5694/mja2.52281) make a compelling case for a drastic change in the way mental health care is organised in Australia which requires a respectful collaboration between specialties. They write that increased funding will not necessarily improve mental health care provision, nor will it be particularly efficient without a greater inclusion of the biopsychosocial model in the way mental health is managed. Most general practitioners are currently shouldering the cost of complex mental health care, especially in socially and economically disadvantaged groups without adequate support or funding. Care is often fragmented and lacks a more holistic approach. They argue that a comprehensive approach with adequate inclusion of non‐mental health care workers to help manage some of the socio‐economic inequities that underscore mental health conditions and improve cohesion between the providers of mental health care is likely to yield better value. Primary care is an integral part of health care provision in Australia. Despite recent fragmentation of care with an increasing scope for pharmacists to prescribe antibiotics for urinary tract infections and the advent of urgent care centres, GPs continue to be important in the diagnosis and management of acute conditions in undifferentiated patients as well as screening for and managing a comprehensive list of chronic conditions. In their perspective article, Venning and colleagues (https://doi.org/10.5694/mja2.52287) acknowledge the difficult work that GPs do in trying to diagnose cancer in an undifferentiated patient. In highlighting the Australian Cancer Plan, unveiled in November 2023, which emphasised a strategic commitment to “maximising cancer prevention and early detection,” they acknowledge that currently “no cancer risk assessment tools are in mainstream use in Australian general practice”. They discuss various prediction tools in use and being trialled in Australia as an exciting addition to assist GPs in their day‐to‐day workflow. In a research article, Cameron and colleagues (https://doi.org/10.5694/mja2.52288) examine dysmenorrhea in adolescents, an oft encountered issue in primary care. Using data collected from 1600 adolescents in the Longitudinal Study of Australian Children (LSAC), they have shown an incredibly high prevalence of dysmenorrhea in young Australian adolescents that directly correlates to missed days of school and sports or extracurricular activities. An accompanying editorial by Grover and colleagues (https://doi.org/10.5694/mja2.52290) highlights the need for primary care physicians to recognise and ask about pelvic pain in young female adolescents while also discussing some management strategies. The most important take‐home message seems to be that too many health professionals normalise dysmenorrhea without considering its impact on daily activities. It has become rare as an editor of the MJA who also works as a GP to see research that focuses on the good that GPs do. Most research manuscripts conclude that primary care physicians need better training in or need better funding to perform an intervention. In this issue, a research letter by Albarqouni and colleagues (https://doi.org/10.5694/mja2.52285) illustrates the positive effect of GP intervention. They examined data collected by the 2020–21 National Health Survey and specifically looked at questions around consumption of alcohol, smoking and dietary habits. The team found that although a small proportion of respondents received advice regarding unhealthy levels of drinking alcohol, smoking and poor intake of fruits and vegetables, the proportion who changed their behaviours over time were more likely to have received advice from a GP regarding their habits compared with those who did not. It was heartening to see the power that general practice potentially has in changing behaviours that have a direct impact on the development of chronic disease. As a GP, respect that GPs get from the government feels lacking. The waning respect and renumeration across the profession are reflected in a significant decrease in training numbers of medical graduates choosing primary care as a career. In their research article, Sturman and colleagues (https://doi.org/10.5694/mja2.52291) perform a qualitative analysis with various stakeholders at different levels of general practice training to provide insight into this complex problem. They provide four recommendations: increasing medical student and junior doctor placements in general practice, increasing exposure to inspiring GP clinicians and educators, improving trainee pay and entitlements, and improving integration care and interprofessional relationships between hospitals and general practice clinics. Although intuitively these suggestions should go far to address the burnout and exhaustion evident in the primary care workforce, it feels like none of this would work unless primary care in Australia receives the respect it deserves from governing bodies. The participants in this study, most of them GPs, express their ongoing passion for the profession despite the challenges involved. One quote that was particularly poignant was of a participant talking about “saving the profession we love”. Current workforce projections already talk about a shortfall of GPs with regards to our rapidly ageing population. The problem is that without adequate funding, that comes from respecting the role GPs play in managing chronic disease, most of the solutions for primary care provision seem to focus on fragmenting care to other professionals rather than the resource we have at hand: a group of dedicated, incredibly well educated, and professional doctors that see anyone and everyone walking through their clinic doors.
Aajuli Shukla
Perspectives
The mental health crisis needs more than increased investment in the mental health system
Tackling the mental health crisis requires addressing the social determinants of mental health and a whole-of-system approach to this problem
Shuichi Suetani · Neeraj Gill · Luis Salvador‐Carulla
Symptomatic cancer diagnosis in general practice: a critical perspective of current guidelines and risk assessment tools
Enhancing symptomatic cancer diagnosis requires GP-appropriate guidelines and tools that reflect a generalist approach to diagnosis
Brent Venning · Jon D Emery
Should voluntary assisted dying in Victoria be extended to encompass people with dementia?
Voluntary assisted dying for people with dementia would require a new framework, presenting social, ethical and clinical challenges
Paul A Komesaroff · Michael Chapman · Geetanjali Lamba · Ian H Kerridge · Cameron L Stewart · Alex Holmes · Sophie Lewis · Jennifer Philip
Medical education
Measurement of digoxin levels falsely affected by enzalutamide
A 75-year-old man presented with three days of lethargy and diarrhoea
Noor Lammoza · Maria Hormiz · Cherie Chiang · Chris Stead · Mustafa Ayhan · Samuel C Hume
Editorials
How can we attract more doctors to general practice training?
We must systematically consider how to best recognise, use, and value these critical members of multidisciplinary primary care teams
Belinda G O'Sullivan · Christie Rodda
Ending the neglect of menstrual pain in adolescents is the key to improving outcomes for people with persistent pelvic pain
Understanding trajectories of menstrual health throughout life is critical for effective public health interventions in women’s health
Courtney Munro · Sonia R Grover
Research
Rescuing the profession we love: general practice training sector recommendations for improving the attractiveness of general practice training. A qualitative analysis
General practitioners see substantial challenges, the solutions for which are largely outside the control of their profession
Nancy Sturman · Michael Tran · Sophie Vasiliadis
Menstrual pain in Australian adolescent girls and its impact on regular activities: a population‐based cohort analysis based on Longitudinal Study of Australian Children survey data
Recognising adolescent period pain is also part of early screening for chronic health conditions such as endometriosis
Lauren Cameron · Antonina Mikocka‐Walus · Emma Sciberras · Marilla Druitt · Katherine Stanley · Subhadra Evans
Age group‐specific changes in keratinocyte cancer treatment rates in Australia, 2012–2021: a retrospective cohort study based on MBS claims data
Factors contributing to lower keratinocyte cancer treatment rates among younger Australians require further investigation
Catherine M Olsen · Nirmala Pandeya · Rachel E Neale · David C Whiteman
Research letter
Lifestyle advice from general practitioners and changes in health‐related behaviour in Australia: secondary analysis of 2020–21 National Health Survey data
Interventions that prioritise effective lifestyle advice from general practitioners are needed to combat major risk factors for chronic medical conditions
Loai Albarqouni · Hannah Greenwood · Caroline Dowsett · Paul P Glasziou
Guideline summary
2023 Australian guideline for assessing and managing cardiovascular disease risk
The 2023 Australian CVD guideline provides a pathway for early detection, clinical assessment and management of CVD risk
Mark R Nelson · Emily Banks · Alex Brown · Clara K Chow · David P Peiris · Nigel P Stocks · Rebecca Davies AO · Natalie Raffoul · Lisa Kalman · Emily Bradburn · Garry Jennings
The long tail of COVID‐19
Elizabeth Zuccala
Beyond the planned and expected: the unintended consequences of telehealth in rural and remote Australia through a complexity lens
Sagda Osman · Kate Churruca · Louise A Ellis · Jeffrey Braithwaite
The role of omega‐3 polyunsaturated fatty acids in the prevention of preterm birth
Joanna YX Fu · Carol A Wang · Elyse C Mead · Jason Phung · Maria Makrides · Craig E Pennell
Nothing about us without us
Virginia Barbour
Medicare‐funded reproductive genetic carrier screening in Australia has arrived: are we ready?
Alice P Rogers · Lara Fitzgerald · Jan Liebelt · Christopher Barnett