Survival, mortality and morbidity outcomes after oesophagogastric cancer surgery in New South Wales, 2001–2008
Authors: Nicola Creighton, Ross C Smith and David C Currow
Published online: 20 October 2014
In reply: International evidence of high-volume institutions having better outcomes for complex cancer surgery is strong.1,2 Our analyses confirm the direction and magnitude of this relationship in New South Wales. Should we ignore the international evidence?
Our analyses showed improved 5-year survival for people with oesophagogastric cancer who received surgery in a higher-volume hospital. The difference in survival was not explained by the age, comorbidity, extent of disease or urgency of admission. We used hospital volume as a measure of hospital experience in the surgical and non-surgical management of oesophagogastric cancer patients. More accurate staging and more effective delivery of adjuvant therapy may be part of the reason for the volume–outcome relationships observed. Patient outcomes are determined by more than what happens on the operating table. This is not about the surgeon but about performing complex procedures frequently enough in institutions able to provide the range of diagnostics, perioperative support services, multidisciplinary care and expertise that surgeons require and patients need for great outcomes.3,4 Can anyone defend institutions performing these procedures at a low volume?
Competing interests
No relevant disclosures.
References
- Wouters MW, Gooiker GA, van Sandick JW, Tollenaar RA. The volume–outcome relation in the surgical treatment of esophageal cancer: a systematic review and meta-analysis. Cancer 2012; 118: 1754-1763. 1
- Pieper D, Mathes T, Neugebauer E, Eikermann M. State of evidence on the relationship between high-volume hospitals and outcomes in surgery: a systematic review of systematic reviews. J Am Coll Surg 2013; 216: 1015-1025. 2
- Australia and New Zealand Gastric and Oesophageal Surgery Association. ANZGOSA guidelines for hospitals and/or health services to assist in credentialing of surgeons performing oesophageal resection in Australia and New Zealand 2013. Adelaide: ANZGOSA, 2013. http://www.anzgosa.org/pdf/guidelines-to-performing-oesophagea-resection.pdf (accessed Jul 2014).
- Padbury RTA. Survival from pancreatic cancer: it's not just about the surgical mortality [editorial]. Med J Aust 2012; 196: 491-492. lefthere
Challenges and Opportunities for Strong and Dynamic Foundations in the Australian Cancer Plan
Ashley M. Hopkins, Andrew Rowland, Natansh D. Modi, Ceara Rickard, Mark Haseloff, Norma B. Bulamu, Imogen Ramsey, Niranjan Bidargaddi, Ganessan Kichenadasse, Michael J. Sorich, Kalinda E. Griffiths, Aideen McInerney-Leo, David M. Roder, Raymond J. Chan
Opportunities and Challenges to Achieving the Australian Cancer Plan Goal of World Class Health Systems for Optimal Cancer Care
Carolyn Ee, Ria Joseph, Elise Button, Stacey George, Makala Castelli, David Currow, Prue Cormie, Olivia Farrer, Michael Jefford, Nicolas H. Hart, Chad Y. Han, Deidre D. Morgan, Michael P. Osborn, Candice Oster, Joel Rhee, Anna Ugalde, Eric Yeung, Catherine Paterson
Maximising Cancer Prevention and Early Detection in the Australian Cancer Plan: Where Are We Now and What Should Come Next?
Erin L. Symonds, Billie Bonevski, Richard Edwards, Nathan J. Harrison, Sana Ishaque, Nicole M. Rankin, Sibel Saya, Renee J. Smith, Carolyn Ee
An Australian Narrative Review of Adoptive Cellular Therapies in Malignancy: Expanding Indications, Referral Pathways and Safety Beyond Specialist Centres
Sarah Childs, David Ma, Anthony Rodrigues, Jennifer Massey, Rasha Cosman, Venessa Chin, Laila Girgis, James Lynam, Peter Lau, Barbara Withers, Anthony M. Joshua, Ben Tran, Jayesh Desai, Simon J. Harrison, John Moore, Jia Liu
Peritoneal Tuberculosis and Chronic Myeloid Leukaemia: A Case of Hickam's Dictum
Zayn Al-Timimi, Gem Chew, Martin Browne, Christiaan Mostert
From Ambition to Action: Closing Policy, Equity and Implementation Gaps in the Australian Cancer Plan's ‘Enhanced Consumer Experience’
Carla Thamm, Elise Button, Oluwaseyifunmi A. Agbejule, Reegan Knowles, Karen van Gorp, Mark B. Pinkham, Meinir Krishnasamy, Alexandra L. McCarthy, Raymond J. Chan