Volume 176 - Issue 11
An ecological perspective of cholesterol
Author: Christopher H Cantor
Med J Aust 2002; 176 (11): 564. || doi: 10.5694/j.1326-5377.2002.tb04564.x
Published online: 3 June 2002
Published online: 3 June 2002
To the Editor: The Lipid management guidelines — 2001 supplement1 is no doubt full of cardiovascular wisdom. Unfortunately, the authors appear oblivious to the fact that people are more than just cardiovascular systems. I found no mention of the risks of violent deaths associated with low cholesterol levels, which in some studies have been found to offset the decreased cardiovascular mortality benefits.2
In 1995, Engstrom et al neatly reviewed the relevant issues for those interested in populations of whole people. They cite studies which found low cholesterol levels to be associated with homicidal offenders with habitual violent tendencies when under the influence of alcohol, boys with aggressive conduct disorder, and criminals with antisocial personality, as well as with increased depressive symptoms in men aged 50–89 years. Further, an evaluation of six primary prevention trials found a significant increase in violent deaths in groups receiving interventions to reduce serum cholesterol levels.2
Engstrom et al also reviewed studies which found increased aggression in cynomolgus monkeys fed a low-fat diet. This appeared related to reduced serotonin activity, as serotonin is widely known to reduce aggression. In fairness, Engstrom and colleagues also cited studies which have not found an association between low cholesterol levels and aggression.
If the increase in violent deaths associated with changing the dietary habits of whole populations turns out to be more than a red herring, the ethical and financial implications will be staggering. This evidence is not so conclusive as to have made me change my own relatively low-fat diet, but they do make me wonder if my irritation about the oversight in the Lipid management guidelines — 20011 might have something to do with my low fat intake!
References
- Lipid management guidelines — 2001. MJA 2001; 175 (Suppl 5 November): S57-S88.
- Muldoon MF, Mannuck SB, Matthews KA. Lowering cholesterol concentrations and mortality: a quantitative review of primary prevention trials. BMJ 1990; 301: 309-314. i1149918
- Engstrom G, Alsen M, Regnell G, Traskman-Bendz L. Serum lipids in suicide attempters. Suicide Life-Threat Behav 1995; 25: 393-400. BABBBACH
Estimating Eligibility for GLP-1 Receptor Agonists for Chronic Weight Management and Cardiovascular Disease in Australia: Cross-Sectional Analysis of National Health Survey Data
Jasmin Castrillon, Chris Schilling, Sharmala Thuraisingam, Michael W. Hii, Priya Sumithran, Peter F. Choong, Michelle M. Dowsey, Cade Shadbolt
Seven Vessel Spontaneous Coronary Artery Dissection and Concurrent Transient Global Amnesia After an Emotional Trigger
Michael J. Stewart, Tom R. Sutherland
Seven Vessel Spontaneous Coronary Artery Dissection and Concurrent Transient Global Amnesia After an Emotional Trigger
Virginia Barbour
Designing Housing to Reduce Overcrowding-Related Harms: Rheumatic Heart Disease as the Canary in the Coal Mine
Simon Quilty, Veronica Matthews, Angus Baumann, James Marangou, Bo Remenyi, Gavin Wheaton, Serena Morton Nabanunga, Norman Frank Jupurrurla, Simon Robinson, Steve Mintern, Cary Duffield, Joshua R. Francis, Paul C. Memmott
Diagnosis and Management of Patent Foramen Ovale for Stroke Prevention: An Australian and New Zealand Consensus Statement Developed by a Modified Nominal Group Approach
Brian R. Chambers, Lauren M. Sanders, Amanda Gilligan, Carlos Garcia-Esperon, Jan Ho, John Fink, Matias Yudi, Matthew Lee-Archer, Vimal Stanislaus, Andrew A. Wong