Near-drowning treated with therapeutic hypothermia

To the Editor: We read with interest the case reported by Williamson and colleagues of an adult survivor of near-drowning complicated by cardiorespiratory arrest. 1 This is a remarkable account of survival with near-intact neurological recovery from what was a very bleak initial clinical scenario, and the pre-hospital and hospital personnel responsible for his resuscitation should be congratulated for their efforts.

However, the authors’ use of therapeutic hypothermia in this case does not necessarily support their contention that “controlled hypothermia . . . should be used in near-drowned patients who have spontaneous circulation but remain comatose”.

As presented, the case illustrates the benefit of supportive care in general, and the use of appropriate controlled ventilation in particular. As the authors noted, “gentle hyperventilation to ‘blow off’ excess CO2” corrected the hypercapnia and acidosis. The graphs of arterial pH, lactate level and Pco2 presented in the report show a linear improvement in all three indices after controlled ventilation, before hypothermia measures were begun. Indeed, the commencement of hypothermia had no discernible impact on these trends.

While there is some evidence in the literature for the use of controlled hypothermia after cardiac arrest,2 there is no direct evidence of its benefit for victims of near-drowning. We do not feel that controlled hypothermia can currently be recommended as standard of care for near-drowning on the basis of this single case report.