Thalidomide and cancer?
Author: J Mark Elwood
Published online: 21 April 2003
To the Editor: McBride reports that there were four deaths from cancer before the age of 40 years in a group of 480 thalidomide-affected people in the United Kingdom, an approximate cumulative mortality rate of 0.83%.1 He compares this with the annual death rate in the under-40-years age group, and concludes that the rate is increased almost 100 times in those affected by thalidomide.
The correct comparison is with the cumulative mortality rate in the general population from birth to age 40. From 1999 UK statistics,2 this is about 0.31% — that is, we would expect 1.48 deaths among 480 people. While the observed number of four is greater than this, it is only slightly greater, and the difference is not statistically significant (the mortality ratio is 2.7, with exact 95% confidence limits of 0.7 to 6.9, based on a Poisson distribution). McBride's conclusion is based on an inappropriate comparison.
A full analysis would use population death rates over the 40-year period and take account of censoring, but that is unlikely to affect the result substantially.
References
- McBride W. Thalidomide and cancer [letter]. Med J Aust 2002; 177; 278.<eMJA full text>
- Quinn M, Babb P, Brock A, et al. Cancer trends in England and Wales 1950–1999. London: The Stationary Office, 2001. i1082450
Challenges and Opportunities for Strong and Dynamic Foundations in the Australian Cancer Plan
Ashley M. Hopkins, Andrew Rowland, Natansh D. Modi, Ceara Rickard, Mark Haseloff, Norma B. Bulamu, Imogen Ramsey, Niranjan Bidargaddi, Ganessan Kichenadasse, Michael J. Sorich, Kalinda E. Griffiths, Aideen McInerney-Leo, David M. Roder, Raymond J. Chan
Opportunities and Challenges to Achieving the Australian Cancer Plan Goal of World Class Health Systems for Optimal Cancer Care
Carolyn Ee, Ria Joseph, Elise Button, Stacey George, Makala Castelli, David Currow, Prue Cormie, Olivia Farrer, Michael Jefford, Nicolas H. Hart, Chad Y. Han, Deidre D. Morgan, Michael P. Osborn, Candice Oster, Joel Rhee, Anna Ugalde, Eric Yeung, Catherine Paterson
Maximising Cancer Prevention and Early Detection in the Australian Cancer Plan: Where Are We Now and What Should Come Next?
Erin L. Symonds, Billie Bonevski, Richard Edwards, Nathan J. Harrison, Sana Ishaque, Nicole M. Rankin, Sibel Saya, Renee J. Smith, Carolyn Ee
An Australian Narrative Review of Adoptive Cellular Therapies in Malignancy: Expanding Indications, Referral Pathways and Safety Beyond Specialist Centres
Sarah Childs, David Ma, Anthony Rodrigues, Jennifer Massey, Rasha Cosman, Venessa Chin, Laila Girgis, James Lynam, Peter Lau, Barbara Withers, Anthony M. Joshua, Ben Tran, Jayesh Desai, Simon J. Harrison, John Moore, Jia Liu
Peritoneal Tuberculosis and Chronic Myeloid Leukaemia: A Case of Hickam's Dictum
Zayn Al-Timimi, Gem Chew, Martin Browne, Christiaan Mostert
From Ambition to Action: Closing Policy, Equity and Implementation Gaps in the Australian Cancer Plan's ‘Enhanced Consumer Experience’
Carla Thamm, Elise Button, Oluwaseyifunmi A. Agbejule, Reegan Knowles, Karen van Gorp, Mark B. Pinkham, Meinir Krishnasamy, Alexandra L. McCarthy, Raymond J. Chan