Letters
Health services administration
Volume 192 - Issue 5

Making cars and making health care: a critical review

Author:  Linda E Shields

Med J Aust 2010; 192 (5): 295-296. || doi: 10.5694/j.1326-5377.2010.tb03521.x
Published online: 1 March 2010
Download PDF (72 KB)
Share: Share on Blue Sky Share on Facebook Share on LinkedIn Share by email

To the Editor: As one who works in paediatrics and sees parents bringing their children to hospital for day surgery, and then taking them home again a few hours later, I concur with Winch and Henderson in their critique of “lean thinking” ways of delivering health care.1

Nowhere is this more obvious, and nowhere is it applied with less critical assessment, than in day admissions. This process, which we are told is best for families, may not be. It is best for the hospital, of course, as it means that care can be delivered for a fraction of the cost of keeping people in for several days. But is it best for families? What are we doing to parents when we send them home with a child fresh from surgery? While we might give them some education about what to do if the child has an adverse event, there is not enough time to make sure the parents have understood, are able to read effectively, and have taken any information on board (with their ability to do so potentially hampered by their state of anxiety).

How do we know what the infection rates are after surgery? If the child develops an infection, the parents are likely to take the child to a general practitioner rather than return to the hospital, and busy GPs may not report back to the hospital on the child’s visit and the need for treatment.

We do not ask parents what financial burden we are placing on them. Have they taken days off work or used their holiday time to look after the child? Does that mean financial hardship for the family? Do we ask them what emotional burden it is placing on them? As a highly educated health professional who knows the ropes, I can only imagine how anxious young parents must be with a child who has just had an operation and for whom there is no health care support at home.

Of course, my comments about children are just as salient for adult day surgery admissions. I believe that lean thinking and its penultimate expression in health delivery, the day admission, should be critically re-examined, and there needs to be much more research on the immediate and long-term effects on patients and their families.

View this article on Wiley Online Library