Depressed youth, suicidality and antidepressants

In reply: The data available are inconclusive, but suggest that treatment with selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors (SSRIs) may increase the short-term (less than 14 weeks) risk of suicidal thoughts or self-harm in children and adolescents slightly, by about 2%. However, SSRI treatment may actually decrease the number of completed suicides,1 as Goldney also highlights. To show whether SSRIs influence the risk of completed suicide, a rare event, requires a randomised trial including up to two million individuals.2 This will not happen. Hence, clinicians must rely on accumulated data from experimental, epidemiological, and observational studies. Disagreements about interpretation will doubtless continue.

In response to Mansfield and colleagues, we personally know of media reports influencing some practitioners to revert to using tricyclic antidepressants, and child psychiatrists to avoid treating depressed adolescents. We do not shrink from our interpretation of the implications of Timimi’s reconceptualisation of “depression” as “unhappiness”. Regardless of how childhood depression is classified or named, we remain concerned that the impetus for clinicians to diagnose and treat it not be lost. Its social correlates include stigma and racism, which often involve seeing mental health problems as moral failures of character.

Our view is that fluoxetine shows a favourable harm–benefit profile in moderate to severe depression. According to the Treatment for Adolescents with Depression study,3 which was not funded by drug companies, four children need to be treated with fluoxetine for one to show much or very much improvement attributable to medication. This compares with having to treat 21 children for one to display a widely defined harm-related event. The numbers improve further when fluoxetine is combined with cognitve behavioural therapy (3 and 50, respectively). Pending new studies, clinicians would be unwise to ignore these data when treating serious depression in young people, a recurring illness that produces much suffering, physical and psychosocial disability, and suicide (odds ratio estimates ranging from 11.0 to 27.0).4 Our opinions are consistent with those of the recently released joint clinical guidance by the colleges of psychiatrists, general practitioners, and physicians.5

Mansfield and colleagues suggest that our editorial’s content might have been influenced by drug company gifts. We provided the educated readers of the Journal with information to judge this for themselves.