In reply: Is breastfeeding best practice?
Author: Patricia McVeagh
Published online: 4 November 2002
In reply: I thank Neate for her comments and for challenging the need to ask "Is breastfeeding best practice?". I appreciate her sentiment that there is more to infant feeding than nutrition and health.
However,
while there are mothers who don't find breastfeeding pleasurable or easy and are deciding how long to persist;
while there are mothers who opt not to exclusively breastfeed for six months or to wean before a year of age;
while mothers' advisors prescribe solids or complementary feeds or weaning for myriad problems without evidence for effectiveness beyond a placebo effect;
while some believe that the disadvantages of not breastfeeding only apply to infants in developing countries;
while there are commercial interests promoting products that undermine exclusive breastfeeding;
while the Australian government has not fully implemented the recommendations of the World Health Organization Code and subsequent resolutions;1
while health professionals are receiving "educational material" implying that a new additive makes commercial infant formula more like human milk; and
while the scientifically minded among us just need to satisfy our curiosity,
we need to know to what extent it matters if an infant is breastfed at all, breastfed exclusively, or breastfed for longer periods.
Thank you for challenging the question. The weight of the evidence is such that the real question is not "Is breastfeeding best practice" but "By how much?".
References
- International Code of Marketing of Breast-milk substitutes. Geneva: World Health Organization, 1981, and subsequent resolutions. Available at: <http://www.who.int/nut/documents/code_english.PDF>. Accessed 24 September 2002.
Forty Years in the Making: Reporting on the Co-Creation of a National Roadmap for Birthing on Country Services for the Best Start to Life
Res McCalman, Anneka J. Bowman, Roianne West, Kristie Watego, Jyai Allen, Claire Clack, Sue Kildea, Sue Kruske, Melanie Briggs, Cleone Wellington, Rebecca Coddington, Yu Gao, Isabella Garti, Sascha Kowalenko, Sarah Ireland, Catherine Austin, John D. Boffa, Marah Prior, Kelsie Kahl, Bettina Chaseling, Sarah Khaw, Emily Armstrong, Donna Hartz, Yvette Roe
Temporal Trends in Preterm Birth Associated With Hypertensive Disorders of Pregnancy in Victoria, Australia: A Population-Based Interrupted Time-Series Study
Melvin Marzan, Heng Jiang, Daniel Lorber Rolnik, Joanne M. Said, Lisa Hui
Linguistic Manoeuvres: Obstetric Violence Camouflages Harm and Loss of Consent From Birth
Liz Sutton, Harsha Ananthram, Rebecca Matthews
Linguistic Manoeuvres: Obstetric Violence Camouflages Harm and Loss of Consent From Birth
Bashi Kumar-Hazard, Andrew M. Bisits, Sharon L. Settecasse, Jenny Gamble, Hazel Keedle, Hannah G. Dahlen
Linguistic Manoeuvres: Obstetric Violence Camouflages Harm and Loss of Consent From Birth
Wendy Pollock, Alissa Fleming, Ensieh Fooladi, Joy Kloester, Anne Tremayne, Yasmin Zisin, Bethany Carr, Kym Davey, Suzanne Willey, Jenny Gamble
Getting on the Same Page: Why Australia Needs a National Maternity Early Warning System (MEWS) Chart
Briony A. Cutts, Lucy Bowyer, Nisha Khot, Sandra Lowe, Stefan C. Kane