The Rudd government’s health care reforms have begun and the MJA has joined the community-wide debate with contributions from a raft of health care experts including Penington (→ Prime Minister Rudds plan for reforming Australian public hospitals), Deeble (→ Reforming Australian health care: the first instalment), Bennett (→ Taking the first step toward a healthier future), Hickie (→ The 2010 Rudd plan: will it actually deliver better health services?), Richardson (→ The Rudd reforms: a poisoned chalice in the long run), Eagar (→ The Rudd hospital plan — many pitfalls to avoid on the way to a better health system) and Boxall (→ Reforming Australia’s health system, again). Van Der Weyden (→ The Rudd government’s health reform 2010) says that, overall, the verdict was that the announced plans lack comprehensive details but that it is time to seek the opinions of the profession at large — we await the verdicts of our readers.
Guidance for guidelines
Within 15 years or so, the number of clinical practice guidelines produced in Australia has increased about ninefold from 34 to 313, according to Buchan and colleagues (→ Australian clinical practice guidelines — a national study). They studied guidelines produced between 2003 and 2007, finding that although there has been some improvement in the reporting of several items crucial for the assessment of guideline quality, much more is needed; for example, funding and competing interest statements are not always provided. Also, the researchers noted that it was not at all easy for them to locate clinical guidelines on websites; to try to help to improve access to current guidelines the NHMRC launched a Clinical Practice Guidelines Portal earlier this year (http://www.clinicalguidelines.gov.au).
What can be done when a patient, usually elderly, with aortic stenosis is not fit for surgical aortic valve replacement? Layland and colleagues (→ Percutaneous management of aortic stenosis in high-risk patients) suggest that percutaneous replacement, which avoids the need for cardiopulmonary bypass, may be a viable management option. They describe two such devices currently undergoing evaluation in clinical trials in Australia — the Edwards SAPIEN valve and the CoreValve ReValving System.
Pathology policy pitfalls
The federal government has introduced legislation — the Health Insurance Amendment (Pathology Requests) Bill 2010 — into Parliament requiring all pathology request forms to be marked with the advice to patients that they may be taken to any pathology services provider. The Senate referred the Bill to the Community Affairs Legislation Committee for inquiry and report by 12 May 2010. In an MJA editorial, published first online and now in print, Rowbotham (→ The Health Insurance Amendment (Pathology Requests) Bill 2010: the risks to patients when the Department of Finance and Deregulation makes health policy) raises several concerns about the safety of such an arrangement not only for patients but also for the medical profession.
A Bigger Australia
Why did Australia fare so much better than other developed countries during the global financial crisis? Pelser (→ Super size me: is a big Australia good for our health?) says that economists believe it was because of Australia’s overall population growth of 1.9% in 2008. The Rudd government has stated that it intends to further increase our population, and it has been estimated that by 2049 Australian citizens will number 35 million. Pelser warns that while a boom in Australia’s population might have some short-term economic benefits, in the long term we are likely to have to pay for this expansion with further strain on the health system. It’s food for thought for us all, including Australia’s first Minister for Population.
Not a potty
Drowning is not the only danger our young ones may face when near a swimming pool. Price and colleagues (→ Swimming pool filter-induced transrectal evisceration in children: Australian experience) report three cases of children who suffered major evisceration injuries after sitting on uncovered swimming pool suction drains. These vortex-style drains can create a powerful vacuum when occluded, and all of these children lost part of their intestines after traction on the mesentery subsequently damaged the mesenteric vessels. Price and colleagues say these suction injuries are rare but catastrophic; they call for legislation to mandate the safety of swimming pool fittings.
All at sea?
With the sharp increase in the number of graduating medical students, overseas medical students will be the first to miss out on intern positions, say Elkin and Studdert (→ Restricted career paths for overseas students graduating from Australian medical schools: legal and policy considerations). Will this be legal, or fair, or reasonable? The authors answer this question and more, presenting an interesting juxtaposition: when these doctors leave our shores they will be carrying with them a valuable set of Australian-specific skills, medical knowledge and cultural familiarity — while, at the same time, we will be devoting substantial effort and resources to recruiting international medical graduates with varied training, skills and cultural literacy.
Another time . . . another place
For Hippocratic medicine the reduction of the human death rate has always been an absolute goal, and concern about population growth has never been an accepted constraint on any public health measure. Yet medicine is largely responsible for the overpopulation, which could be one of the major causes of human extinction . . . The application of Hippocratic medicine . . . has proven to be anti-biological; it . . . is largely responsible for the complete disorganization of the ecosystem of the Earth.
Dennis V Razis
Publication of your online response is subject to the Medical Journal of Australia's editorial discretion. You will be notified by email within five working days should your response be accepted.