The shortage of kidneys for transplantation in Australia

To the Editor: We are writing in response to the pejorative, unhelpful and somewhat misleading editorial “The shortage of kidneys for transplantation in Australia”.1

There are many possible reasons for lower organ donation rates in Australia. Several Australian initiatives have led the way in reducing the incidence of severe, traumatic brain injuries. These include the compulsory wearing of seat belts and helmets, random breath testing, and a zero blood alcohol limit for inexperienced drivers. Intensive care medicine is better structured and organised in Australia and New Zealand than in most of the countries cited by Mathew et al, with higher organ donation rates. Intensive care outcomes in Australia are world-leading. So the donor rate may be lower because patient outcomes are better. A comprehensive chart audit of donor potential in New South Wales carried out under the supervision of the Organ Donation Network NSW/ACT, identified very few missed donors (T Wills, Manager, Organ Donation Network NSW/ACT, personal communication), and a Victorian audit has suggested that the donor pool may be much lower in Australia than previously estimated.2

Similarly, organ donation rates will appropriately vary considerably among hospitals. To improve outcomes, critically ill patients are transported to centres with specific experience and expertise, resulting in a preponderance of potential donors in hospitals with trauma and neurosurgical services compared with hospitals lacking these. The intensive care community supports these life-saving initiatives, notwithstanding the effect they may have on organ donation potential.

In fact, the principal “barrier” to organ donation in Australia appears to be the consent rate. From 2000 to 2004, 44% of families declined organ donation when faced with an actual rather than a hypothetical request.3

The intensive care community represents the interests of critically ill patients and their families. We will continue our best endeavours to improve both the survival and quality of life of patients suffering devastating brain injuries (our performance standard). When all brain function ceases, despite our best efforts, we will continue to facilitate organ donation, in discussion with the family, and in consideration of the patient’s known or projected wish. The intensive care community has led the way in developing organ donation-related practice guidelines4 and in related education. Australian Donor Awareness Program — Training (ADAPT) workshops are now a compulsory component of Fellowship of the Joint Faculty of Intensive Care Medicine training. The editorial implication of poor performance and lack of commitment is inaccurate and offensive.