Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people are three times more likely than non-Indigenous Australians to report vision loss due to cataracts, but are four times less likely to have cataract surgery.
To increase access for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people to cataract surgery, we need to identify the barriers to current services and trial strategies to overcome these barriers.
Barriers to cataract surgery exist at the health service, community and individual level.
Health service factors include infrastructure, cost, and provision of interpreters, escorts and transport.
Community factors include social support, perceptions about the success of surgery, and beliefs about the causes of cataracts.
Individual factors include ignorance that cataracts can be cured, fear of surgery or poor outcome, and comorbidity.
Strategies proven to increase uptake of cataract surgery in other countries could be trialled in remote Australia.
Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people are three times more likely than non-Indigenous Australians to report vision loss due to cataracts, but are four times less likely to have cataract surgery.1 This is despite evidence that cataract surgery has a beneficial effect on visual acuity and quality of life.2
The reason for the increased prevalence of cataracts in Indigenous Australians is not known for certain. Relevant risk factors are trauma, age-dependent relationships between cataract (and subsequent mortality) and lower socioeconomic group, smoking, alcohol consumption and increased exposure to sunlight and ultraviolet light.3-5 Impaired glucose tolerance and diabetes6 are risk factors for cataracts, and cataract extraction may be required so that diabetic retinopathy can be treated. The high incidence of diabetes in remote Indigenous people,7 and recent gains in life expectancy8 mean that cataract surgery is an increasing issue in remote Australia.
More services are urgently needed, but the reasons for Indigenous Australians’ low rates of cataract surgery are complex. In this review I discuss the barriers to cataract surgery and make recommendations for action.
Two researchers searched the electronic database MEDLINE 1966–2006 using the medical subject headings eye, cataract, ophthalmology, vision, Oceanic ancestry group, qualitative research, health services accessibility, and delivery of health care, and the key words Indigenous, Aborigin$, and blind. We searched the Australian Government website, the Australian Indigenous HealthInfoNet, the Medical Journal of Australia, the Australian and New Zealand Journal of Ophthalmology, Clinical and Experimental Ophthalmology and the Community Eye Health Journal for relevant articles. Each researcher independently read the titles and available abstracts. The resulting articles were read and assessed for their relevance. The reference lists of these articles were hand searched for further relevant articles.
Most articles on the barriers to cataract surgery come from large surveys in developing countries. This literature is relevant to remote Indigenous Australians whose morbidity and mortality statistics and access to health services resemble those experienced in developing countries. Indigenous Australians live in a developed country, but have blindness rates of 1% (compared with 0.1% blindness for non-Indigenous Australians), similar to rates in the populations of Indonesia, Nepal and Zimbabwe.9 Similarly, Indigenous Australians in remote communities maintain their cultural values of responsibility to family and community, rather than focus on the individual. Combining the literature from Australia and developing countries may reveal clues about the uptake of cataract surgery in Indigenous Australians.
The Australian health ministers have agreed that “All Australians should have equitable access to appropriate eye health care when required”.10 To ensure equity, waiting lists are created. But lists work against those for whom access to communication and transport is unreliable. Being put on a waiting list can mean that other life priorities take precedence on the eventual date of surgery. Many allocated theatre slots are wasted. Conversely, waiting lists mean that care cannot be provided opportunistically when patients are in a regional centre for other reasons.
The primary and secondary care systems and government bureaucracy designed to assist eye health can inadvertently become a barrier to its delivery. In a discussion paper from the Koori Health Research and Community Development Unit, Kaplan-Myrth criticised Aboriginal blindness prevention policy as echoing colonial practice; she argued that Indigenous Australians should shape their health services, not westernised specialists.11
In New South Wales, collaboration between the Aboriginal community, researchers, health care funders, health care providers and educators has increased access and uptake of eye services in Aboriginal Medical Services.12 This service is well used, but cannot provide surgery.
In developing countries, cost is the major barrier to cataract surgery.13-16 Cataract surgery is free in public hospitals in Australia, but the indirect costs of surgery, including the carers’ cost of food, transport and loss of income,17,18 are not. How much cost deters remote Indigenous Australians needing cataract surgery is not known.
The utilisation of eye care services is lower in rural Victoria than in metropolitan Victoria,19 but there is no difference in cataract surgery rates.20 The distances involved in remote Australia exceed those experienced by rural Victorians.
International experience is that uptake of cataract surgery is lower in rural and remote areas than in urban areas.18 Geographical distance and transport18 are cited as barriers for patients and their families;16 if surgery is performed, distance remains an issue for accessing follow-up.21
In Victoria, non-English speakers used eye services less.19 Interpreter services for Indigenous patients are patchy, despite English being the fourth or fifth language for many. Evidence shows that communication problems with Indigenous people extend beyond simple language issues.22
Patients, families and staff all reported a lack of information as a barrier to cataract surgery in The Gambia.16 The effect of information about cataract surgery is mixed. In most patients, information leads to a reduction in fear,23 but some prefer not to know.24 Increasing knowledge does not necessarily increase uptake of cataract surgery: “Physicians walk a tightrope between informing patients sufficiently and frightening them”.25 We need to find the optimum level of information to aid remote Indigenous Australians in making informed decisions about cataract surgery.
Health professionals said African Americans’ knowledge and attitudes were barriers to cataract surgery. In contrast, the patients rated vision and eye care as important and their perceived barriers were trusting and communicating with the doctor, and cost.13 Not being comfortable with the eye doctor can be a barrier,21 and counselling by the ophthalmologist affects satisfaction with quality of care more than other eye health education.26
Social support is an important precondition to surgery.18 Fears of cataract surgery expressed by the family and community15,16 are barriers to cataract surgery, as are family dynamics27 if the dominant member does not see the need for eye care.19 We need to find out what the relevant family dynamics are for Indigenous Australians facing surgery.
Remote Aboriginal Australians have a 28% chance of posterior capsule opacification within 5 years of cataract surgery.28 Seeing others “going blind” again following surgery — albeit from a treatable cause — may affect fellow community member’s enthusiasm. In India, the community misperceived continued poor vision after an operation as an operative failure, when the real cause was macular degeneration or glaucoma.15
The key to health and wellbeing is a balance and harmony with one’s culture. Indigenous people have told me that the dust and environment or people “being sung” cause eye problems. It may be hard to trust that an operation can cure a problem created by these causes.
Estimates from India are that about 50% of those blind from cataracts did not know they could be cured,18 and many did not know where they could get treatment.21 It is not known how many Indigenous Australians are in a similar situation.
Cataracts grow slowly. Gradual loss in vision is less noticeable than sudden loss. People adapt and manage despite poor vision and literally do not see the need for surgery.15,16,21,28 Surgery becomes a more acceptable option as blindness from cataract worsens.14
Fear is a significant barrier to cataract surgery. There can be fear of the operation,30 fear of a poor outcome (ie, that the operation will damage the eye),15 fear that a check-up would show a real problem,21 and fear of death.15,27
In some instances, this fear is justified from having seen a bad outcome.15 The Western Australian data on endophthalmitis show a higher incidence for remote community people.31 Watching the experience of others28 affects the level of personal fear.16
Personal beliefs are often intertwined with societal beliefs and so barriers noted at the community level also affect the individual. The effect on individuals of isolation from their land when having cataract surgery is assumed,32 but needs further exploration.
In Victoria, there were no differences in cataract surgery rates according to age, ethnicity, health insurance status, occupation or education level.20 Similarly, the Blue Mountains Eye Study showed no statistically significant difference in the incidence of cataract surgery for 5 years for any of the occupational categories.33 However, more recent data from Western Australia showed increased surgery rates for female and older patients, and lower rates for socioeconomically disadvantaged people and rural residents.34 The most advantaged underwent 9% more surgery than the most disadvantaged. These differences demonstrate the increasingly two-tiered Australian health system, with more privately provided cataract surgery in urban areas.
Experience from overseas is that some patients want eye check-ups, but other medical problems prevent them from going.21 The high morbidity experienced by remote Indigenous Australians creates similar dilemmas, and the waiting list system means that patients accessing care in a regional centre for a comorbid condition cannot opportunistically seek cataract removal.
In eastern Africa,35 surgery rates increased when:
the decision to do surgery was made on the community site;
the examiner on site had enough training to differentiate causes of visual impairment;
the patient was transported to hospital on the day of diagnosis;
the patient was transported to and from hospital;
the team included a dedicated counsellor and program manager;
there were no hidden charges;
there was no fee for examination at the site;
fixed sites were visited regularly and advertised, and never cancelled; and
the community program was closely coordinated with hospital services.
A study in Aravind, India, compared the cost-effectiveness of strategies to reduce the barriers to cataract surgery in 10 villages with 10 control villages.36 The interventions were an aphakic motivator (a person who had had a successful cataract operation), a basic eye health worker, a screening van, or a mass media campaign, and either fully funded or partially funded (excluding costs of transport or food) surgery. The most effective, but more costly, intervention was fully funded surgery and an aphakic motivator. Second best, and less expensive, was a mobile screening van. Aphakic motivators have subsequently proved effective in rural Malawi.37
The higher risk of endophthalmitis in remote Australians31 and high morbidity from other illnesses demand that surgery be performed in a sterile hospital environment. Cataract camps work effectively in developing countries, but anecdotal evidence is that this model had mixed results in central Australia.
Cataracts are a significant cause of preventable blindness in the remote Indigenous population. A comprehensive strategy is needed,38 and the National Framework for Action to Promote Eye Health and Prevent Avoidable Blindness and Vision Loss is welcome. Our approach must be comprehensive from the patients’ perspective as well as the providers’. The Box summarises the recommendations for action. The Fred Hollows Foundation is trialling the second recommendation of a fully funded and supported model of care in partnership with the Northern Territory and Commonwealth governments in central Australia.
Removal of external barriers by the provision of accessible and affordable surgery reveals other fundamental attitudinal barriers among the blind population.27 “People who do not use eye services know why they do not seek treatment. It is therefore critical that providers ask and listen to the views of their community”.39
Eye services in Australia could trial models that have been successful in developing countries. The literature suggests factors that could explain the underutilisation of cataract surgery in the Indigenous population. Research is needed to explore these factors to reduce the preventable burden of blindness of Aboriginal Australians.
Recommendations for action
Patient-centred hospital service: designated slots for cataract surgery for Indigenous patients. Slots allocated according to community eye visits, people available for opportunistic care, and the waiting list.
Fully funded and supported services: this includes transport, food for the patient and carer, interpreter, counselling/liaison services, program management, and a visionary.*
Research, grounded in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities, into the best ways to overcome the information, fear and health belief barriers to allow Indigenous Australians to make informed decisions about cataract surgery.
- 1. Vision 2020 Australia. Facts on eye health: Australia (including Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islanders) [fact sheet]. http://www.vision2020australia.org.au/pdf/Fact_Sheet_Aust_ATSI-final.pdf (accessed Jul 2007.)
- 2. Hewitt A, Verma N, Gruen R. Visual outcomes for remote Australian Aboriginal people after cataract surgery. Clin Experiment Ophthalmol 2001; 29: 68-74.
- 3. McGwin G, Owsley C, Gauthreaux S. The association between cataract and mortality among older adults. Ophthalmic Epidemiol 2003; 10: 107-119.
- 4. Hollows F, Moran D. Cataract — the ultraviolet risk factor. Lancet 1981; 2: 1249-1250.
- 5. Angra SK, Murthy GVS, Gupta SK, et al. Cataract related blindness in India and its social implications. Indian J Med Res 1997; 106: 312-324.
- 6. Saxena S, Mitchell P, Rochtchina E. Five-year incidence of cataract in older persons with diabetes and pre-diabetes. Ophthalmic Epidemiol 2004; 11: 271-277.
- 7. Australian Institute of Health and Welfare Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health and Welfare Unit. Ill-health conditions: diabetes. http://www.aihw.gov.au/indigenous/health/health_conditions.cfm#Diabetes (accessed Jul 2007).
- 8. Australian Institute of Health and Welfare Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Health and Welfare Unit. Mortality. http://www.aihw.gov.au/indigenous/health/mortality.cfm (accessed Jul 2007).
- 9. Thylefors B, Negrel AD, Pararajasegaram R, et al. Global data on blindness. Bull World Health Organ 1995; 73: 115-121.
- 10. Australian Health Ministers’ Conference. National framework for action to promote eye health and prevent avoidable blindness and vision loss. Canberra: Australian Government Department of Health and Ageing, 2005: 20. http://www.health.gov.au/internet/wcms/publishing.nsf/Content/ageing-eyehealth-publication.htm (accessed Jul 2007).
- 11. Kaplan-Myrth N. Political visions: blindness prevention policy as a case study of community–government relations in Aboriginal health. Discussion Paper No. 10. Melbourne: VicHealth Koori Health Research and Community Development Unit, 2004. http://www.onemda.unimelb.edu.au/publications/discpapers.html (accessed Jul 2007).
- 12. Layland B, Holden B, Evans K, et al. ICEE/AHMRC NSW Aboriginal Eye and Visioncare Program, Australia. Rural Remote Health 2004; 4: 247.
- 13. Owsley C, McGwin G, Scilley K, et al. Perceived barriers to care and attitudes about vision and eye care: focus groups with older African Americans and eye care providers. Invest Ophthalmol Vis Sci 2006; 47: 2797-2802.
- 14. Snellingen T, Shrestha BR, Gharti MP, et al. Socioeconomic barriers to cataract surgery in Nepal: the South Asian cataract management study. Br J Ophthalmol 1998; 82: 1424-1428.
- 15. Fletcher AE, Donoghue M, Devavaram J, et al. Low uptake of eye services in rural India: a challenge for programs of blindness prevention. Arch Ophthalmol 1999; 117: 1393-1399.
- 16. Johnson JG, Goode V, Faal H. Barriers to the uptake of cataract surgery. Trop Doct 1998; 28: 218-220.
- 17. Brilliant GE, Lepkowski JM, Zurita B. Social determinants of cataract surgery utilization in South India. Arch Ophthalmol 1991; 109: 584-589.
- 18. Brilliant GE, Brilliant LB. Using social epidemiology to understand who stays blind and who gets operated for cataract in a rural setting. Soc Sci Med 1985; 21: 553-558.
- 19. Keefe JE, Weih LM, McCarty CA, Taylor HR. Utilisation of eye care services by urban and rural Australians. Br J Ophthalmol 2002; 86: 24-27.
- 20. McCarty CA, Nanjan MB, Taylor HR. Operated and unoperated cataract in Australia. Clin Experiment Ophthalmol 2000; 28: 77-82.
- 21. Dandona R, Dandona L, Naduvilath TJ, et al. Utilisation of eye care services in an urban population in southern India: the Andra Pradesh eye disease study. Br J Ophthalmol 2000; 84: 22-27.
- 22. Cass A, Lowell A, Christie M, et al. Sharing true stories: improving communication between Aboriginal patients and healthcare workers. Med J Aust 2002; 176: 466-470. <MJA full text>
- 23. Leydhecker W, Gramer E, Krieglstein GK. Patient information before cataract surgery. Ophthalmologica 1980; 180: 241-246.
- 24. Cheung D, Sandramouli S. The consent and counselling of patients for cataract surgery: a prospective audit. Eye 2005; 19: 963-971.
- 25. Kiss CG, Richter Muekesch S, Stifter E, et al. Informed consent and decision making by cataract patients. Arch Ophthalmol 2004; 122: 94-98.
- 26. Nijkamp MD, Ruiter RAC, Roeling M, et al. Factors related to fear in patients undergoing cataract surgery: a qualitative study focusing on factors associated with fear and reassurance among patients who need to undergo cataract surgery. Patient Educ Couns 2002; 47: 265-272.
- 27. Rotchford AP, Rotchford KM, Mthethwa LP, et al. Reasons for poor cataract surgery uptake — a qualitative study in rural South Africa. Trop Med Int Health 2002; 7: 288-292.
- 28. Hewitt A, Verma N. Posterior capsule opacification after cataract surgery in remote Australian Aboriginal patients. Clin Experiment Ophthalmol 2002; 30: 248-251.
- 29. Geneau R, Lewallen S, Bronsard A, et al. The social and family dynamics behind the uptake of cataract surgery: findings from Kilimanjaro Region, Tanzania. Br J Ophthalmol 2005; 89: 1399-1402.
- 30. Fagerstrom R. Fear of a cataract operation in aged persons. Psychol Rep 1993: 72; 1339-1346.
- 31. Semmens JB, Li J, Morlet N, et al. Trends in cataract surgery and postoperative endophthalmitis in Western Australia (1980–1998): the Endophthalmitis Population Study of Western Australia. Clin Experiment Ophthalmol 2003; 31: 213-219.
- 32. Burns J, Thomson N. Summary of Indigenous health: eye health. Aboriginal Islander Health Worker J 2004; 28; 32-43.
- 33. Younan C, Mitchell P, Cumming RG, et al. Socioeconomic status and incident cataract surgery: the Blue Mountains Eye Study. Clin Experiment Ophthalmol 2002; 30: 163-167.
- 34. Ng JQ, Morlet N, Semmens JB. Socioeconomic and rural differences for cataract surgery in Western Australia. Clin Experiment Ophthalmol 2006; 34: 317-323.
- 35. Lewallen S, Roberts H, Hall A, et al. Increasing cataract surgery to meet Vision 2020 targets; experience from two rural programmes in east Africa. Br J Ophthalmol 2005; 89: 1237-1240.
- 36. Ellwein LB, Lepkowski JM, Thulasiraj GE, et al. The cost effectiveness of strategies to reduce barriers to cataract surgery. Int Ophthalmol 1991; 15: 175-183.
- 37. Courtwright P. Eye care knowledge and practices among Malawian traditional healers and the development of collaborative blindness prevention programmes. Soc Sci Med 1995; 41: 1569-1575.
- 38. Brian G, Taylor H. Cataract blindness — challenges for the 21st century. Bull World Health Organ 2001; 79: 249-256.
- 39. Donoghue M. People who don’t use eye services: ‘Making the Invisible Visible’. Community Eye Health 1999; 12: 36-38.
Publication of your online response is subject to the Medical Journal of Australia's editorial discretion. You will be notified by email within five working days should your response be accepted.