Doctors of many talents

Annabel McGilvray
Med J Aust
Published online: 18 November 2013

Junior doctors are pushing to create pathways to more diverse careers

Many of medicine’s most celebrated practitioners have been doctors whose work has shone beyond the consulting rooms, wards and theatres of the clinical sphere — from John Snow and the epidemiology of his Broad Street Pump intervention, to Anton Chekhov and The cherry orchard. More recently and closer to home, we have Dr Pat McGorry and his research in and advocacy for mental health, and Dr Norman Swan and his medical journalism.

Theirs are often called “portfolio careers”, a term coined by management guru Charles Handy in the 1980s. It describes the working life of people who don’t follow a single career path but who, like Swan, McGorry, Snow and Chekhov, are able combine two or more different areas simultaneously. It may be medicine and art, business, media or engineering but, in practice, it is more often a combination of medicine and research, teaching or health administration.

And in an increasingly competitive Australian medical workplace for junior doctors, a second or third string to the professional bow is now an important career advantage. Training administrators say this is contributing to a growing interest in participation in research and teaching during the prevocational and specialist training periods.

But how can doctors incorporate the additional commitments required to develop a career in parallel with their medical training?

Dr Harris Eyre is busy developing his portfolio career with a mix of clinical medicine, administration, public health, education and research, based in Townsville, Queensland, where he is resident medical officer and in the first year of his PhD through the University of Adelaide. He cites Dr McGorry as a particular inspiration in how to balance clinical and non-clinical career paths.

Like Dr McGorry, Dr Eyre and other doctors-in-training are keen to have health-related experience outside clinical medicine. They’re all just a little bit nerdy that way, he says.

“We’re just a little bit inquisitive and want to see what else is out there. We know that there’s a whole other world related to health — the social issues that are outside clinical medicine. So we know it’s a good thing to get involved and we want to help engineer the system in Australia to make it possible for other people.”

He says there is a big hunger out there in junior doctors and medical students for the opportunity to incorporate additional pathways during their training in order to be involved in other aspects of the health system. Clinical academic training pathways in particular are needed, he says.

Dr Eyre points out the current difficulty in pursuing such a pathway. “I do my research, my PhD, on top of my clinical work and it’s very hard to get time off from the hospital.

“My research now is done in the morning before I go to work and after work when I get home. That has big impacts on my relationship with my partner, and sport and socialising.”

Earlier this year Dr Eyre and his colleagues were involved in setting out the Australian Medical Association’s position statement, which points out that the current academic-clinical workforce is ageing and that raises questions about career progression, job security and remuneration.

Among other recommendations, the position statement suggests that the opportunity to take part in research should become part of every medical student’s education and that mentors could play a vital role in fostering early career medical researchers.

Dr Eyre suggests that for those interested in a clinical-academic career, one rotation of the internship year could be devoted to research. The concept is similar to the United Kingdom’s successful Academic Foundation Programme, where medical graduates have the opportunity to begin working towards a combined clinical and research, teaching or leadership career from their internship year. In 2013, 501 places were offered in the UK program and there is strong demand for it to be expanded.

At a time when clinical training places are at a critical shortage across Australia, if interested graduates are able to spend part of their internship in a laboratory, it may help free some more placements.

And tentative moves by a number of colleges to provide more part-time specialist and general practice training places could make space for Dr Eyre and his colleagues to cultivate emerging portfolio careers without significantly eating into precious family and social life.

Given the track record of doctors past and present who have embraced such multifaceted careers, with greater recognition and encouragement, the benefits for the individuals involved, the broader health system and society in general could well be significant.

Case studies

Dr Sam Prince – Entrepreneur, philanthropist

In addition to overseeing two rapidly growing restaurant chains, Dr Sam Prince, a 2006 Monash University medical graduate and the 2012 ACT Young Australian of the Year, is driving initiatives to eliminate scabies from Australia, build schools in Sri Lanka, and provide food in Liberia.

He is also studying genetics and bioinformatics, and is developing a genomics company that he hopes will be at the forefront in the evolution of personal medicine. “I find that if you’re doing what you’re passionate about, then you always find the time [to do it].”

Dr Prince, 30, says that his love of adventure and discovery has prompted his diverse careers but clinical medicine remains the part of his life most grounded in reality. “Business can be exhilarating, but you can also inhale your own fumes a little.

“Sometimes, you have to see through your own business trouble and pain, to realise tha the clinical stuff puts everything else into perspective.”

Dr Prince’s portfolio career began while he was still a medical student with the opening of his first restaurant Zambrero. The incredible growth of the Zambrero chain — now stretching across Australia — provided the funding for him to establish the Emagine foundation to provide information technology learning centres in South-East Asia and northern Australia. It also enabled him to begin One-Disease-at-a-Time which aims to eliminate preventable diseases.

But right now, Dr Prince is most excited about upskilling to run his newest business, an ambitious genomics project that he hopes will lead the way when it comes to personal medicine and the power of knowledge.

“It’s medicine, it’s patient advocacy, and it’s heavy on discovery!”

And his advice to other doctors considering branching out into new field?

“Do it, because if it doesn’t work, what is the worst thing that could happen to you? You’d be a doctor. It’s not a bad contingency plan.”

Professor Ajay Rane – Urologist, movie producer

Professor Ajay Rane realised that he wanted to contribute more to the world, above and beyond his clinical work, when he was living in the United Kingdom and basking in the benefits of a successful specialist consultancy career.

“Life was good, and yet it was not enough", says the Indian-born urogynaecologist now based in Townsville, Queensland. “I suddenly realised that it shouldn’t be all about me. The more fun was actually in giving.”

As a first step towards amending this, Professor Rane worked to set up a fistula hospital in southern India and moved with his wife to northern Queensland to establish a women’s health program.

He is still involved with the Indian hospital, which treats between 300 and 400 women each year, but says that the training and infrastructure they have provided has enabled it to begin operating independently.

Professor Rane has also been an enthusiastic educator in the school of medicine and dentistry at James Cook University and now heads the department of obstetrics and gynaecology as well as sustaining a busy consultancy practice and developing a new toilet design to better suit our anatomy — the Duneze.

However, the plight of women and girls in India remains a major focus of what he describes as his “weird” portfolio career. Concern about the estimated 60 million girls killed through infanticide and feticide since 1984 alone prompted him to create a feature film exploring the issues behind this tragedy.

“We made a proper Bollywood movie with songs because it had to go to the grassroots.

“Unfortunately, it was a megaflop in India”, he says, but garnered awards at Cannes and Berlin.

But with all of this giving, he says there are some sacrifices, and he is thankful he has a very supportive wife and equally understanding children.

“It’s all a state of mind really. You can complain about your life or you can make something out of it.”

  • Annabel McGilvray



remove_circle_outline Delete Author
add_circle_outline Add Author

Do you have any competing interests to declare? *

I/we agree to assign copyright to the Medical Journal of Australia and agree to the Conditions of publication *
I/we agree to the Terms of use of the Medical Journal of Australia *
Email me when people comment on this article

Online responses are no longer available. Please refer to our instructions for authors page for more information.