Volume 195 - Issue 2
Safeguard or mollycoddle? Medical student placements in Aboriginal communities
Author: Adrian N Winsor
Med J Aust 2011; 195 (2): 102-104. || doi: 10.5694/j.1326-5377.2011.tb03229.x
Published online: 18 July 2011
Published online: 18 July 2011
To the Editor: I spent my fifth-year medical student elective at Alice Springs Hospital and a remote Aboriginal settlement in the north-west of South Australia in the early 1980s. I organised this myself and came away with a fairly firm belief that the health of the Indigenous population in remote areas was unlikely to improve.
Between 1995 and 2009, I visited remote Aboriginal settlements and hospitals in Darwin and Alice Springs as a specialist physician. Nothing I have seen in that time has changed the view I formed as a student.
During my time in these settings, I have seen in the Indigenous population extreme examples of poverty, severe neglect of children and adults with disability, and examples of physical and sexual abuse. On occasions I have been threatened, and at times I have needed to be escorted for my safety. When staying overnight on settlements, I have been provided with secured accommodation. I have walked in fear of feral and diseased camp dogs and have been hurried along in my work to avoid cultural incidents.
The article by Patel and colleagues explores some of the issues in this area as they affect medical student training.1 I think it is good that they have done so, but to dress it up with quasi-scientific methodology is unnecessary.
My view is that it is not possible to provide or sustain health services of any reasonable standard in small and remote communities that have no economic basis for development and where the population is poor, poorly educated and has little prospect to share in this country’s fortune.
There is a reason that we are failing to improve the health of the Indigenous population in remote areas, and that is that we cannot. It is an unrealistic expectation. This needs to be acknowledged, and we all need to move on.
References
- Patel A, Underwood P, Nguyen HT, Vigants M. Safeguard or mollycoddle? An exploratory study describing potentially harmful incidents during medical student placements in Aboriginal communities in Central Australia. Med J Aust 2011; 194: 497-500. 0_DHBDGCJH
Costs of Delivering the Hep B PAST Model of Care in Remote Australia: A Retrospective Pre–Post Study
Hoa Nguyen, Anh Le Tuan Nguyen, Paula Binks, Melita McKinnon, Emily Vintour-Cesar, Karen Wills, Nicola Stephens, Benjamin Cowie, Joshua S. Davis, Yuejen Zhao, Peter Nihill, Julie A. Campbell, Andrew J. Palmer, Jane Davies, Barbara de Graaff
Epidemiology and Quality of Care for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Peoples Treated by Emergency Medical Services for Stroke in Victoria, Australia: Retrospective Analysis of Linked Data
Candice Menezes, Ziad Nehme, Luke J. Burchill, Tegwyn McManamny, Angela Dos Santos, Michelle Crilly, Luke P. Dawson, Benjamin Clissold, David Anderson, Emily Nehme
Hepatitis C Among First Nations Australians: A Rethink Is Required to Meet the 2030 Elimination Target
James Ward, Emily Pegler, Kellie Stacy, Stephen Harfield
Sovereignty and Survival: Understanding Lung Cancer Outcomes for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander People in Australia, a Case–Control Study
Alice R. T. Bergin, Luc te Marvelde, Roger L. Milne, Benjamin J. Solomon, Kris Ivanova, Peter Savas, Stephen J. Luen, Jay Hamann, Andrea Casey, Nicole Watt, Sue M. Evans, Gail Garvey, Sherene Loi
Rethinking Rheumatic Fever Diagnosis: Progress, Pitfalls and the Path Towards a Definitive Test
Anna P. Ralph, Rachel Webb, Tom Parks, Nicole J. Moreland, Asha C. Bowen, Benjamin Jones, Emma Ndagire, Andrea Z. Beaton
Not Gone but Often Forgotten: Action Needed to Address Tuberculosis in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Communities
Nikkita Joshua, Emma L. Smith, Eunice (Cheeky) Love, Christopher P. Lowbridge, Nicole Tukana, Amy Bowden, Megan A. Campbell, Dawn Casey, James Ward