In reply: Primum non nocere means both “first, do no harm” and “above all, do no harm”. We acknowledge there may be both potential harms (the most significant being removal of the child from the family) as well as hoped-for benefits in involving child protection services in cases of severe childhood obesity. Though we strenuously oppose notification of child protection authorities as a general policy, we raised the idea that, in exceptional circumstances, health care professionals may nonetheless have a professional and legal obligation at least to consider notifying such authorities. We did so cautiously because we fear an exception becoming a rule, particularly in services such as ours where we frequently care for children very like the “child” we describe.
Publication of your online response is subject to the Medical Journal of Australia's editorial discretion. You will be notified by email within five working days should your response be accepted.