Alcohol sales must be monitored
Relying solely on the results of consumer surveys to estimate alcohol usage patterns in the Australian population would be a huge mistake, say Hall et al (→ Alcohol sales data are essential for good public policies towards alcohol). Despite the known inadequacies of self-report in this domain, the Australian Government is on the brink of abandoning the use of sales data to supplement consumer surveys. The authors argue against this move, calling for continued and enhanced sales surveillance.
Obesity surgery on the rise
According to a study from Western Australia, bariatric surgery is becoming an increasingly common treatment for obesity, with acceptable morbidity and mortality rates. Smith et al used the WA Data Linkage System to correlate all bariatric procedures performed in WA hospitals between 1988 and 2004 with hospital morbidity and death data (→ Incidence of bariatric surgery and postoperative outcomes: a population-based analysis in Western Australia). Over the 17 years, the rate of surgery increased from 1.2 to 24.2 procedures per 100 000 person-years — about a 20-fold increase overall (and a 13-fold increase in the obese population). Thirty-day postoperative mortality was 0.07%, and complications were recorded in 9.6% of patients. At 5 years, the risk of death was equal to that of the general population.
A word from our sponsors
Hutchinson and Rubinfeld surveyed 259 people participating in clinical research at the Royal Melbourne Hospital, finding that just over a third of participants would like to know how much funding had been allocated to their study, and more than half wanted to be informed of the sponsors’ identity (→ Financial disclosure and clinical research: what is important to participants?). Other issues, such as payments received by the investigators, were also of interest to many.
The Swinburne National Technology and Science Monitor has been measuring consumer experiences of health care for some years. Hardie and Critchley report the results of a recent 800-person telephone survey (→ Public perceptions of Australia’s doctors, hospitals and health care systems). Trust in medical practitioners was generally high, with general practitioners slightly outdoing specialists. Private hospitals were marginally more trusted than public hospitals, but Medicare fared better than private health funds, and there was strong “pro-public” response to questions about future funding models for health care.
A large postal survey of general practice patients in Victoria has also yielded heartening results regarding patient satisfaction. In “How do Australian patients rate their general practitioner? A descriptive study using the General Practice Assessment Questionnaire”, Potiriadis et al collate the responses of over 7000 patients to the General Practice Assessment Questionnaire, which has been extensively used in the United Kingdom. Victorian GPs exceeded the UK national benchmarks in all domains — receptionists, access, continuity of care, communication, practice nurses, and the practice overall.
Carcinogenic policy void
The need for obesity control measures is becoming more urgent, say Olver and Grogan, as the link between increased body mass index and several common cancers becomes firmly established (→ Cancer adds further urgency to prioritising obesity control). Will the government finally rise to the challenge as our cancer control bodies join the strident calls for tough legislative approaches to the obesogenic Australian diet?
Keeping track of PCIs
Australia should establish a registry of interventional cardiology procedures, says Scott (→ Why we need a national registry in interventional cardiology). While percutaneous coronary intervention is increasingly being used in patients with acute coronary syndromes and angina, there are questions about efficacy, safety and costs that we do not have enough Australian data to answer. In the absence of randomised trials to cover every clinical circumstance, a registry would be of enormous benefit. Stent thrombosis, which carries a high mortality rate, is one of the complications that a registry would monitor. As indicated by the case presented by Barthwal and Herman, this can occur after ceasing clopidrogel therapy, even several years after stent placement (→ Very late stent thrombosis after discontinuation of clopidogrel therapy).
More on reform
Our reform series continues in this issue, with very concrete contributions on the two major Australian health care interfaces. Dwyer suggests some rational restructuring and reorganisation of the hospital sector (→ Fixing the problems that beset the Australian hospital system), which will nonetheless be ineffective without adequate funding, while Kidd et al articulate equity as the major principle that must underpin reform in primary health care (→ Primary health care reform: equity is the key).
Another time . . . another place
Winston Churchill, 1963
Publication of your online response is subject to the Medical Journal of Australia's editorial discretion. You will be notified by email within five working days should your response be accepted.