Letters
Mental health Health services administration
Volume 188 - Issue 8

Early intervention in youth mental health

Author:  David A Sholl

Med J Aust 2008; 188 (8): 492-493. || doi: 10.5694/j.1326-5377.2008.tb01734.x
Published online: 21 April 2008
Download PDF (349 KB)
Share: Share on Blue Sky Share on Facebook Share on LinkedIn Share by email

To the Editor: There are two fundamental flaws in the case for reform of youth mental health services outlined recently by McGorry and colleagues.1,2 They argued that 18 years is an unnatural and inappropriate transition point between adolescent and adult services, and that Child and Adolescent Mental Health Services (CAMHSs) are somehow inherently ill equipped to deal with serious mental illness.

McGorry has long advocated a “youth model” catering for adolescents and young adults together. I believe this would be a disaster, particularly for adolescents. Adolescents and young adults need very different models of care, because of the differing degrees of responsibility and autonomy they can handle, the legal and moral responsibilities of families, carers, schools and health professionals, and the effectiveness of treatments.

McGorry’s well deserved reputation and influence mean there is a real risk his opinions will be accepted as fact, especially as the opposing view is seldom heard.

People aged under 18 years (on average) are not expected, or permitted, to take full responsibility for their lives or their mistakes. Legally, they cannot vote, drink or buy cigarettes. They are generally still at school and living in the family home. Those aged under 16 years are not automatically entitled to grant or withhold consent to treatment.

Families thus have a central role in the management of illness in adolescents, in a way that is neither possible nor appropriate for adult patients.

Adolescent inpatient units need to be highly structured environments where adults would be out of place, with school-like rules, and careful control of group process and peer interactions. Otherwise, there is bullying, sexual exploitation, epidemics of self-harm, and the kind of competitive rebelliousness that leads to riots and fires. In adult units, adolescents are unacceptably vulnerable, not only from exploitative older patients, but from a lack of boundaries to their own behaviour.

McGorry made several perplexingly dismissive comments about CAMHSs. Two cannot go unanswered: that CAMHSs “struggle operationally and clinically with . . . mood, psychotic, substance use, and borderline personality disorders”;1 and that “the capacity to skilfully and safely manage highly disturbed behaviour, and the more sophisticated psychopharmacological skills, are often lacking in . . . CAMHSs”.1

The disorders described are, in fact, “bread-and-butter” work for CAMHSs. Further, there is powerful anecdotal evidence that CAMHSs manage them better, not worse, than others. Examination of data held by the Victorian Department of Human Services and the Office of the Chief Psychiatrist on seclusion (sole confinement) rates, consumer satisfaction and suicide rates will bear this out. Child psychiatrists all train as adult psychiatrists first and, in my experience, do not lack psychopharmaceutical sophistication.

It is hard to see what adolescents and their families have to gain from being incorporated into young adult services, nor why 30-year-olds should be excluded from specialist early psychosis services.

We need greater integration between the current tiers of service, and a more flexible approach to transition between them, not another separate tier of service.

View this article on Wiley Online Library

More like this

Mental health Perspective 20 July 2026 Open Access

Reorienting Allied Health Into Community-Based Care for People Experiencing Trauma and Social Disadvantage

Simon Rosenbaum, Grace McKeon, Gulsah Kurt, Oscar Lederman, Kemi Wright, Sabuj Kanti Mistry, Jackie E. Curtis, Philip B. Ward, Zachary Steel, Hamish Fibbins, Rachel Morell, Melissa C. Eaton, Andrew Watkins, Ben Harris-Roxas, Brendan Goodger, Eleanor Beck, Megan Teychenne, Joseph Firth, Davy Vancampfort, David Burns, Russell Roberts, Tristan Favaloro, Danielle Weber, Rosanna Barbero, Vasili Maroulis, Melissa Holmes, Stefan Mackenzie, Chiara Mastrogiovanni, Afsana Anwar, Uzma Choudhry, Catherine Sherrington, Jane Currie, Thomas Gadsden, Scott Teasdale

View more