MJA
MJA InSight
MJA Careers
For debate

Ethics and the proposed treatment for a 13-year-old with atypical gender identity

Merle P Spriggs
Med J Aust 2004; 181 (6): 319-321.

The case of a 13-year-old girl given permission by the Family Court of Australia to begin a sex-change process involves complex issues. Nevertheless, the ethical justification for the decision is not complicated. In this case, it can be argued that the net benefit eclipses concerns about competence, autonomy and the appropriateness of the intervention. The debate this case generated in the media reminds us that one of the essential tasks in ethics debates is to get our facts straight.

Merle P Spriggs, BA, MBioeth, PhD, Ethicist; Honorary Fellow, Centre for the Study of Health and Society, University of Melbourne; and Supervising Examiner, Centre for Human Bioethics, Monash University
Ethics Unit, Murdoch Children’s Research Institute, Royal Children’s Hospital, Parkville, VIC.
Article References: 
Reference Text: 
Re Alex: hormonal treatment for gender identity dysphoria [2004] FamCA 297.
Reference Order: 
1
PubMed ID: 
Reference Text: 
Family Court of Australia. Court permits hormone therapy treatment for “Alex”. Media release, 13 April 2004. Available at: www.familycourt.gov.au/media/html/realex.html (accessed Jul 2004).
Reference Order: 
2
PubMed ID: 
Reference Text: 
Family Court of Australia. Re Alex: hormonal treatment for gender identity dysphoria [2004] FamCA 297 [summary]. Available at: www.familycourt.gov.au/judge/2004/html/realex.html (accessed Jul 2004).
Reference Order: 
3
PubMed ID: 
Reference Text: 
Rogers W, Draper H. Confidentiality and the ethics of medical ethics. J Med Ethics 2003; 29: 220-224.
Reference Order: 
4
PubMed ID: 
Reference Text: 
Cohen-Kettenis P, Pfafflin F. Transgenderism and intersexuality in childhood and adolescence: making choices. California: Sage Publications, 2003. (Developmental clinical psychology and psychiatry, Vol. 46.)
Reference Order: 
5
PubMed ID: 
Reference Text: 
Royal College of Psychiatrists. Gender identity disorders in children and adolescents: guidance for management. Council report CR63. London: RCP, 1998.
Reference Order: 
6
PubMed ID: 
Reference Text: 
Department of Health and Community Services v JWB and SMB (Marion’s case) (1992) 175 CLR 218.
Reference Order: 
7
PubMed ID: 
Reference Text: 
Family Court of Australia. Special medical procedures. 2004. Available at: www.familycourt.gov.au/html/medical_procedures.html (accessed Jul 2004).
Reference Order: 
8
PubMed ID: 
Reference Text: 
Kelly J. Court backs sex swap for girl, 13. Herald Sun (Melbourne) 2004 Apr 14; News section: 3.
Reference Order: 
9
PubMed ID: 
Reference Text: 
Gough D. Court allows girl’s bid to become boy. The Age (Melbourne) 2004 Apr 14; News section: 1.
Reference Order: 
10
PubMed ID: 
Reference Text: 
Symons E. Teenager “needs help not surgery”. The Australian 2004 Apr 15; News section: 3.
Reference Order: 
11
PubMed ID: 
Reference Text: 
Goddard C, Tucci J. When too much intervention may be the problem. The Age (Melbourne) 2004 May 4; Opinion: 11.
Reference Order: 
12
PubMed ID: 
Reference Text: 
Bolt A. A girl betrayed. Herald Sun (Melbourne) 2004 Apr 16; Opinion: 21.
Reference Order: 
13
PubMed ID: 
Reference Text: 
Kelly J. Sex-swap girl urged to rethink. Herald Sun (Melbourne) 2004 Apr 15; News section: 9.
Reference Order: 
14
PubMed ID: 
Reference Text: 
Sex change decision sparks debate. Sydney Morning Herald 2004 Apr 14. Available at: www.smh.com.au/articles/2004/04/14/1081838789145.html (accessed Jul 2004).
Reference Order: 
15
PubMed ID: 
Reference Text: 
Child gender change takes the law too far. The Australian 2004 Apr 15; Editorial: 12.
Reference Order: 
16
PubMed ID: 
Reference Text: 
The court, a child and a change of gender. The Age (Melbourne) 2004 Apr 15; Editorial: 12.
Reference Order: 
17
PubMed ID: 
Reference Text: 
Gregory J, Taylor C. Judge hits outdated gender laws. Courier-Mail (Brisbane) 2004 Apr 15: News section: 3.
Reference Order: 
18
PubMed ID: 
Reference Text: 
Zucker KJ. Gender identity disorder. In: Rutter M, Taylor E, editors. Child and adolescent psychiatry. Cambridge: Blackwell; 2002: 737-753.
Reference Order: 
19
PubMed ID: 
Reference Text: 
Meyer W, Bockting W, Cohen-Kettenis P, et al. The standards of care for gender identity disorders – sixth version. International Journal of Transgenderism 2001; 5(1). Available at: www.symposion.com/ijt/soc_2001/index.htm (accessed Aug 2004).
Reference Order: 
20
PubMed ID: 
Reference Text: 
Beauchamp T, Childress J. Principles of biomedical ethics. 5th ed. New York: Oxford University Press, 2001.
Reference Order: 
21
PubMed ID: 
Reference Text: 
Buchanan AE, Brock DW. Deciding for others: the ethics of surrogate decision making. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press, 1990.
Reference Order: 
22
PubMed ID: 

The full contents of this page are only available to subscribers.