Volume 178 - Issue 5

Management of acute adult sexual assault

Authors:  Jacqueline K Mein,*†, Cheryn M Palmer,†, Meon Carol Shand,*, David J Templeton,*†, Vanita Parek,*, Margaret Mobbs,*†, Kay Haig,*, Sarah E Huffam and Lyndall Young

Med J Aust 2003; 178 (5): 226-230. || doi: 10.5694/j.1326-5377.2003.tb05168.x
Published online: 3 March 2003

1: Clinical definition of adult male or female sexual assault6

a) Penetration of the vulva (beyond the labia majora) and/or anus by a penis or any other object, and/or penetration of the mouth by a penis

and

b) Without the consent of the person

A United States meta-analysis estimates that 13% of women and 3% of men worldwide may be raped at some time during their lives.1 New Zealand and Australian data suggest similar findings,2 ranging from 4.6%3 to 11.3%4 in different populations. Although reliable incidence figures are impossible to estimate given considerable barriers to reporting,4 sexual assault presents, often unexpectedly, to healthcare providers working in diverse areas.5 Practitioners may feel sexual assault is challenging to manage, but it is simple when broken into components — emotional, physical and medicolegal. Here we provide a framework for non-forensic medical management of recent adult sexual assault. Box 1 gives a clinical definition, broader than that used in Australian law.

Disclosure

Victims are reluctant to disclose that they have been sexually assaulted for many reasons, including fear of police, not being believed or retribution, as well as guilt and a desire to forget the event. However, they may present for medical care because of concerns about pregnancy, sexually transmissible infections (STIs), or injury.7 They may present with post-traumatic stress, depressive symptoms,8 alcohol or substance misuse or self-harm.9 To encourage disclosure it is necessary to ask directly about the possibility of sexual assault.

Most victims of reported sexual assault are women; men are also assaulted, but are less likely to disclose.10 Although people of all ages and cultures are vulnerable, prisoners,11 adolescents, injecting drug users, the elderly, those who experienced sexual assault as children, and people with mental or physical disabilities are at particular risk.12 A recent survey of sexual health clinics in Australia and New Zealand found that staff were more likely to ask about sexual assault if their workplace encouraged it.13 It also identified patient distress, time constraints and lack of expertise in managing a positive response as barriers to asking. However, nearly all of the patients in the survey reported they did not mind being asked about sexual assault.13 A recent Sydney survey linked sexual assault firmly with the words "forced" and "non-consent" (L Dayan, Director, Sexual Health Services, Royal North Shore Hospital, Sydney, personal communication). Suggestions on how to ask about sexual assault are shown in Box 2.

Management

When responding to a disclosure of sexual assault, it is important to:

Further action is defined by whether the victim decides to make a formal complaint. Most jurisdictions require that the first person who hears an allegation of sexual assault must give evidence if the complaint comes to trial, so document the exact words used, even if the victim is referred for forensic management.

Investigation

Tests for forensic purposes, sexually transmissible infections and pregnancy are performed according to need. If a woman is being transferred to a sexual assault service for forensic assessment after unprotected vaginal rape, the initial dose of the emergency contraceptive pill should be given first.

Forensics: If the victim is willing for the police to be involved, he or she should be referred immediately to an expert sexual assault service for forensic assessment (a list is provided at the end of this article). If a victim is undecided about reporting the assault, forensic specimens may be stored while a formal complaint is considered.

DNA evidence left on or in the body of a victim, particularly in moist areas, degrades quickly over 2–10 days.16,17 Therefore, forensic assessments need to be made as soon as possible, but within 10 days of an assault. If proceeding to a forensic assessment, advise victims not to shower (or to clean their teeth or rinse their mouths if the assault was oral), and ensure all clothes worn during the assault remain unwashed. As DNA evidence degrades quickly if moist, ask the victim to store underclothes worn during the assault in paper (not plastic) bags.

In remote areas, timely expert forensic assessment is difficult. Most sexual assault services provide 24-hour phone assistance by doctors experienced in forensic medicine to discuss assessment. After discussion, some practitioners in remote areas may decide to perform forensic assessments, but this can be a difficult decision, as the practitioner may later be required to give evidence in court. Sexual assault services in Western Australia suggest a compromise solution that entails wiping the victim's vulval and/or anal area with sterile gauze, air-drying it, putting it into a labelled sterile container and handing it directly to local police for forensic testing before the victim's transfer for forensic assessment.18

Pregnancy risk: Depending on the victim's contraceptive and menstrual history, testing urine or serum might be useful to direct therapy and follow-up.

Sexually transmissible infections: Baseline testing of sexual assault victims for sexually transmissible infections (STIs) in Australia varies with local clinical practice. In some Queensland sexual assault services serum is held in case STI testing is requested or required later (M Mobbs, Visiting Medical Officer, Brisbane Sexual Assault Service, personal communication). Baseline testing usually occurs in sexual assault services and communities with known high STI risk. As victims of sexual assault have higher rates of STIs compared with the general population,19 opportunistic screening is worthwhile if follow-up can be organised. Under Australian law, a rape victim's sexual history is inadmissible in court and this includes any history of STI. Thus, possible court prejudice is not a reason to withhold testing. See Box 4 for screening test recommendations. Note PAP smears are not generally included.

The HIV/STI status of the perpetrator is usually unknown. In the absence of any better indicators, ethnicity or culture is sometimes used as a proxy for HIV/STI risk. The purpose of this judgement of risk is not to vilify minority groups, but to assess the victim's risk of infection on the basis of often very limited information about the perpetrator. Treatment recommendations alter for victims assaulted by anyone thought to be from a high risk group (see Box 5).

The National HIV/AIDS Strategy states that community prevalence of HIV and STIs is higher in certain groups, including African and South-East Asian people, homosexual and bisexual men, and injecting drug users.21 Rates of STI are high in northern Australia, including in Indigenous communities,22,23 while HIV prevalence is higher in inner Sydney than elsewhere in Australia.24 As the risk of sexual transmission of hepatitis C virus (HCV) is low,25 tests are usually only performed in high risk situations (eg, assault with bleeding injuries, or assault by known HCV-positive assailant).

Although the risk of HIV from one act of unprotected intercourse is very small, if the assault was penetrative unprotected vaginal or anal rape victims should be advised to use condoms until follow-up testing at three months. Most victims are concerned about HIV risk, even though they may not admit it.7 The vast majority will not require HIV prophylaxis, as the risk of transmission from an HIV-positive assailant is very small (see Box 6) and the chance that the perpetrator was HIV positive far smaller.

Specific therapy
Counselling

Sexual assault is a frightening and sometimes life-threatening violent experience and counselling should be offered to all. Even if victims do not wish to attend counselling, it is important that they know where they can go for help, as memories can surface later (eg, at first childbirth) and can impair future functioning.27 Family and partners may also require counselling, or referral may be needed for domestic violence issues. Safety after rape can require moving house if the rapist lives with the victim, or knows where he or she lives. Emergency housing may be needed, as may other forms of immediate support, such as certificates for absence from work and support letters for school.

Emergency contraception

If the assault was unprotected vaginal rape, or if there was any possibility that this occurred (eg, victim lost consciousness, was intoxicated or is unsure), then emergency contraception can be offered up to three, and possibly up to five, days after the assault.28 The progesterone-only regimen is recommended over the Yuzpe method because it is more effective with fewer side effects. Give the first dose as soon as possible, as efficacy halves with each 12-hour interval after the assault.29

Progesterone-only method: 750 μg levonorgestrel orally; repeat 12 hours later. A 750 μg tablet (Postinor-2, Schering Pty Ltd) is now available in Australia, or 25 30-μg tablets (Microval, Wyeth Australia Pty Ltd; or Microlut, Schering Pty Ltd) can be used for each dose.

Yuzpe method: 100 μg oestradiol orally; repeat 12 hours later. Use two 50-μg oestrogen-containing combined oral contraceptive tablets for each dose. This regimen should only be used if the progesterone-only method is not tolerated or unavailable.

Sexually transmitted infections

For unprotected vaginal or anal assault, victims are offered single-dose prophylaxis with azithromycin for chlamydia (see Box 5). They are also offered prophylactic hepatitis B vaccine if likely to be non-immune.

Treatment varies according to community prevalence of STIs and perceived individual risk. In tropical areas of Australia, or if the perpetrator is considered at high risk of being infected, prophylaxis may also be added for gonorrhoea, occasionally syphilis, and passive vaccination with hepatitis B immune globulin30 may also be given if the recipient is not immune.

For victims at high risk of having acquired HIV infection (eg, rape by someone from an area of high HIV prevalence), urgent phone consultation with an infectious diseases or sexual health physician about post-exposure prophylaxis for HIV is recommended (see Box 7).

Review

It is notoriously difficult to get victims back for follow-up.31 The review program suggested (Box 4) is a guide only and should be tailored to suit individual patients. At the very least, an appointment is recommended at two weeks for discussing test results, further testing (eg, pregnancy), review of coping, and assessment of healing. Follow-up serological tests should be performed at three months for HIV, hepatitis B virus and syphilis. Reviews are a good opportunity to assess the need for counselling if this has not already been organised.

Before the victim leaves, give written instructions for taking medications and review appointments, and include counselling service phone numbers. Victims may be intoxicated, shocked or tired and are unlikely to remember verbal medical instructions.

Summary

Management of acute adult sexual assault may appear daunting, but when viewed in its component parts is not difficult. Review by a sympathetic, non-judgemental practitioner can play an important role in helping victims regain control of their lives.

Australia-wide resources

Websites

Comprehensive listing of services available in Australia and New Zealand, both updated 2002.

Australia: http://www.acshp.org.au/sexual_health/assault.htm New Zealand: http://www.dsac.org.nz

Major State and Territory resource phone numbers for sexual assault services

The following lists only one major service for each Australian State or Territory, as these services will refer to other local services as appropriate.


Australian Capital Territory

Forensic and Medical Sexual Assault Care
BH 02 6244 2184/3058

Canberra Rape Crisis Centre
02 6247 2525*

Queensland

Brisbane Sexual Assault Service
07 3636 5206*
Toll free 1800 010 120*

Government Medical Office (forensic regional services)
07 3405 5755*

Tasmania

Sexual Assault Support Service Hobart
BH 03 6231 1811
AH 03 6231 1817*

New South Wales

Eastern and Central Sexual Assault Service, Sydney
BH 02 9515 3680
AH 02 9515 6111*
(ask for sexual assault counsellor)

South Australia

http://www.wch.sa.gov.au/yarrow/index.html
Yarrow Place, Adelaide
BH 08 8226 8777
AH 08 8226 8787* Toll free 1800 817 421

Western Australia

Sexual Assault Resource Centre, Perth
08 9340 1820/1830
08 9340 1828* Toll free 1800 199 888*

Northern Territory

Darwin Sexual Assault Referral Centre
08 8922 7156*

Victoria

Victorian Institute of Forensic Medicine
03 9684 4444*


* Denotes 24-hour contact number.

6: HIV transmission risk per unprotected act of intercourse with an HIV-positive person*26

Type of intercourse

Risk per 1000 acts


Receptive anal

1–30 in 1000

Receptive vaginal

1–2 in 1000

Insertive vaginal

1 in 1000

Insertive anal

3–9 in 1000


* For comparison, the risk of acquiring HIV infection from using a shared HIV-contaminated needle is 667 in 1000, and from a needlestick injury to healthcare workers is about 4–8 in 1000.


Authors


Competing interests


References