Issues
Volume 218 Issue 5
Editor’s choice
Health requires a whole‐of‐government, and ultimately whole‐of‐system, approach
For anyone who lived in Australia in the summer of 2019–2020, the cover of this issue showing Parliament House shrouded in smoke is a stark reminder of that terrible black summer. Like many others, I first became only too familiar with the properties of masks then, and I have vivid memories of my daughter returning to a smoky Canberra after the Christmas holidays with boxes of masks to protect against the particles in the air, not just for her but for friends who could not buy them locally. Only a few months later, we would of course become only too familiar with the properties of other kinds of masks. But as the COVID‐19 pandemic continues, the perspective by Heenan and colleagues reminds us that the health risks of COVID‐19, enormous as they are, are dwarfed by the risks of climate change, not just to human health but to the health of the planet (doi: 10.5694/mja2.51857). Australia does not have a good record in taking this risk seriously at a political level except at times of immediate crisis. Heenan and colleagues note that “Australia's engagement with the health impacts of climate change relates primarily to disaster response”, which is probably explained by a lack of high level strategy — “Australia makes no reference to health in its contribution pledge to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change, and to date is one of few countries lacking a national health and climate change strategy”. Without a strategy, action is unlikely. The MJA–Lancet Countdown was established in 2017, and produced its first national assessment in 2018 and annual updates thereafter in 2019, 2020, 2021 and 2022. The 2022 title was clear: “Australia unprepared and paying the price”. We are now nine months into the term of a new government that has indicated that it will prioritise climate action, but we must hold them to account. Heenan and colleagues state the challenge clearly: “Overcoming current obstacles to political engagement is vital to Australia's health and wellbeing, and is critically time‐sensitive given the accelerating pace of climate change and fast‐approaching critical thresholds”. The perspective by Dudgeon and colleagues highlights another critical challenge that the Australian health sector must address: “that interpersonal and structural racism contributes to Indigenous people's physical and mental ill health and reduces access to health services” (doi: 10.5694/mja2.51862). Governments and legislation have a role here too. But as Dudgeon and colleagues point out, legislation is not enough: “Although most signatory governments [to the International Convention of the Elimination of All Forms of Racial Discrimination], including Australia, denounce racism, most allow racism in its different forms due to inadequate legal mechanisms, poor definitions of racism, a lack of moral and political will, and a lack of accurate data revealing the inequalities in accessing services experienced by Indigenous people”. Dudgeon and colleagues highlight a role for public awareness campaigns such as “Racism. It stops with me” but note that ultimately, “The cultural safety frameworks established to support mainstream services to create culturally safe environments, services and practices need recourse to a legislative framework as well”. The narrative that health is not purely a personal issue could not be more clearly articulated by these articles; health requires a whole‐of‐government, and ultimately whole‐of‐system, approach.
Virginia Barbour
Perspectives
Australia's political engagement on health and climate change: the MJA–Lancet Countdown indicator and implications for the future
Urgent and sustained political engagement is needed to address the health impacts of climate change
Maddie Heenan · Lucie Rychetnik · Elly Howse · Paul J Beggs · Tarun S Weeramanthri · Fiona Armstrong · Ying Zhang
Mitigating the impacts of racism on Indigenous wellbeing through human rights, legislative and health policy reform
System-wide racial discrimination and inequitable access to justice impedes Indigenous rights to health and wellbeing
Pat Dudgeon · Abigail Bray · Roz Walker
Mpox outbreak in 2022: implications for blood component and donor human milk safety in Australia
Ongoing surveillance for emerging and re- emerging infectious diseases is essential to assess their impact on blood and breastmilk safety
Philip Kiely · Veronica C Hoad · Claire E Styles · Iain B Gosbell
More and better clinical trials in health care: focusing on people, not just systems and processes
Clinical trials improve care and save lives but need more clinician and consumer engagement
Angela L Todd · Don Nutbeam
Medical education
Non‐typhoidal Salmonella myocarditis: a disease manifestation not to be missed
A 19-year-old man presented with a two-day history of intermittent pleuritic chest pain and associated fevers
Nilanthy Vigneswaran · Elaine Cheong
Editorial
Coronary calcium scoring for guiding lipid‐lowering therapy is cost‐effective: time to remove barriers to its use
Widespread, inexpensive CAC scanning could economically expand access to statin therapy to those at highest risk
Erfan Tasdighi · Michael J Blaha
Research
The cost‐effectiveness of coronary calcium score‐guided statin therapy initiation for Australians with family histories of premature coronary artery disease
Expanding eligibility for statin therapy should selectively target people with subclinical atherosclerosis rather than simply lowering treatment thresholds
Prasanna Venkataraman · Amanda L Neil · Geoffrey K Mitchell · Tony Stanton · Stephen Nicholls · Andrew M Tonkin · Gerald F Watts · Thomas H Marwick
Infectious syphilis in women and heterosexual men in major Australian cities: sentinel surveillance data, 2011–2019
People who attend reproductive health or alcohol and drug services should be routinely screened for syphilis
Allison Carter · Hamish McManus · James S Ward · Tobias Vickers · Jason Asselin · Greta Baillie · Eric PF Chow · Marcus Y Chen · Christopher K Fairley · Christopher Bourne · Anna McNulty · Phillip Read · Kevin Heath · Nathan Ryder · Jenny McCloskey · Christopher Carmody · Heather McCormack · Kate Alexander · Dawn Casey · Mark Stoove · Margaret E Hellard · Basil Donovan · Rebecca J Guy
Research letter
Direct‐acting antiviral treatments in Australia for children with chronic hepatitis C virus infection
The benefits of DAA therapy for children with HCV infection are now attainable in Australia in normal practice
Jessica A Eldredge · Michael O Stormon · Julia E Clark · Scott Nightingale · Brendan McMullan · Brooke Andersen · Christina Travers · Winita Hardikar
Consensus statement
Consensus recommendations on the management of hepatitis C in Australia's prisons
Prison settings are risk environments for HCV transmission and should therefore be a priority setting for harm reduction and clinical and educational interventions
Rebecca J Winter · Yumi Sheehan · Timothy Papaluca · Graeme A Macdonald · Joy Rowland · Anton Colman · Mark Stoove · Andrew R Lloyd · Alexander J Thompson
Letters
Historic breakthrough for public access defibrillation in Australia
To the Editor: Over 26000 Australians experience out‐of‐hospital cardiac arrest (OHCA) each year, with almost nine in ten of these patients not surviving to hospital discharge or 30 days.1 Although it is known that swift defibrillation increases the possibility of patient survival in these situations, and that initial defibrillation by first responders (regardless of training) is associated with greater survival than initial defibrillation by emergency medical services,2 in Australia, less than 2% of OHCA cases receive defibrillation by a bystander.1 It is likely that this is driven by the limits to publicly accessible automated external defibrillators (AEDs) in Australian communities.3 On 30 November 2022, South Australia took a major step to deal with this problem and reduce death from OHCA. The SA Parliament passed the Automated External Defibrillators (Public Access) Bill 2022,4 making SA the first state or territory in Australia, and one of few in the world, to mandate the public provision of AEDs. The legislation, introduced by Member of the Legislative Council, the Hon Frank Pangallo of the SA‐BEST party, had bipartisan political support and backing from various organisations, and follows a recent public health campaign to install AEDs in Adelaide. The Bill will come into effect for government and public buildings in 2025 and a variety of private buildings in 2026, with awareness campaigns, grant programs, and communication with organisations being the focus of the interim period. The expected cost to the SA government of $7.2 million across four years is weighed against the $2 billion gross domestic product loss that Australia incurs annually as a result of sudden cardiac arrest.5 The health and economic benefits of public access defibrillation to Australian society are large. For the benefit of all Australians, other states and territories should follow the example set by SA and move to implement similar laws mandating the public availability of AEDs in their communities.
Joshua G Kovoor · Gregory J Page · Pramesh Kovoor
Clinician alert: toxigenic diphtheria cases across North Queensland are on the rise
To the Editor: Until recently, detection of locally acquired tox gene carrying diphtheria in Australia was rare. Toxigenic diphtheria had almost disappeared from the Australian landscape, with the widespread uptake of the diphtheria toxoid vaccine. Diphtheria is predominantly caused by toxigenic Corynebacterium diphtheriae and can present as both respiratory and cutaneous diphtheria disease. There have been increasing reports internationally of diphtheria outbreaks primarily in vulnerable migrant populations.1 In Australia, there were 46 diphtheria cases between 1999 and 2019 (eight respiratory diphtheria and 38 cutaneous), with C. diphtheriae accounting for 87% of these cases.2 Since 2020, a genomically linked clone of tox gene carrying diphtheria bacteria has spread across North Queensland. Cases described here are from the Queensland Health's Notifiable Conditions Register. The Townsville Hospital and Health Service Human Research and Ethics Committee provided an ethics exemption (EX/2022/HREC/88895) for this study. Of the 29 linked cases identified between 2020 and 2022, all have had epidemiological links to North Queensland and 23 were notified in 2022. Three of these cases were detected interstate. Clinically, three cases presented with classic diphtheria, four with mild respiratory diphtheria, and 22 with cutaneous diphtheria. The median age was 21 years (range, 2–59 years). Of the 29 cases, 34% (10/29) were aged 11–20 years and 45% (13/29) were older than 20 years. Further, 38% of cases (11/29) were fully vaccinated, 48% (14/29) were partially vaccinated and 10% (3/29), including two of the classic diphtheria cases, were unvaccinated for their age according to the National Immunisation Program Schedule. All were acquired in Australia, and 86% of patients (25/29) identified as Aboriginal and/or Torres Strait Islander. Isolates in the cluster are closely genomically linked, with between zero and 20 single nucleotide polymorphism differences found on whole genome sequencing. All cases were managed with penicillin or azithromycin, vaccination, and diphtheria antitoxin administered when deemed appropriate by infectious disease physician assessment. Azithromycin was given in most cases, as higher minimum inhibitory concentrations to penicillin have been observed with this clone. Household contacts were screened for symptoms, administered chemoprophylaxis with penicillin or azithromycin, and offered a diphtheria‐containing vaccine if due. A North Queensland public health working group has recently been established to develop a consensus on further public health management. This diphtheria outbreak, almost exclusively in Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander communities, highlights the continuing impact of social determinants on disease in vulnerable populations. We recommend clinicians be aware of these cases and consider diphtheria among their differentials in patients from, or who recently travelled to, North Queensland. Classic diphtheria is characterised by a sore throat, fever, and membrane on the back of the throat, which may cause difficulty in breathing and swallowing. Cutaneous diphtheria usually presents as a non‐healing ulcerative lesion.2 The toxoid vaccine protects against the toxin effects rather than the infection itself. Unvaccinated individuals are therefore at highest risk of severe disease, including classic diphtheria, myocarditis, and neuropathies. Vaccination remains imperative and timely vaccinations are essential. The National Immunisation Program Schedule currently recommends a diphtheria‐containing vaccine for children at two, four, six and 18 months, and four years, and adolescents at 11–13 years. A diphtheria‐containing vaccine booster is recommended for adults at 50 years.3 Clinicians across the state and nation should be vigilant for future cases.
Allison Hempenstall · Jay Short · Tonia Marquardt · Valmay Fisher · Janice Johnson
Health and society intertwined
Virginia Barbour
“A wolf in sheep's clothing”: when so‐called placebo interventions are not what they seem
Jessica Stanhope · Amy Salter · Philip Weinstein
Assessing preparedness for Alzheimer disease‐modifying therapies in Australasian health care systems
Amy Brodtmann · David Darby · Carly Oboudiyat · Colin J Mahoney · Campbell Le Heron · Peter K Panegyres · Bruce Brew
Diseases old and new
Virginia Barbour
Bridging the gap in skin cancer research for Australians with skin of colour
Ayooluwatomiwa I Oloruntoba · Michelle Rodrigues
Long telephone consultations for GP appointments: evidence versus policy
Feby Savira · Eva Yuen · Anna Ugalde · Katherine Graham · Anna Peeters
Recent advances in critical care
Yasmine Ali Abdelhamid · Adam Deane · Rinaldo Bellomo