Connect
MJA
MJA

Research

John Orchard, Hugh Seward, Jeanne McGivern and Simon Hood
Med J Aust 1999; 170 (7): 304-306.
Published online: 5 April 1999

Research

Rainfall, evaporation and the risk of non-contact anterior cruciate ligament injury in the Australian Football League

John Orchard, Hugh Seward, Jeanne McGivern and Simon Hood

MJA 1999; 170: 304-306

 


Abstract Objective: To determine if weather conditions affect the risk of anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) tear in Australian Football.
Design: Prospective observational analytic study of football matches.
Setting: The Australian Football League (AFL), a professional competition.
Participants: All players in 2280 matches from 1992-1998.
Main outcome measures: Surgically-proven ACL injury, not involving a direct contact mechanism, during a match; rainfall; water evaporation.
Results: 59 ACL injuries not involving direct contact occurred during the study period, more commonly in cities north of Melbourne (χ2 = 17.0; df = 1; P < 0.001). Senior grade matches (relative risk [RR], 3.03; 95% confidence interval [CI], 1.52-6.03), high water evaporation in the month before the match (RR, 2.80; 95% CI, 1.53-5.10) and low rainfall in the year before the match (RR, 1.93; 95% CI, 1.12-3.34) were significantly associated with these injuries.
Conclusion: Low water evaporation and high rainfall significantly lower the risk of ACL injuries in AFL footballers. The likely mechanism is a softening of the ground, which lowers shoe-surface traction. Consistent extra watering and covering of grounds during periods of high water evaporation may lower the rate of ACL injuries.


Introduction Anterior cruciate ligament (ACL) injuries of the knee are the most costly injuries in football at both professional and amateur levels. Of the commonly occurring injuries, they are the most devastating for the player, as they usually require reconstruction and long term rehabilitation in order to retain normal knee function.

In the Australian Football League (AFL), ACL injuries account for 12% of all missed playing time,1 which costs the competition over $1 million annually in injury payments alone. The rate of ACL injury in the AFL competition has increased over recent years.2

The exact numbers and costs of ACL injuries in amateur football are unknown. One report that tried to estimate the cost of sports injuries in Australia3 suggested that the cost of ACL injuries in all grades and codes of football was at least 10% of the nation's entire bill for sports injuries. It estimated 5000 football-related ACL injuries in Australia annually, directly costing $5000 each (not including lost work time and the increased susceptibility to later knee problems caused by these injuries).4

Recent studies have noted that there have been relatively more ACL injuries in the early months of the AFL season, in non-Victorian games, and in recent seasons of dry weather.2,5 Our aim was to examine the strength of the relationship of weather conditions to ACL injury.


Methods We studied 2280 matches (all AFL home and away season, finals, reserve grade and Ansett Cup matches which occurred from 1992-1998 in the cities of Adelaide, Brisbane, Canberra, Darwin, Geelong, Hobart, Melbourne, Perth and Sydney), involving 2239 individual players. Approximately 75% of the matches were held in Melbourne, 5% to the south (Geelong and Hobart) and the remaining 20% in the northern cities.

The occurrence of ACL injuries was determined by an ongoing injury surveillance program, which has attempted to determine the cause of every game missed through injury of listed players. The accuracy of this survey in determining the cause of missed games reached 100% in 1997, and has been greater than 90% in every year.1 In addition, a separate register for ACL injuries is held by the AFL. ACL injuries in the AFL are managed surgically and have the diagnosis proven at the time of simultaneous arthroscopy and reconstruction.

The mechanism of injury was recorded by team doctors and divided into the categories of direct contact (where the player's knee or leg was contacted by another player) and no direct contact (which was subdivided into indirect contact and no contact).

Daily weather variables were measured prospectively (but obtained by us retrospectively) by the Bureau of Meteorology at central locations in each city studied. No differentiation was made between rainfall in the differing suburbs of any city, except for Waverley Park (30 km from the centre of Melbourne), for which rainfall data were taken from the nearest centre (Moorabbin). Maximum and minimum temperature of the day of the match, rainfall, water evaporation and maximum wind gust were the raw weather variables considered. Water evaporation is a meteorological variable measuring the change of surface water into water vapour -- it is affected by temperature, sunshine, humidity and wind.6 Composite rainfall and evaporation variables were created (measuring the totals for the previous 7, 14, 28, 90 and 365 days), which were considered to have had potentially more effect on ground conditions than the weather only on the day of the match.

Statistical analysis was carried out using SPSS for Windows.7 Chi-square and t tests (after variances assessed using Levene's test) were performed in the initial stages of the analysis. Multivariate analysis was performed using a logistic regression forward stepwise technique, with a significance of 0.05 to enter the equation. Continuous variables in the logistic regression were redefined into binary variables based on group median values, to calculate risk ratios adjusted for confounding.


Results There were 111 surgically-proven ACL tears recorded in AFL players during the study period. Excluded from analysis were 33 injuries that did not occur in AFL matches (13 occurred during practice matches, 14 during training sessions and six in other league matches). Of the 78 injuries in AFL matches, 19 occurred through direct contact, 15 involved indirect contact (to another part of the body than the leg) and there was no contact involved in 44.

Overall, games played north of Melbourne had a significantly higher rate of all ACL injuries (Table). However, injuries involving contact were not significantly associated with being north of Melbourne, although indirect-contact injuries were more common north of Melbourne.

For the 59 ACL injuries that did not involve direct contact, the most predictive rainfall and evaporation variables for ACL injury were 28-day evaporation (t = - 3.8; df = 59; P < 0.001) and 365-day rainfall (t = 1.34; df = 2278; P = 0.18). Other significant associations were higher grade of match (t = 4.8; df = 59; P < 0.001), lower minimum temperature (t = - 3.7; df = 59; P < 0.001) and month (fewer injuries in winter) (t = 3.1; df = 2278; P = 0.002). Non-significant associations were night games (t = - 1.7; df = 59; P = 0.09) and wind speed (t = - 0.18; df = 2278; P = 0.86).

Although 365-day rainfall was not significant according to the t test, this variable was entered into the logistic regression equation as significant. This is because of the confounding effect of evaporation -- venues with high evaporation also tend to have high rainfall. In a multivariate analysis including evaporation, variance in rainfall is more significant than when rainfall is considered alone. In contrast, night games and minimum temperature had less significance in the logistic regression model.

All variables were considered in a logistic regression model with match grade, 28-day evaporation and 365-day rainfall qualifying to be entered into the equation. Senior grade matches had a 3.03-times risk of injury compared with reserve grade matches (95% confidence interval [CI], 1.52-6.03). Matches with high evaporation in the previous 28 days (> 48 mm) had a 2.80-times greater risk of injury (95% CI, 1.52-6.03). Matches with low rainfall (< 449 mm) in the previous year had a 1.93-times greater risk of injury (95% CI, 1.12-6.03).

Figures 1 and 2 illustrate a strong association between the rate of ACL injuries not involving direct contact and 28-day evaporation and 365-day rainfall, respectively, for the matches in Melbourne over the study period.


Discussion Risk factors for injury can be divided into intrinsic (personal) and extrinsic (environmental). Two intrinsic risk factors for ACL injury have been established: female sex8-11 and narrowed intercondylar notch.12-14 In a recent study, both factors were prospectively followed, and it was concluded that narrow intercondylar notch accounts for the increased number of ACL tears seen in female athletes. At this stage, narrowed intercondylar notch is not a reversible risk factor, but it can be measured at the time of injury and used to counsel athletes on the risk of recurrence, particularly to the contralateral knee.

The most promising extrinsic risk factors postulated relate to the shoe-surface interface. It has been hypothesised for many years that increasing traction between a football boot and the playing surface would cause an increase in the rate of knee injuries.15 A recent study showed that American football boots, with a greater number of cleats and higher torsional resistance, were prospectively associated with an increased number of ACL injuries.16

Our results show that high water evaporation in the month before and low rainfall in the year before an AFL match confer an increased risk of ACL injury. This relationship is strong for most injuries not involving contact, but may not apply when the mechanism of injury involves a direct blow to the knee. The mechanism of this association is almost certainly through ground-related factors (either soil moisture content or amount and/or quality of grass). Increased speed of the game on dry grounds may also be relevant. These results are in keeping with the theory that excessive shoe-surface traction is a risk factor for ACL injury. Friction and torsional resistance from football boots has been shown to be higher in dry conditions on natural grass compared with wet conditions.17 In a recent review of non-contact ACL injuries in American Football, it was noted that almost all injuries on natural grass occurred in dry conditions,18 but that review did not measure or control for conditions on days when injury did not occur.

We found that the long term effects of rainfall and water evaporation (over a period of months) are more relevant than the amount of rainfall and evaporation on the day or in the days leading up to a match.

Further studies are required to determine the exact mechanism by which this relationship occurs and what the effects of intervention would be. The AFL has embarked on a study, beginning with the 1998 season, where matches have ground hardness readings taken with a Penetrometer, a device used in horse racing to measure track hardness. Penetrometer results are reliable and correlate with the speed of races.19 The preliminary results of the AFL study confirm that low rainfall and high evaporation are associated with hard (low) Penetrometer readings (< 4.7 cm).20

We did not study differences between ground conditions in coastal and inland locations, as (except for Canberra) all the major AFL venues are currently in coastal cities. Further study could include inland cities, which may experience different ground conditions due to much colder and drier winters.

Irrespective of their mechanism of action, the effects of high water evaporation and low rainfall could be reversed on football grounds by consistently watering grounds during times of lower rainfall and covering them during times of increased sunshine. If grounds were prepared in this way to simulate the ground conditions typically experienced in a Melbourne winter, the number of ACL injuries would almost certainly be reduced. This is unlikely to lead to an increase in injuries of other types, as overall injury rates are consistently higher outside Victoria than in Victoria.1,5 In rugby league in the United Kingdom, injury rates increased across the board when the season was changed from winter to summer,21,22 suggesting harder grounds may be a universal risk factor for football injuries.

In AFL, the main competing concern would be whether games played on consistently softer grounds would be a lesser spectacle for the attending and television public. In amateur football, similar reductions in ACL injuries could probably be achieved, without the standard of spectacle being an issue. The cost of manipulating ground conditions might seem initially prohibitive in this environment, but when the massive cost of ACL injury is considered, great overall savings could be made.

In conclusion, low water evaporation and high rainfall significantly lower the risk of non-contact ACL injuries in AFL footballers. The mechanism is likely to be a softer surface, with lower shoe-surface traction and consequently less force transferred to the knee in movements such as pivoting. Consistent extra watering and covering of grounds during times of high water evaporation (sunny, windy periods with no rain) is likely to lower the rate of these devastating and costly injuries.


Acknowledgement The Australian Football League funds the AFL Injury Surveillance System from which data for this study were derived.


References
  1. Orchard J, Wood T, Seward H. AFL injury report 1997. Football Record 1998; 87: 54-61.
  2. Seward H. Can ACL injuries be prevented? In: Australian Conference of Science and Medicine in Sport. Canberra: Sports Medicine Australia, 1997.
  3. Egger G. Sports injuries in Australia: causes, costs and prevention. Sydney: National Better Health Program, 1990.
  4. Deacon A, Bennell K, Kiss ZS, et al. Osteoarthritis of the knee in retired, elite Australian Rules footballers. Med J Aust 1997; 166: 187-190.
  5. Orchard J, Seward H, Garlick D. Ground conditions and AFL injuries. In: Australian Conference of Science and Medicine in Sport. Canberra: Sports Medicine Australia, 1997.
  6. Lewis R, editor. Meteorological glossary. 6th ed. London: HMSO Publications, 1991.
  7. SPSS for Windows [computer program]. Version 6.0. Chicago, Ill: SPSS Inc, 1992.
  8. Arendt E, Dick R. Knee injury patterns among men and women in collegiate basketball and soccer. NCAA data and review of the literature. Am J Sports Med 1995; 23: 694-701.
  9. Ferretti A, Papandrea P, Conteduca F. Knee ligament injuries in volleyball players. Am J Sports Med 1992; 20: 203-207.
  10. Gray J, Taunton J, McKenzie D. A survey of injuries to the anterior cruciate ligament of the knee in female basketball players. Int J Sports Med 1985; 6: 314-316.
  11. Bjordal J, Arnoy F, Hannestad B, Strand T. Epidemiology of anterior cruciate ligament injuries in soccer. Am J Sports Med 1997; 25: 341-345.
  12. Souryal T, Moore H, Evans J. Bilaterality in anterior cruciate ligament injuries: associated intercondylar notch stenosis. Am J Sports Med 1988; 16: 449-454.
  13. Shelbourne K, Facibene W, Hunt J. Radiographic and intraoperative intercondylar notch width measurements in men and women with unilateral and bilateral anterior cruciate ligament tears. Knee Surg Sports Traumatol Arthrosc 1997; 5: 229-233.
  14. Shelbourne K, Davis T, Klootwyk T. The relationship between intercondylar notch width of the femur and the incidence of anterior cruciate ligament tears: a prospective study. Am J Sports Med 1998; 26: 402-408.
  15. Torg J, Quendenfeld T, Landau B. The shoe-surface interface and its relationship to football knee injuries. J Sports Med 1974; 2: 261-269.
  16. Lambson R, Barnhill B, Higgins R. Football cleat design and its effect on anterior cruciate ligament injuries: a three year prospective study. Am J Sports Med 1996; 24: 155-159.
  17. Heidt R, Dormer S, Cawley P, et al. Differences in friction and torsional resistance in athletic shoe-turf surface interfaces. Am J Sports Med 1996; 24: 834-842.
  18. Scranton P, Whitesel J, Powell J, et al. A review of selected noncontact anterior cruciate ligament injuries in the National Football League. Foot Ankle Int 1997; 18: 772-776.
  19. Neylan J, Stubbs A. Assessing racetrack conditions: a review of available devices. Canberra: Rural Industries Research & Development Corporation, 1998.
  20. Orchard J. Measurement of football ground hardness using the racetrack Penetrometer [abstract]. Med Sci Sports Exer. In press, 1999.
  21. Hodgson Phillips L, Standen P, Batt M. Effects of seasonal change in rugby league on the incidence of injury. Br J Sports Med 1998; 32: 144-148.
  22. Gissane C, Jennings D, White J, Cumine A. Injury in summer rugby league football: the experiences of one club. Br J Sports Med 1998; 32: 149-152.

(Received 30 Jul, accepted 28 Nov, 1998)


Authors' details Sports Medicine Unit, University of New South Wales, Kensington, NSW.
John Orchard, MB BS, FACSP, Visiting Fellow.

Australian Football League Medical Officers Association, Melbourne, VIC.
Hugh Seward, MB BS, FACSP, President;
Jeanne McGivern, MB BS, FRCS, Club Medical Officer;
Simon Hood, BAppSci(PE), Research Officer.

Reprints: Dr J Orchard, South Sydney Sports Medicine, 111 Anzac Parade, Kensington, NSW 2033.
Email: johnorchardATmsn.com.au


Make a comment



Journalists are welcome to write news stories based on what they read here, but should acknowledge their source as "an article published on the Internet by The Medical Journal of Australia <http://www.mja.com.au>".
<URL: http://www.mja.com.au/>


Back to text

Back to text

Back to text

Received 13 November 2018, accepted 13 November 2018

  • John Orchard
  • Hugh Seward
  • Jeanne McGivern
  • Simon Hood


Correspondence: 

Author

remove_circle_outline Delete Author
add_circle_outline Add Author

Comment
Do you have any competing interests to declare? *

I/we agree to assign copyright to the Medical Journal of Australia and agree to the Conditions of publication *
I/we agree to the Terms of use of the Medical Journal of Australia *
Email me when people comment on this article

Responses are now closed for this article.