To the Editor: Schofield and Beard,1 discussing demographic shifts among doctors, raise the spectre of “workforce shortages within the next 5 years”.

For decades, Australian health authorities have used various proxy indicators, ranging from Medicare utilisation to World Health Organization and other comparative data, to deny the existence of shortages of doctors. Based on those faulty premises, government policies have aggravated these shortages.

The Oxford English Dictionary defines a “shortage” as “a deficiency”. For many years, there have been deficiencies in services provided by Australia’s doctors, including, among others:

• General practitioners available for house calls and visits to nursing homes; working past 6:00 pm on weeknights or on Saturday mornings; available at nights and on weekends; offering prompt appointments; and being available in locum tenens.

• Specialist initial consultations within a week or two, especially dermatologists, oncologists, neurologists, and, more recently, neurosurgeons and obstetricians.

And all this in our cities and large towns.

The sho rtages of all medical personnel in rural and remote areas has long been obvious. Our current reliance on overseas-trained doctors is undeniable proof of the existence of those shortages.

For more than three decades, the general practice “positions available” advertisements in the medical newspapers have far outnumbered advertisements from doctors seeking GP positions.2

None of the proxy indicators of workforce adequacy, so beloved of politicians and bureaucrats, can rival the plain truth that the supply of doctors, probably in every field of medicine and in every region of Australia, is plainly insufficient to meet reasonable demand, and has been so for at least 30 years.